BPPV位置试验顺序优化:Dix-Hallpike试验与滚转试验的比较
研究纳入230例BPPV管石症患者(PSC-Can 170例,HSC-Can 60例),用视频眼震图记录Dix-Hallpike试验和滚转试验诱发的眼震特征。结果发现Dix-Hallpike试验不仅可诊断PSC-Can,也能有效诱发HSC-Can眼震(一致性95%);滚转试验仅对HSC-Can有意义。建议先做Dix-Hallpike试验,根据水平眼震有无决定是否继续滚转试验。
要点
- Dix-Hallpike试验可诊断PSC-Can,也能有效诱发HSC-Can眼震,与滚转试验一致性95%。
- 滚转试验仅适用于HSC-Can诊断,在PSC-Can中未记录到连续性眼震。
- 位置试验建议从Dix-Hallpike试验开始,根据水平眼震有无判断是否继续滚转试验。
核心结论
- Dix-Hallpike试验不仅是PSC-Can的可靠诊断方法,也能有效诱发HSC-Can眼震;滚转试验仅适用于HSC-Can诊断。
- 位置试验建议从Dix-Hallpike试验开始,根据水平眼震有无判断是否需要继续施行滚转试验,以减少对患者的不适刺激。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入BPPV管石症患者230例,其中PSC-Can 170例,HSC-Can 60例,应用视频眼震图仪记录两种位置试验诱发的眼震并比较特征。
主要发现
- 170例PSC-Can患者在Dix-Hallpike试验患侧悬头位均记录到垂直向上为主眼震,回坐位时眼震方向反转且弱,滚转试验未记录到连续性眼震。
- PSC-Can患者Dix-Hallpike试验患侧悬头位与坐位垂直眼震强度分别为(30.3±14.1)°/s和(12.6±7.5)°/s,差异有统计学意义(t=20.153,P<0.05)。
- 60例HSC-Can患者滚转试验均诱发出与转头方向一致的水平眼震,患侧及健侧强度分别为(42.0±18.0)°/s和(20.3±8.7)°/s,差异有统计学意义(t=12.731,P<0.05)。
- 57例HSC-Can患者在Dix-Hallpike试验悬头位记录到与转头方向一致的水平眼震,与滚转试验诊断结果一致性达95%。
临床怎么用
- 位置试验建议从Dix-Hallpike试验开始,根据水平眼震的有无判断是否需要继续施行滚转试验,以减少对患者的不适刺激。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To analyze the objective characteristics of roll test and Dix-Hallpike test in benign paroxysmal positional vertigo(BPPV)patients, discussing the premier solution of positional test. Methods: A total of 230 patients with BPPV, whereas 170 posterior semicircular canal canalithiasis (PSC-Can) BPPV and 60 horizontal semicircular canal canalithiasis (HSC-Can) BPPV were involved respectively. The induced nystagmus in roll test and Dix-Hallpike test was recorded by video nystagmuo graph (VNG), and the direction, intensity and time characteristics of nystagmus were compared in various BPPV.SPSS19.0 software was used for statistical analysis. Results: Vertically upward nystagmus was induced by hanging in 170 PSC-Can Dix-Hallpike test, and the nystagmus reversed and turned weaker when the subjects came to sit. The intensity of nystagmus at turning to lesion side by hanging and sitting were (30.3±14.1)°/s and (12.6±7.5)°/s respectively, the difference was statistically significant (t=20.153, P<0.05). However, no nystagmus was induced in PSC-Can roll test. Horizontal nystagmus in the same direction with turning was induced in 60 HSC-Can roll test. The intensity of nystagmus at turning to lesion side and normal side was (42.0±18.0)°/s and (20.3±8.7)°/s respectively, the difference was statistically significant (t=12.731, P<0.05). Furthermore, horizontal nystagmus in the same direction with turning was induced in 57 HSC-Can Dix-Hallpike. The coherence was 95% with the results of roll test. Conclusions: Dix-Hallpike test can not only be used to diagnose PSC-Can, but also induce nystagmus in HSC-Can effectively. Whereas the roll test only show significance in diagnosing HSC-Can. To avoid uncomfortable stimulation to patients as much as possible, we suggest to use Dix-Hallpike test at first, and to judge whether using roll test based on the result of the horizontal nystagmus. 目的: 分析良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)患者在Dix-Hallpike试验(Dix-Hallpike test)和滚转试验(roll test)两种位置试验中的眼震特征,探讨这两种位置试验的顺序优选方案。 方法: BPPV管石症患者230例,其中后半规管管石症(posterior semicircular canal canalithiasis, PSC-Can)170例,外半规管管石症(亦称水平半规管管石症,horizontal semicircular canal canalithiasis, HSC-Can)60例。应用视频眼震图仪分别记录患者Dix-Hallpike试验和滚转试验所诱发的眼震,比较两种位置试验在各试验头位诱发眼震的方向、强度等参数特征,采用SPSS19.0软件进行统计分析。 结果: 170例PSC-Can患者在Dix-Hallpike试验患侧悬头位均能记录到垂直向上为主的眼震,回坐位时眼震方向反转且弱,但在滚转试验中未记录到连续性眼震。Dix-Hallpike试验患侧悬头位与坐位诱发垂直眼震的强度分别为(30.3±14.1)°/s和(12.6±7.5)°/s,差异有统计学意义(t=20.153,P<0.05)。60例HSC-Can患者滚转试验均能够诱发出与转头方向一致的水平眼震,患侧及健侧的水平眼震强度分别为(42.0±18.0)°/s和(20.3±8.7)°/s,差异有统计学意义(t=12.731,P<0.05);其中57例HSC-Can患者在Dix-Hallpike试验悬头位记录到与转头方向一致的水平眼震,与滚转试验诊断结果的一致性达95%。 结论: Dix-Hallpike试验不仅是PSC-Can的可靠诊断试验方法,也能够有效诱发HSC-Can眼震;而滚转试验仅适用于HSC-Can的诊断。位置试验建议从Dix-Hallpike试验开始,根据水平眼震的有无判断是否需要继续施行滚转试验,以减少对患者的不适刺激。.
引用
- Ji R, Chen TS, Wang W, et al. [The exploration on optimization of two alternatives between roll test and Dix-Hallpike test in benign paroxysmal positional vertigo]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2017. PMID: 28635217. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-0860.2017.06.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。