成人非对称性听力损失人工耳蜗植入者的前瞻性纵向研究:言语识别、声源定位与自评结果
结果显示,术后6个月双模式条件下软声与噪声下言语识别、声源定位及沟通功能自评均较术前日常聆听条件显著改善;双模式优于任一单耳,且多数受试者获得有临床意义的获益。
要点
- 较差耳植入人工耳蜗可显著改善非对称性听力损失成人的可听度与言语识别。
- 术后6个月双模式言语识别、声源定位及自评沟通获益显著,且定位与自评获益不依赖较好耳听力。
- 较好耳纯音平均听阈≤40 dB HL者双模式获益较小但绝对表现更好,噪声朝向人工耳蜗耳时仅56–70 dB HL组获益。
核心结论
- 较差耳植入人工耳蜗是该非对称性听力损失成人群体的有效治疗。
- 术后6个月可听度与言语识别改善明显,声源定位与自评沟通获益显著且与较好耳听力无关。
研究设计与样本
- 测试包括客观与主观沟通测量,时间点为术前及术后6、12个月。
- 术前按日常聆听条件测试:双耳助听器9例、较好耳助听器29例、无助听器9例;术后分别测试各耳及双模式条件。
主要发现
- 双模式条件术后6个月较术前日常聆听条件在软声与噪声下句子得分、声源定位及沟通功能评分显著改善。
- 术后6个月双模式结果显著优于任一单耳;较差耳单独使用人工耳蜗较术前可听度与言语识别显著改善。
- 多数受试者在多数指标上获得有临床意义的获益;年龄较大者双模式噪声下言语识别与定位较差。
- 早期重度至极重度听力损失起病者双模式定位优于晚期起病者;重度至极重度听力损失病程较长者人工耳蜗单独噪声下言语理解较差,安静下无此差异。
- 较好耳纯音平均听阈与双模式所有言语识别指标相关;按较好耳纯音平均听阈分组(≤40 dB HL组19例、41–55 dB HL组14例、56–70 dB HL组14例),各组均有安静与噪声下双模式言语识别获益,但噪声朝向人工耳蜗耳时仅56–70 dB HL组获益。
关键数值与推荐
- 较好耳纯音平均听阈分组:组1≤40 dB HL(n=19)、组2 41–55 dB HL(n=14)、组3 56–70 dB HL(n=14)。
- 所有组均显示双模式言语识别获益(安静与噪声下)及定位与自评沟通改善。
- 噪声朝向人工耳蜗耳时,仅组3(56–70 dB HL)获得获益。
临床怎么用
- 对非对称性听力损失成人可考虑较差耳人工耳蜗植入以改善言语识别、定位与沟通。
- 评估应包含生活质量量表、声源定位及空间分离噪声下的自适应言语识别测试。
- 咨询时需结合较好耳听力水平、年龄、重度至极重度听力损失起病年龄与病程预估获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告失访率、样本代表性及长期(超过12个月)结果。
- 原文未设非植入对照组,获益估计可能受练习或预期效应影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Asymmetric hearing with severe to profound hearing loss (SPHL) in one ear and better hearing in the other requires increased listening effort and is detrimental for understanding speech in noise and sound localization. Although a cochlear implant (CI) is the only treatment that can restore hearing to an ear with SPHL, current candidacy criteria often disallows this option for patients with asymmetric hearing. The present study aimed to evaluate longitudinal performance outcomes in a relatively large group of adults with asymmetric hearing who received a CI in the poor ear. DESIGN: Forty-seven adults with postlingual hearing loss participated. Test materials included objective and subjective measures meant to elucidate communication challenges encountered by those with asymmetric hearing. Test intervals included preimplant and 6 and 12 months postimplant. Preimplant testing was completed in participants' everyday listening condition: bilateral hearing aids (HAs) n = 9, better ear HA n = 29, and no HA n = 9; postimplant, each ear was tested separately and in the bimodal condition. RESULTS: Group mean longitudinal results in the bimodal condition postimplant compared with the preimplant everyday listening condition indicated significantly improved sentence scores at soft levels and in noise, improved localization, and higher ratings of communication function by 6 months postimplant. Group mean, 6-month postimplant results were significantly better in the bimodal condition compared with either ear alone. Audibility and speech recognition for the poor ear alone improved significantly with a CI compared with preimplant. Most participants had clinically meaningful benefit on most measures. Contributory factors reported for traditional CI candidates also impacted results for this population. In general, older participants had poorer bimodal speech recognition in noise and localization abilities than younger participants. Participants with early SPHL onset had better bimodal localization than those with later SPHL onset, and participants with longer SPHL duration had poorer CI alone speech understanding in noise but not in quiet. Better ear pure-tone average (PTA) correlated with all speech recognition measures in the bimodal condition. To understand the impact of better ear hearing on bimodal performance, participants were grouped by better ear PTA: group 1 PTA ≤40 dB HL (n = 19), group 2 PTA = 41 to 55 dB HL (n = 14), and group 3 PTA = 56 to 70 dB HL (n = 14). All groups showed bimodal benefit on speech recognition measures in quiet and in noise; however, only group 3 obtained benefit when noise was toward the CI ear. All groups showed improved localization and ratings of perceived communication. CONCLUSIONS: Receiving a CI for the poor ear was an effective treatment for this population. Improved audibility and speech recognition were evident by 6 months postimplant. Improvements in sound localization and self-reports of communication benefit were significant and not related to better ear hearing. Participants with more hearing in the better ear (group 1) showed less bimodal benefit but greater bimodal performance for speech recognition than groups 2 and 3. Test batteries for this population should include quality of life measures, sound localization, and adaptive speech recognition measures with spatially separated noise to capture the hearing loss deficits and treatment benefits reported by this patient population.
引用
- Firszt JB, Reeder RM, Holden LK, et al. Results in Adult Cochlear Implant Recipients With Varied Asymmetric Hearing: A Prospective Longitudinal Study of Speech Recognition, Localization, and Participant Report. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29373326. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000548
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。