单侧声带麻痹患者的长期结局
各组末次随访时声门闭合面积与CAPE-V评分相似,提示不能仅凭声门裂隙大小决定治疗,注射喉成形术可带来与永久性内移术相当的长期获益。
要点
- 初诊时各组声门闭合面积相似,不能仅凭声门裂隙大小决定治疗。
- 注射喉成形术长期声门闭合与CAPE-V评分与永久性内移术相当。
- 保守管理组初诊时气息声与响度CAPE-V评分更优。
核心结论
- 初诊时单侧声带麻痹患者声门闭合面积相似,治疗推荐不能仅基于声门裂隙大小。
- 许多患者接受注射喉成形术可获得与永久性内移术相当的长期声门闭合和CAPE-V评分。
主要发现
- 6例仅接受保守管理,20例后续需永久性内移术,19例仅接受注射喉成形术,8例接受注射喉成形术及后续永久性内移术。
- 初诊时各组声门闭合面积相似,但保守管理组气息声CAPE-V评分更优(P = .007),响度CAPE-V评分更优(P = .018)。
- 末次随访时各组声门闭合面积和CAPE-V评分相似。
- 与永久性内移术汇总数据相比,注射喉成形术组初诊时声门闭合面积和CAPE-V评分相似。
- 末次随访时注射喉成形术组粗糙声评分略优(13.3 vs. 18.3,P = .03)。
关键数值与推荐
- 声门闭合程度以标准化声门裂隙面积(NGGA)量化。
- 感知嗓音分析采用CAPE-V在相应时间点评估。
临床怎么用
- 单侧声带麻痹治疗决策不应仅依据声门裂隙大小。
- 注射喉成形术可作为获得长期声门闭合和嗓音改善的选择,效果与永久性内移术相当。
局限性
- 回顾性图表综述,证据等级为4级。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: At presentation, unilateral vocal fold paralysis (UVFP) patients have different treatment options, including conservative management (CM), injection laryngoplasty (IL) with a temporary agent, or permanent medialization (PM). This study evaluates long-term outcomes for UVFP patients relative to intervention. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. METHODS: A retrospective chart review was performed of UVFP patients who presented to the University of California San Francisco Voice and Swallowing Center. Videolaryngostroboscopy examinations were reviewed. Maximum glottic closure was quantified with the normalized glottic gap area (NGGA). Perceptual voice analysis was performed using the Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V) at corresponding time points. RESULTS: Fifty-three patients met inclusion criteria. Six underwent CM only, 20 went on to require PM, 19 underwent IL only, and eight underwent IL and subsequent PM. NGGA at presentation was similar among groups; however, the CM group was noted to have more favorable CAPE-V scores for Breathiness (P = .007) and Loudness (P = .018). All groups had similar NGGA and CAPE-V scores at last follow-up. When compared to pooled data for patients who underwent PM, the IL group was noted to have similar NGGA and CAPE-V scores at presentation. Although improvements in both groups were noted following intervention, both groups appeared similar at last follow-up with the exception of Roughness, for which the IL group retained a slightly improved outcome (13.3 vs. 18.3, P = .03). CONCLUSIONS: At presentation, UVFP patients have similar NGGA. This finding suggests that treatment recommendations cannot be made on the size of the glottic gap alone. Furthermore, in many patients, IL results in long-term benefit with glottic closure and CAPE-V scores equivalent to that obtained with PM. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4. Laryngoscope, 128:430-436, 2018.
引用
- McLaughlin CW, Swendseid B, Courey MS, et al. Long-term outcomes in unilateral vocal fold paralysis patients. Laryngoscope. 2017. PMID: 29171729. doi:10.1002/lary.26900
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。