耳部手术后是否需要住院?全国调查与术后事件回顾分析
该研究先调查国内耳鼻咽喉科医生对择期中耳手术术后管理(住院或日间手术)的习惯,再回顾本中心2010至2016年相关手术病例,分为住院组与日间手术组,记录住院期间术后事件及日间手术组咨询/再入院率。结果显示多数择期中耳手术可安全地以日间手术完成,住院并未提供家中无法提供的照护;镫骨手术可考虑过夜观察。
要点
- 多数择期中耳手术可安全以日间手术完成
- 住院患者88.6%无并发症,住院未提供家中无法提供的照护
- 镫骨手术再入院占100%,可考虑过夜观察
核心结论
- 多数择期中耳手术可安全地以日间手术完成,住院在大多数病例中未提供家中无法提供的照护。
- 镫骨手术可考虑过夜住院观察。
- 将此类病例转为日间手术可降低医疗系统成本并增加床位可用性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究先开展关于择期中耳手术术后习惯的全国调查,调查对象为耳鼻咽喉科同仁。
- 随后回顾本中心2010至2016年所有接受这些手术的患者病例,分为住院组与日间手术组。
- 记录住院期间术后事件及日间手术组咨询/再入院率。
主要发现
- 多数择期耳科手术的术后习惯在耳鼻咽喉科医生之间存在异质性;但鼓室成形术一致倾向于日间手术。
- 本机构住院患者中88.6%住院期间无并发症。
- 其他住院患者记录的并发症为恶心(7.2%)、出血(3.1%)、血肿(0.5%)和感音神经性听力损失(0.5%)。
- 日间手术组3.0%在术后48小时内咨询,再入院率为1.3%。
- 恶心是再入院的唯一原因,镫骨手术占再入院的100%。
关键数值与推荐
- 住院患者88.6%无并发症;恶心7.2%、出血3.1%、血肿0.5%、感音神经性听力损失0.5%。
- 日间手术组术后48小时内咨询率3.0%,再入院率1.3%。
- 再入院唯一原因为恶心,镫骨手术占再入院的100%。
临床怎么用
- 择期中耳手术大多数可以日间手术方式安全开展。
- 镫骨手术可考虑过夜住院观察。
- 将合适病例转为日间手术有助于降低医疗系统成本并增加床位可用性。
局限性
- 为单中心2010至2016年病例回顾,结合全国调查,原文未报告样本量、置信区间与P值等统计细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective First, to survey our national otolaryngology colleagues on their postoperative care habits (hospitalization vs day surgery) after elective middle ear surgery. Second, to evaluate the necessity of hospitalization and safety of day surgery after these procedures. Methods A national survey regarding postoperative habits after elective middle ear surgery was launched. Then, the cases of all patients having undergone these surgical procedures at our center between 2010 and 2016 were reviewed. They were divided into 2 groups: hospitalization and day surgery. Postoperative events during hospitalization and rate of consultation/readmission for day surgery were recorded. Results Heterogeneity in postoperative habits for most elective otologic surgery exists among otolaryngologists. For tympanoplasty, however, day surgery was uniformly favored. At our institution, 88.6% of hospitalization patients had no complications during their stay. Complications noted for others were nausea (7.2%), bleeding (3.1%), hematoma (0.5%), and sensorineural hearing loss (0.5%). In the day surgery group, 3.0% consulted within 48 hours following their procedure, and the readmission rate was 1.3%. Nausea was the only cause for readmission, and stapes surgery accounted for 100% of readmissions. Discussion Most elective middle ear surgery can be safely performed as day care. Hospitalization does not provide care that could not have been provided at home in the majority of cases. Overnight hospital stay may be considered for stapes surgery. Implications for Practice Day surgery for elective middle ear surgery is sufficient for most cases. Transferring these cases to day care should lower costs to our health care system and increase bed availability.
引用
- Jelicic T, Savage JR, Aron M, et al. Is Hospitalization Necessary after Ear Surgery? A National Survey and Retrospective Review of Postoperative Events. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28895462. doi:10.1177/0194599817726307
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。