推荐信与面试官印象及偏好的关联研究
该调查研究了标准化推荐信(SLOR)与传统叙述式推荐信(NLOR)与面试官面对面面试印象的关联程度差异,并匿名调查面试官对推荐信的偏好。结果显示2573份评估中回收964份(37.5%响应率),推荐信与面试VAS评分平均关联度在各年度和类型间为72至81,61%面试官偏好NLOR,13%偏好SLOR。结论认为过去5年不同类型推荐信与面试印象的关联度相当,推荐信的一般效用仍存疑。
要点
- 推荐信与面试印象的VAS平均关联度在各年度和类型间为72至81。
- 61%面试官偏好NLOR,13%偏好SLOR,理由分别为信息更多和阅读更快。
- 过去5年不同类型推荐信与面试印象的关联度相当。
核心结论
- 面试官基于推荐信与面对面面试对申请者的印象在不同推荐信类型间相当。
- 推荐信的一般效用仍存疑,应批判性评估其持续必要性。
研究设计与样本
- 调查研究,单机构耳鼻咽喉科住院医师项目,在引入SLOR前1年及后4年进行。
- 共2573份评估,回收964份(37.5%响应率),包括927份与NLOR相关、561份与SLOR相关、316份与医学院学生表现评估(即院长信)相关。
主要发现
- 推荐信与面试之间VAS评分的平均关联度在各年度和推荐信类型间范围为72至81。
- 61%面试官偏好NLOR,13%偏好SLOR。
- 偏好理由包括NLOR提供更多信息,而SLOR阅读时间更快。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective Letters of recommendation (LORs) are an inescapable aspect of the application process. Standardized LORs (SLORs) have been developed and compared with traditional narrative LORs (NLORs). This study investigated whether there was a difference in degree of association between LOR types and face-to-face interviews. Interviewer preference for LOR was anonymously surveyed. Study Design Survey. Setting Single-institution otolaryngology residency program, 1 year before and 4 years after introduction of SLORs. Subjects and Methods Residency interviewers indicated on a visual analog scale how well their impression of an applicant compared between the LOR and the face-to-face interview. Interviewers assessed each applicant, each year, based on LOR type. Results Of 2573 assessments, 964 were collected (37.5% response rate), including 927 responses related to NLORs, 561 to SLORs, and 316 to medical student performance evaluations (ie, dean's letters). The average association of VAS scores between LORs and interviews ranged from 72 to 81 across years and LOR types. Sixty-one percent of interviewers preferred NLORs, and 13% preferred SLORs. Reasons for these preferences included more information provided in NLORs versus faster read time with SLORs. Conclusions Interviewers' perceptions of applicants based on LORs and face-to-face interviews were comparable across LOR types over the last 5 years. For many reasons, the general utility of the LOR remains questionable, and the continued need for it should be critically assessed.
引用
- Young VN. Letters of Recommendation: Association with Interviewers' Perceptions and Preferences. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28463640. doi:10.1177/0194599817706063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。