门诊喉科操作前心血管预筛查方案
本研究旨在制定并评估门诊喉科操作(IOLP)前的心血管预筛查方案。第一阶段56例患者筛查失败率为40%,主要与四项代谢当量工作相关;第二阶段440例中筛查失败率仅为2.6%(15/572),最终仅1.5%(5/440)患者因预筛查标准需将服务地点从无监护改为监护设置。作者认为该方案识别了心血管风险因素患者,可能以极低医生负担提高IOLP安全性。
要点
- 第一阶段56例患者筛查失败率为40%,主要与四项代谢当量工作相关。
- 第二阶段440例患者中筛查失败15/572例(2.6%),最终仅5/440例(1.5%)需更改服务地点。
- 预筛查标准为收缩压>160 mmHg、舒张压>100 mmHg和/或心率>110次/分。
核心结论
- 基于本研究设定的门诊心血管参数,少数患者需要进一步检查。
- 筛查方案识别了具有心血管风险因素的患者。
- 建立血流动力学参数可能以极低的医生负担提高IOLP的安全性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分为两阶段:第一阶段纳入56例患者,采用包含四项代谢当量工作相关问题的完整心血管预筛查方案;第二阶段纳入440例患者,仅采用改良心血管预筛查方案。
- 所有患者在操作前均筛查心率和血压,需进一步心血管评估的标准为收缩压>160 mmHg、舒张压>100 mmHg和/或心率>110次/分。
- 血压/心率超过上述值的患者被转诊至其初级保健医生(PCP)进行再筛查;若第二次筛查仍超标,则在监护麻醉下进行操作。
主要发现
- 第一阶段56例患者筛查失败率为40%,主要与四项代谢当量工作相关。
- 第二阶段440例患者中,筛查失败15/572例(2.6%);其中12/132例(9.1%)初次筛查失败并被转诊至PCP进一步评估,5/440例(1.4%)在操作当日筛查失败。
- 总体而言,5/440例(1.5%)患者因预筛查标准符合将其喉科操作服务地点从无监护改为监护设置。
关键数值与推荐
- 需进一步心血管评估的标准:收缩压>160 mmHg、舒张压>100 mmHg和/或心率>110次/分。
- 第一阶段56例患者筛查失败率为40%。
- 第二阶段440例患者中筛查失败15/572例(2.6%),其中12/132例(9.1%)初次筛查失败转诊PCP,5/440例(1.4%)操作当日失败,最终5/440例(1.5%)需更改服务地点。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Currently, there are no cardiovascular (CV) preprocedure screening parameters for patients undergoing in-office laryngeal procedures (IOLP). Studies have shown significant changes in CV measures for IOLP. The aim was to develop and evaluate a pre-IOLP CV screening protocol. METHODS: Review of IOLP literature and consultation with an anesthesiologist and cardiologist led to the development of CV parameters and questions related to four metabolic equivalents (METS) of work as a patient-screening tool before IOLP. A separate cohort was screened with only a modified CV protocol. All patients were screened for heart rate (HR) and blood pressure (BP) elevation prior to the procedure. Need for further CV evaluation was characterized as systolic blood pressure BP >160, diastolic BP >100, and/or HR >110 beats/minute. Patients whose BP/HR exceeded these values were referred to their primary care physician (PCP) before re-screening. If parameters were exceeded again at the second screen, then the procedure was done under monitored anesthesia care. RESULTS: The first study phase included 56 patients. The fail rate was 40% largely related to four METS of work. The second study phase included 440 patients. The screen fail rate was 15 patients of 572 (2.6%). Of these, 12 patients of 132 (9.1%) failed the initial screen and were sent to their PCP for further evaluation, and five of 440 (1.4%) patients failed on the day of the procedure. Overall, five of 440 (1.5%) patients would qualify to have their site of service changed for their laryngology procedure from an unmonitored to a monitored setting due to the prescreening criteria. CONCLUSION: Few patients needed further workup based upon the in-office CV parameters set in this study. Patients with CV risk factors were identified by the screening protocol. Having established hemodynamic parameters in place may improve the safety of IOLP with a very low physician burden. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2b Laryngoscope, 127:1845-1849, 2017.
引用
- Madden LL, Ward J, Ward A, et al. A cardiovascular prescreening protocol for unmonitored in-office laryngology procedures. Laryngoscope. 2017. PMID: 28407258. doi:10.1002/lary.26481
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。