文献速递耳科与耳神经小儿耳鼻咽喉

双侧人工耳蜗植入幼儿的噪声下言语检测:是否优于遮蔽耳单独使用

Speech Detection in Noise for Young Bilaterally Implanted Children: Is There Evidence of Binaural Benefit Over the Shadowed Ear Alone?
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2017-01-01

研究纳入20例4岁前双侧人工耳蜗植入、术后约2年的儿童,测量前方言语、90°噪声条件下的检测信噪比。组水平分析显示单侧与双侧人工耳蜗条件间检测信噪比无显著差异,多数个体亦无显著差异;仅4例显示双侧获益,且1例的获益无法与所加耳为表现更优耳区分。作者指出结果可用于术后预期咨询,尤其术后前2年。

要点

  • 4岁前双侧植入、术后约2年的儿童中,组水平单侧与双侧人工耳蜗的噪声下言语检测信噪比无显著差异。
  • 多数个体单侧与双侧条件间检测信噪比无显著差异,仅4例显示双侧获益。
  • 结果可用于向家庭说明幼儿术后尤其前2年的预期。

核心结论

  • 组结果及多数个体结果不支持双侧条件下检测信噪比更低的假设;4例显示获益者中1例的获益无法与所加耳为表现更优耳区分。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入在墨尔本Eye and Ear Hospital Clinic接受双侧人工耳蜗植入、植入时小于4岁且术后约2年的儿童,共20例。
  • 测量前方言语、90°噪声下至少3种设备/噪声条件的检测信噪比,包括左耳人工耳蜗/右耳噪声、右耳人工耳蜗/左耳噪声、双侧人工耳蜗/右耳噪声、双侧人工耳蜗/左耳噪声。

主要发现

  • 因部分参与者仅能在1个测试区块内完成3种条件,单侧与双侧比较在15例中针对1个耳(即1个噪声方向)进行,在5例中针对双耳(即噪声左和噪声右)进行。
  • 组分析显示,加入左耳或右耳人工耳蜗(总体组)或加入第一或第二耳人工耳蜗(15例序贯双侧植入者)时,单侧与双侧条件间检测信噪比无显著差异。
  • 分别分析显示,多数个体单侧与双侧条件间检测信噪比无显著差异,无论所加耳为表现更差、表现更好还是无显著差异。
  • 4例在双侧条件下显示显著改善,其中所加耳为表现更好者1例、表现更差者2例、无显著差异者1例。
  • 各耳间检测信噪比差异与单侧和双侧条件间检测信噪比差异无关系。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这些结果可用于向家庭说明幼儿术后尤其术后前2年的预期。

局限性

  • 部分参与者仅能在1个测试区块内完成3种条件,单侧与双侧比较仅对1个耳(1个噪声方向)在15例中进行、对双耳在5例中进行。
  • 4例显示获益者中1例的获益无法与所加耳为表现更优耳区分。
  • 结局变异无法与该组人口学因素相关,该组在双侧植入年龄和体验方面相对同质;年龄更大、经验更丰富的组可能在这些条件下显示更大双耳获益。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To measure binaural benefit over the shadowed ear alone for young bilateral cochlear implant (CI) users. It was hypothesized that children who received bilateral CIs at a young age (<4 years), and had significant bilateral experience, would demonstrate lower detection thresholds for speech sounds in background noise in the bilateral CI over the unilateral CI condition when the added CI was ipsilateral to the noise source. DESIGN: Children receiving bilateral CIs at the Eye and Ear Hospital Clinic in Melbourne were invited to participate in a wider research project evaluating outcomes; those participating in the wider project who were bilaterally implanted by 4 years and were approximately 2 years postoperative were included in the present study. For 20 participants, detection signal to noise ratios (SNRs) were measured for speech presented from in front and noise from 90° in at least 3 of 4 device/noise conditions, namely left CI/noise right and right CI/noise left, plus bilateral CIs/noise right and bilateral CIs/noise left. RESULTS: As some participants could only complete testing in 3 conditions within the 1 test block, the unilateral versus bilateral comparison was performed for 1 CI (i.e., 1 noise direction) for 15 participants and for both CIs (i.e., noise left and noise right) for 5 participants. Group analysis indicated no significant difference in detection SNR between the unilateral and bilateral CI conditions when adding the left CI or right CI (for the overall group) or when adding the first or second CI (for the 15 participants with sequential bilateral CIs). Separate analyses indicated no significant difference in detection SNR between the unilateral and bilateral CI conditions for the majority of individuals; this occurred irrespective of whether the analysis indicated that the CI added in the bilateral condition was poorer-performing, better-performing, or not significantly different compared with the other CI. Four individuals demonstrated a significant improvement in the bilateral condition when the CI added in the bilateral condition was a better-performing (n = 1), poorer-performing (n = 2), or not significantly different CI (n = 1). There was no relationship between the detection SNR difference between each CI and the detection SNR difference between the unilateral and bilateral conditions. CONCLUSIONS: The hypothesis of a lower detection SNR in the bilateral condition was not supported by the group results or by the results for the majority of individuals. For the 4 participants who did demonstrate benefit over the shadowed ear alone, that benefit cannot be separated from the potential benefit gained as a result of the CI added in the bilateral condition being the better-performing CI for 1 of the 4. Variation in outcomes could not be related to demographic factors for this group, which was relatively homogeneous for age at bilateral CI and experience; an older, more experienced group may demonstrate greater binaural benefit in these conditions. These results can be used during counseling for families regarding postoperative expectations for young children, especially in the first 2 years.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Galvin KL, Dowell RC, van Hoesel RJ, et al. Speech Detection in Noise for Young Bilaterally Implanted Children: Is There Evidence of Binaural Benefit Over the Shadowed Ear Alone? Ear Hear. 2017. PMID: 28441300. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000442

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。