耳聋患者乳突与前额位置振动触觉阈值:B71与B81比较
本研究测量双侧耳聋患者乳突与前额位置的振动触觉阈值,并比较Radioear B71与B81两种骨导振动器。16例耳蜗植入者参与,结果显示振动触觉阈值在125至500 Hz随频率升高,2 kHz内保持恒定;两设备在125 Hz处乳突与前额阈值均有显著差异,B71似更敏感;乳突与前额绝对力级无显著差异,但听力级平均差分别为10 dB(B71)和9 dB(B81)。
要点
- 振动触觉阈值在125至500 Hz随频率增加,2 kHz内恒定。
- 125 Hz处B71与B81在乳突和前额的振动触觉阈值有显著差异,B71似更敏感。
- 乳突与前额绝对力级无显著差异,听力级平均差B71为10 dB、B81为9 dB。
核心结论
- 使用标准听力计测量骨导听阈时,振动触觉阈值可能与骨导听阈混淆,频率可达500 Hz,尤其在前额位置。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入16例双侧耳聋的耳蜗植入者(31%女性,69%男性,年龄29至77岁),基于听力图不可测的未助听听阈选择。
- 使用听力计驱动的骨导振动器Radioear B71和B81,脉冲啭音,测量乳突与前额位置的振动触觉阈值,患者仅对振动反应。
主要发现
- 振动触觉阈值随频率从125 Hz至500 Hz增加,更高频率至2 kHz保持恒定。
- 125 Hz处两种设备在乳突和前额位置的振动触觉阈值有统计学显著差异,B71的振动触觉阈值似更敏感,可能由于失真成分贡献。
- 乳突与前额位置的振动触觉阈值以绝对力级(dB re 1 µN)计无统计学显著差异,但以听力级(dB HL)计平均差异B71为10 dB、B81为9 dB。
临床怎么用
- 使用标准听力计测量骨导听阈时,需注意振动触觉阈值可能混淆骨导听阈,频率可达500 Hz,尤其在前额位置。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The main objective of this study was to measure the vibrotactile thresholds on the mastoid process and forehead positions using patients with bilateral deafness and to compare the results from the two bone conduction vibrators Radioear B71 and B81. DESIGN: There is a possibility that the vibrotactile sensation on the skin makes it difficult to discriminate between sound and vibration. The risk is highest for patients who have bone conduction hearing thresholds in proximity to or worse than their vibrotactile thresholds. All measurements were performed similar to regular bone conduction threshold testing using an audiometer-driven bone conduction vibrator and pulsed warble tones, but the patients were instructed to respond only when feeling vibrations of the bone conduction vibrator instead of when hearing sound. Both the posterior forehead position and the mastoid process position on the temporal bone were tested for comparative reasons. In total, 16 patients participated in the study, 31% females and 69% males of age 29 to 77 years. All subjects were cochlear implant recipients, either uni- or bilaterally implanted. They were selected based on their audiogram data showing unmeasurable unaided hearing. RESULTS: The force level at which the vibrotactile thresholds were reached, increased with frequency from 125 up to 500 Hz, but remained constant for higher frequencies up to 2 kHz. A statistically significant difference was found between the 2 devices at 125 Hz at both the mastoid process and forehead position, where the vibrotactile threshold seem to be more sensitive for B71, possibly due to contribution of distortion components. There was no statistically significant difference in vibrotactile thresholds between the mastoid process and forehead position in absolute values (force level in dB re 1 µN), but in terms of hearing levels (dB HL) there was an average difference of 10 and 9 dB for B71 and B81, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that the vibrotactile thresholds can be confounded with bone conduction hearing thresholds measurements up to 500 Hz when using a standard audiometer and in particular when measuring on the forehead position.
引用
- Fredén Jansson KJ, Håkansson B, Reinfeldt S, et al. Vibrotactile Thresholds on the Mastoid and Forehead Position of Deaf Patients Using Radioear B71 and B81. Ear Hear. 2017. PMID: 28737551. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000456
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。