喉老化治疗:注射填充与双侧甲状软骨成形术效果比较
回顾性比较双侧甲状软骨成形术与注射填充治疗喉老化的效果,纳入22例患者。甲状软骨成形术后V-RQOL评分改善25.5,注射填充后为-16.4(P<0.05);64%甲状软骨成形术患者报告显著疗效,注射填充为33%。
要点
- 甲状软骨成形术后所有问卷自评均显著改善,注射填充后无显著改善
- 甲状软骨成形术V-RQOL改善25.5,注射填充为-16.4,差异有统计学意义
- 治疗前有吞咽症状者更可能出现V-RQOL>20的改善
核心结论
- 甲状软骨成形术在患者自评问卷上均显示显著改善,而注射填充未显示显著改善。
- 甲状软骨成形术患者报告声音更接近最佳状态的比例及显著疗效比例均高于注射填充。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病历审查,纳入22例接受双侧甲状软骨成形术和/或注射填充治疗的患者。
- 治疗前后评估内镜下声门间隙面积与真声带宽度、患者自评问卷及声学与空气动力学指标。
主要发现
- 甲状软骨成形术后38%患者声带弓形减少,注射填充后为33%。
- 甲状软骨成形术后63%患者声门上活动减少,注射填充后为43%(P=0.09)。
- V-RQOL评分平均变化:甲状软骨成形术为25.5,注射填充为-16.4(P<0.05)。
- 64%甲状软骨成形术患者报告显著疗效,注射填充为33%。
- 治疗后V-RQOL变化大于20的患者,治疗前更可能报告吞咽症状。
关键数值与推荐
- V-RQOL评分变化:甲状软骨成形术25.5,注射填充-16.4(P<0.05)。
- 声带弓形减少比例:甲状软骨成形术38%,注射填充33%。
- 声门上活动减少比例:甲状软骨成形术63%,注射填充43%(P=0.09)。
- 显著疗效报告比例:甲状软骨成形术64%,注射填充33%。
临床怎么用
- 对于喉老化患者,甲状软骨成形术在患者自评嗓音相关生活质量上可能优于注射填充。
- 治疗前存在吞咽症状的患者可能更易从治疗中获得V-RQOL的显著改善。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,证据等级为4级。
- 样本量较小(22例),部分比较未达统计学显著性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare the effectiveness of injection augmentation and bilateral thyroplasty surgery in managing age-related changes of the larynx. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review of patients treated with bilateral thyroplasty and/or injection augmentation. METHODS: We evaluated 22 patients before and after treatment using: 1) normalized glottal gap area and normalized true vocal fold width from endoscopic images; 2) patient self-rating questionnaires; and 3) acoustic and aerodynamic measures. RESULTS: Thyroplasty surgery resulted in 38% of patients demonstrating less bowing compared to 33% after injection, and 63% demonstrated less supraglottic activity compared to 43% after injection (P = 0.09). Change in mean Voice-Related Quality of Life (V-RQOL) scores was 25.5 after thyroplasty compared to -16.4 after injection (P < 0.05). Those exhibiting a greater than 20 change in V-RQOL after treatment were significantly more likely to report swallowing symptoms pretreatment. CONCLUSION: Patients postinjection did not rate themselves on any questionnaires as significantly better compared to pretreatment, whereas patients post-thyroplasty rated themselves as significantly improved on all questionnaires. Patients post-thyroplasty rated their voices as significantly closer to their best voice than patients postinjection. Likewise, 64% of patients who had thyroplasty surgery reported a significant treatment effect compared to 33% for injection augmentation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4. Laryngoscope, 127:2572-2577, 2017.
引用
- Sachs AM, Bielamowicz SA, Stager SV, et al. Treatment effectiveness for aging changes in the larynx. Laryngoscope. 2017. PMID: 28681923. doi:10.1002/lary.26706
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。