使用客观指标测量助听器性能
本文首次将助听器言语感知指数(HASPI)和助听器言语质量指数(HASQI)应用于商用助听器,测量三家厂商基础与高端型号在不同信噪比、给声级、验配配置及听力图下的表现。结果显示指标能检测设备与处理设置的显著差异,厂商与处理程度影响显著,基础与高端型号无显著差异。
要点
- HASPI与HASQI可量化商用助听器在可听度与非线性失真上的差异。
- 信噪比、给声级、处理程度对两指标均显著,听力损失仅对HASPI显著。
- 基础与高端助听器型号间未发现显著差异。
核心结论
- HASPI和HASQI可测量商用助听器在设备、处理设置及听力损失调整上的显著差异。
- 基础与高端助听器型号间未发现显著差异。
- 这些指标能预测同时运行的多重处理策略的总效应,包括传统测量可能遗漏的算法交互。
研究设计与样本
- 应用HASPI与HASQI指标测量三家厂商基础与高端商用助听器性能。
- 测试条件包括信噪比、给声级、两种听力图及从线性到激进非线性处理的不同验配配置。
主要发现
- 指标能测量设备与处理设置间的统计学显著差异。
- HASPI和HASQI同时反映可听度与非线性失真。
- 存在预测言语可懂度高但言语质量显著降低的条件。
- 信噪比与给声级均统计学显著;听力损失对HASPI显著但对HASQI不显著;处理程度对两指标均显著。
- 厂商二次模型对HASPI和HASQI效应量大,但基础与高端型号不显著。
临床怎么用
- HASPI和HASQI可用于预测助听器多重处理策略的总效应,辅助验配评估。
- 临床需注意可懂度高时言语质量可能显著降低的情况。
- 基础与高端型号性能差异不显著,选配时需结合其他因素。
局限性
- 本文为将HASPI和HASQI应用于商用助听器的第一步。
- 需进一步研究确定这些测量的临床相关性及成功验配的目标值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The performance of hearing aids is generally characterized by a small set of standardized measurements. The primary goals of these procedures are to measure basic aspects of the hearing aid performance and to ascertain that the device is operating properly. A more general need exists for objective metrics that can predict hearing aid outcomes. Such metrics must consider the interaction of all the signal processing operating in the hearing aid and must do so while also accounting for the hearing loss for which the hearing aid has been prescribed. This article represents a first step in determining the clinical applicability of the hearing aid speech perception index (HASPI) intelligibility and hearing aid speech quality index (HASQI) speech quality metrics. The goals of this article are to demonstrate the feasibility of applying these metrics to commercial hearing aids and to illustrate the anticipated range of measured values and identify implementation concerns that may not be present for conventional measurements. DESIGN: This article uses the HASPI intelligibility and HASQI speech quality metrics to measure the performance of commercial hearing aids. These metrics measure several aspects of the processed signal, including envelope fidelity, modifications of the temporal fine structure, and changes in the long-term frequency response, all in the context of an auditory model that reproduces the salient aspects of the peripheral hearing loss. The metrics are used to measure the performance of basic and premium hearing aids from three different manufacturers. Test conditions include the environmental factors of signal to noise ratio and presentation level, and the fitting configurations were varied to provide different degrees of processing from linear to aggressive nonlinear processing for two different audiograms. RESULTS: The results show that the metrics are capable of measuring statistically significant differences across devices and processing settings. HASPI and HASQI measure both audibility and nonlinear distortion in the devices, and conditions are identified where predicted intelligibility is high but predicted speech quality is substantially reduced. The external signal properties of signal to noise ratio and presentation level are both statistically significant. Hearing loss is significant for HASPI but not for HASQI, and degree of processing is significant for both metrics. A quadratic model for manufacturer showed large effect sizes for HASPI and HASQI, but basic versus premium hearing aid model is not significant. CONCLUSIONS: The results presented in this article represent a first step in applying the HASPI and HASQI metrics to commercial hearing aids. Modern hearing aids often use several different processing strategies operating simultaneously. The proposed metrics provide a way to predict the total effect of this processing, including algorithm interactions that may be missed by conventional measurement procedures. The measurements in this article show significant differences between manufacturers, processing settings, and adjustment for different hearing losses. No significant differences were found between basic and premium hearing aid models. Further research will be needed to determine the clinical relevance of these measurements and to provide target values appropriate for successful fittings.
引用
- Kates JM, Arehart KH, Anderson MC, et al. Using Objective Metrics to Measure Hearing Aid Performance. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29554034. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000574
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。