文献速递咽喉与嗓音

嗓音障碍指数VHI-10的最小重要差异研究

Minimal Important Difference in Voice Handicap Index-10.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg · 2017-01-01

该队列研究纳入273例明尼苏达大学嗓音门诊成人患者,采用锚定法结合全局变化评分估算VHI-10总分的MID,并以分布法佐证。结果提示VHI-10差值6可能代表MID,与中等变化相关,而小变化与无变化难以区分,且相关性有限,需进一步研究。

要点

  • VHI-10差值6分可能代表最小重要差异。
  • 小变化与无变化组VHI-10变化无法区分。
  • 全局变化评分与VHI-10变化相关性有限,结论需谨慎。

核心结论

  • VHI-10差值6可能代表MID,对应全局评分的中等变化。
  • 小变化与无变化类别不可区分,且全局变化评分与VHI-10变化相关性有限,需更多研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究为队列研究,样本为2013年4月7日至2016年7月3日明尼苏达大学嗓音门诊的成人志愿者患者,共273例。
  • 参与者在基线和2周后完成VHI-10(范围0-40,分数越高嗓音相关障碍越重)并填写全局变化评分。
  • 采用锚定法估算MID,用Pearson秩相关分析全局变化评分与VHI-10变化的关系,并以分布法佐证。

主要发现

  • 273例中女性183例(67.0%)、男性90例(33.0%),平均(SD)年龄54.3(15.6)岁,259例(94.9%)为白人。
  • 患者嗓音疾病多样,最常见为肌紧张性发声障碍、喉部易激、良性声带病变和运动异常。
  • 报告无变化者VHI-10平均(SD)变化为1(5),报告小变化者亦为1(5)。
  • 报告中等变化者VHI-10平均(SD)变化为6(8),报告大变化者为9(13)。
  • 全局变化评分与VHI-10变化的相关系数为0.32(95%CI,0.12-0.49)。

关键数值与推荐

  • VHI-10总分范围0-40,分数越高表示嗓音相关障碍越重。
  • 报告中等变化者VHI-10平均(SD)变化为6(8),提示差值6可能为MID。
  • 分布法分析所得效应量与锚定法各分类相当。

临床怎么用

  • 临床可参考VHI-10差值约6分作为患者感知有意义变化的参考。
  • 解读小幅度变化时需谨慎,因小变化与无变化难以区分。
  • 因相关性有限,MID应用应结合其他临床信息,不宜单独依赖。

局限性

  • 小变化与无变化类别无法区分,削弱了MID界定的精确性。
  • 全局变化评分与VHI-10变化相关性仅为0.32(95%CI,0.12-0.49),属有限相关。
  • 样本以白人为主(259例,94.9%),作者指出需更多研究验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: The minimal important difference (MID) on patient-reported outcome measures can indicate how much of a change on that scale is meaningful. OBJECTIVE: To use an anchor-based approach to estimate MID in the Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) total score. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this cohort study, a volunteer sample of adult patients visiting the voice clinic at the University of Minnesota from April 7, 2013, through July 3, 2016, completed the VHI-10 (range, 0-40, with higher scores indicating greater voice-related handicap) at baseline and 2 weeks later in conjunction with a global rating of change. An anchor-based approach was used to identify an MID. The association between the global change score and change in VHI-10 score was analyzed using Pearson rank correlation. A distribution-based method was used to corroborate the findings. MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES: Global rating of change on the VHI-10. RESULTS: Of the 273 participants, 183 (67.0%) were women and 90 (33.0%) were men (mean [SD] age, 54.3 [15.6] years); 259 (94.9%) were white. Participants had a variety of voice disorders, most commonly muscle tension dysphonia, irritable larynx, benign vocal fold lesions, and motion abnormalities. Among patients reporting no change on the global change score, the mean (SD) change in VHI-10 score was 1 (5). Among those reporting a small change, the mean (SD) change in VHI-10 was also 1 (5). Among those reporting a moderate change in voice symptoms, the mean (SD) change in VHI-10 score was 6 (8). Among those with a large change, the mean (SD) change in VHI-10 score was 9 (13). The correlation between the global change score and the change in VHI-10 score was 0.32 (95% CI, 0.12-0.49). Distribution-based analyses identified effect sizes comparable to those of the anchor-based categories. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: These findings suggest that a difference of 6 on the VHI-10 may represent an MID. This difference was associated with a moderate change on the global rating scale, and the small-change and no-change categories were indistinguishable. Given the lack of differentiation between small and no change and the modest correlation between the global change score and change in the VHI-10 score, additional studies are needed.

来源:JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Misono S, Yueh B, Stockness AN, et al. Minimal Important Difference in Voice Handicap Index-10. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28973078. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2017.1621

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。