双模式人工耳蜗使用者的术前与术后双耳掩蔽效应
研究纳入11例有人工耳蜗(CI)适应证的候选者,在术前及其中10例术后至少5个月用视听语句测试双耳掩蔽效应(BILD)。5例术前存在显著BILD,术后仅2例保留但均值由3.1 dB降至1.3 dB;10例中9例术后言语识别等于或优于术前最佳表现。
要点
- 11例CI候选者中5例术前存在显著双耳掩蔽效应,范围2.0至7.3 dB。
- 这5例中仅2例术后保留显著双耳掩蔽效应,其均值由术前3.1 dB降至术后1.3 dB。
- 10例术后测试者中9例言语识别表现等于或优于术前最佳表现。
核心结论
- 本研究中约半数CI候选者术前存在视听噪声下言语识别的双耳听觉获益,多数术后植入耳 acoustic 听力丧失而失去该获益。
- 除1例外,双耳掩蔽获益的丧失均被CI带来的言语识别改善所补偿或超越。
- 作者认为术前存在BILD的证据提示某些CI候选者可能从保留 acoustic 双耳掩蔽的听力保留手术中进一步获益,该测试可作为识别最可能从双侧 acoustic 听力获得功能获益的CI候选者的诊断工具。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为术前与术后对照设计,纳入11例CI候选者,其中10例在CI激活后至少5个月完成术后测试,1例选择不接受CI。
- 采用视听语句噪声下言语感知测试,噪声为言语形状掩蔽噪声,信噪比范围-10至+15 dB,噪声两耳间始终相关,语句信号为相关(N0S0)或反相关(N0Sπ)。
- 刺激通过耳机给未助听耳、并通过辅助输入给CI言语处理器;以z检验比较每位受试者N0S0与N0Sπ条件表现,对差异显著者以达到50%正确率所需信噪比差值定义BILD幅度。
- 1例接受听力保留手术的受试者额外接受术后测试,声音直接给双耳及CI言语处理器。
主要发现
- 11例受试者中5例术前存在显著BILD,范围为2.0至7.3 dB。
- 10例术后测试者中9例表现等于或优于术前最佳表现。
- 植入耳保留功能性 acoustic 听力的那例受试者,术后也保留了 acoustic BILD。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,术前存在BILD的证据提示某些CI候选者可能从听力保留手术中进一步获益,以保留 acoustic 双耳掩蔽,正如接受听力保留手术的那例受试者所示。
- 作者认为,该视听噪声下双耳言语感知测试可作为诊断工具,识别最可能从双侧 acoustic 听力获得功能获益的CI候选者。
- 原文未据此给出其他推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implants (CIs) are increasingly recommended to individuals with residual bilateral acoustic hearing. Although new hearing-preserving electrode designs and surgical approaches show great promise, CI recipients are still at risk to lose acoustic hearing in the implanted ear, which could prevent the ability to take advantage of binaural unmasking to aid speech recognition in noise. This study examined the tradeoff between the benefits of a CI for speech understanding in noise and the potential loss of binaural unmasking for CI recipients with some bilateral preoperative acoustic hearing. DESIGN: Binaural unmasking is difficult to evaluate in CI candidates because speech perception in noise is generally too poor to measure reliably in the range of signal to noise ratios (SNRs) where binaural intelligibility level differences (BILDs) are typically observed (<5 dB). Thus, a test of audiovisual speech perception in noise was employed to increase performance to measureable levels. BILDs were measured preoperatively for 11 CI candidates and at least 5 months post-activation for 10 of these individuals (1 individual elected not to receive a CI). Audiovisual sentences were presented in speech-shaped masking noise between -10 and +15 dB SNR. The noise was always correlated between the ears, while the speech signal was either correlated (N0S0) or inversely correlated (N0Sπ). Stimuli were delivered via headphones to the unaided ear(s) and, where applicable, via auxiliary input to the CI speech processor. A z test evaluated performance differences between the N0S0 and N0Sπ conditions for each listener pre- and postoperatively. For listeners showing a significant difference, the magnitude of the BILD was characterized as the difference in SNRs required to achieve 50% correct performance. One listener who underwent hearing-preservation surgery received additional postoperative tests, which presented sound directly to both ears and to the CI speech processor. RESULTS: Five of 11 listeners showed a significant preoperative BILD (range: 2.0 to 7.3 dB). Only 2 of these 5 showed a significant postoperative BILD, but the mean BILD was smaller (1.3 dB) than that observed preoperatively (3.1 dB). Despite the fact that some listeners lost the preoperative binaural benefit, 9 out of 10 listeners tested postoperatively had performance equal to or better than their best pre-CI performance. The listener who retained functional acoustic hearing in the implanted ear also demonstrated a preserved acoustic BILD postoperatively. CONCLUSIONS: Approximately half of the CI candidates in this study demonstrated preoperative binaural hearing benefits for audiovisual speech perception in noise. Most of these listeners lost their acoustic hearing in the implanted ear after surgery (using nonhearing-preservation techniques), and therefore lost access to this binaural benefit. In all but one case, any loss of binaural benefit was compensated for or exceeded by an improvement in speech perception with the CI. Evidence of a preoperative BILD suggests that certain CI candidates might further benefit from hearing-preservation surgery to retain acoustic binaural unmasking, as demonstrated for the listener who underwent hearing-preservation surgery. This test of binaural audiovisual speech perception in noise could serve as a diagnostic tool to identify CI candidates who are most likely to receive functional benefits from their bilateral acoustic hearing.
引用
- Sheffield BM, Schuchman G, Bernstein JGW, et al. Pre- and Postoperative Binaural Unmasking for Bimodal Cochlear Implant Listeners. Ear Hear. 2017. PMID: 28301390. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000420
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。