分泌性中耳炎儿童听力损失对言语感知的实际与模拟效应
研究纳入41名学龄期分泌性中耳炎(OME)相关听力损失儿童,按性别年龄匹配41名听力正常儿童作为配对,并将纯音阈值差作为衰减水平模拟于正常听力儿童,另设41名耳科正常儿童对照,采用普通话噪声下听力测试评估。结果显示模拟与实际的OME相关听力损失在安静环境下的言语接收阈值显著相关且可比,在5、0、-5 dB SNR的句子回忆准确率相似,但噪声下接收阈值实际OME儿童显著优于模拟组。提示该模拟方法可反映安静环境下的影响,对噪声环境仅能近似估计。
要点
- 模拟法可较好反映OME相关听力损失在安静环境下的言语感知损害
- 噪声下实际OME儿童表现优于模拟组,提示可能存在补偿策略
- 教室典型噪声水平下模拟仅能近似估计实际影响
核心结论
- 频率特异性衰减模拟法反映了OME相关听力损失在安静环境下对言语感知的损害,在噪声环境下仅能近似估计典型教室噪声水平的影响。
- OME相关听力损失儿童可能发展出补偿策略以减轻不良听环境中的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入41名学龄期OME相关听力损失儿童,每名与同性别同年龄听力正常儿童配对。
- 以每对儿童125至8000 Hz倍频程纯音阈值差作为正常听力儿童的模拟衰减水平。
- 另招募41名耳科正常学龄儿童作为无实际或模拟听力损失的对照组。
- 采用普通话噪声下听力测试,评估四个信噪比下的句子回忆准确率及安静与噪声下的言语接收阈值。
主要发现
- 模拟OME相关听力损失儿童的安静与噪声下言语感知显著差于耳科正常儿童。
- 实际OME儿童与模拟OME儿童的安静下言语接收阈值显著相关且可比。
- 在5 dB、0 dB和-5 dB信噪比下句子回忆准确率在实际与模拟OME儿童间相似。
- 实际OME儿童的噪声下言语接收阈值显著优于模拟OME儿童。
临床怎么用
- 可用频率特异性衰减模拟辅助预估OME儿童在安静教室中的言语困难。
- 噪声环境下模拟结果仅作近似参考,应结合真实听力评估判断。
- 对OME儿童应关注其噪声下交流表现及可能的补偿策略。
局限性
- 摘要未报告招募来源、听力损失程度分布及统计检验细节。
- 模拟无法完全复现OME相关听力损失在噪声环境下的真实效应。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Conductive hearing loss simulations have attempted to estimate the speech-understanding difficulties of children with otitis media with effusion (OME). However, the validity of this approach has not been evaluated. The research aim of the present study was to investigate whether a simple, frequency-specific, attenuation-based simulation of OME-related hearing loss was able to reflect the actual effects of conductive hearing loss on speech perception. DESIGN: Forty-one school-age children with OME-related hearing loss were recruited. Each child with OME was matched with a same sex and age counterpart with normal hearing to make a participant pair. Pure-tone threshold differences at octave frequencies from 125 to 8000 Hz for every participant pair were used as the simulation attenuation levels for the normal-hearing children. Another group of 41 school-age otologically normal children were recruited as a control group without actual or simulated hearing loss. The Mandarin Hearing in Noise Test was utilized, and sentence recall accuracy at four signal to noise ratios (SNR) considered representative of classroom-listening conditions were derived, as well as reception thresholds for sentences (RTS) in quiet and in noise using adaptive protocols. RESULTS: The speech perception in quiet and in noise of children with simulated OME-related hearing loss was significantly poorer than that of otologically normal children. Analysis showed that RTS in quiet of children with OME-related hearing loss and of children with simulated OME-related hearing loss was significantly correlated and comparable. A repeated-measures analysis suggested that sentence recall accuracy obtained at 5-dB SNR, 0-dB SNR, and -5-dB SNR was similar between children with actual and simulated OME-related hearing loss. However, RTS in noise in children with OME was significantly better than that for children with simulated OME-related hearing loss. CONCLUSIONS: The present frequency-specific, attenuation-based simulation method reflected the effects of OME-related hearing loss on speech perception impairment in quiet environments. In noisy environments, the simulation method could only approximately estimate the effects of OME-related hearing loss on speech perception in typical classroom noise levels. Children with OME-related hearing loss may develop compensatory strategies to reduce the effects of hearing loss in adverse listening environments.
引用
- Cai T, McPherson B, Li C, et al. Hearing Loss in Children With Otitis Media With Effusion: Actual and Simulated Effects on Speech Perception. Ear Hear. 2018. PMID: 29176394. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000519
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。