文献速递小儿耳鼻咽喉耳科与耳神经

模拟听力损失对双语儿童噪声下辅音识别的影响

Effects of Simulated Hearing Loss on Bilingual Children's Consonant Recognition in Noise.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2017-01-01

本研究以11名英语主导的西班牙语-英语双语儿童和12名英语单语同龄儿童为对象,用阈值提升噪声模拟轻至中度斜坡型感音神经性听力损失,考察噪声下辅音识别表现。结果发现双语儿童在安静及噪声条件下辅音识别平均正确率与单语同龄儿童相似,模拟听力损失对两组的影响也相似,原假设被否定。

要点

  • 双语儿童在安静条件下辅音识别表现与英语单语同龄儿童相似。
  • 模拟听力损失对双语和单语儿童均有显著不利影响,组间无显著差异。
  • 双语儿童辅音识别随年龄改善,提示经验可能起作用。

核心结论

  • 学龄期英语主导的西班牙语-英语双语儿童在语音整形噪声背景下识别英语辅音的平均正确率与英语单语同龄儿童相似。
  • 模拟听力损失对双语和单语儿童的一般影响也相似,双语儿童英语辅音识别比单语同龄儿童更受噪声或模拟听力损失影响的原假设被否定。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究对象为11名英语主导的西班牙语-英语双语儿童(6至12岁)和12名英语单语同龄儿童,所有受试者听力正常且非言语智力与英语表达词汇与年龄相符。
  • 受试者完成听音复述言语感知任务,目标为嵌入元音-辅音-元音(VCV)音节的13个美式英语辅音。
  • VCV在安静及信噪比-5、0、5 dB的语音整形噪声中呈现(听力正常条件);模拟听力损失条件为在正常听力刺激上加入模拟轻至中度斜坡型感音神经性听力损失的阈值提升噪声,条件为0、5 dB信噪比及安静。
  • 反应按辅音正确计分,分析13个辅音平均(总体)及单个辅音表现。

主要发现

  • 如预测,两组在安静条件下表现相似。
  • 模拟听力损失对两组均有相当大的不利影响,即使在无语音整形噪声时也是如此。
  • 与预测相反,在两种条件的任何信噪比下均未观察到组间差异。
  • 尽管不显著,双语儿童在听力正常条件下的组内方差大于单语儿童,提示其「正常」范围更宽。
  • 双语儿童在两种条件下总体辅音识别均随年龄改善,而单语儿童的这种发育趋势仅在模拟听力损失条件下观察到,提示经验可能起作用。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文指出若干问题需进一步研究,包括双语与单语儿童「正常」范围的可能差异、经验的影响、实际听力损失对双语儿童的影响以及刺激质量。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the possible impact of simulated hearing loss on speech perception in Spanish-English bilingual children. To avoid confound between individual differences in hearing-loss configuration and linguistic experience, threshold-elevating noise simulating a mild-to-moderate sloping hearing loss was used with normal-hearing listeners. The hypotheses were that: (1) bilingual children can perform similarly to English-speaking monolingual peers in quiet; (2) for both bilingual and monolingual children, noise and simulated hearing loss would have detrimental impacts consistent with their acoustic characteristics (i.e., consonants with high-frequency cues remain highly intelligible in speech-shaped noise, but suffer from simulated hearing loss more than other consonants); (3) differences in phonology and acquisition order between Spanish and English would have additional negative influence on bilingual children's recognition of some English consonants. DESIGN: Listeners were 11 English-dominant, Spanish-English bilingual children (6 to 12 years old) and 12 English-speaking, monolingual age peers. All had normal hearing and age-appropriate nonverbal intelligence and expressive English vocabulary. Listeners performed a listen-and-repeat speech perception task. Targets were 13 American English consonants embedded in vowel-consonant-vowel (VCV) syllables. VCVs were presented in quiet and in speech-shaped noise at signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) of -5, 0, 5 dB (normal-hearing condition). For the simulated hearing-loss condition, threshold-elevating noise modeling a mild-to-moderate sloping sensorineural hearing loss profile was added to the normal-hearing stimuli for 0, 5 dB SNR, and quiet. Responses were scored for consonant correct. Individual listeners' performance was summarized for average across 13 consonants (overall) and for individual consonants. RESULTS: Groups were compared for the effects of background noise and simulated hearing loss. As predicted, group performed similarly in quiet. The simulated hearing loss had a considerable detrimental impact on both groups, even in the absence of speech-shaped noise. Contrary to our prediction, no group difference was observed at any SNR in either condition. However, although nonsignificant, the greater within-group variance for the bilingual children in the normal-hearing condition indicated a wider "normal" range than for the monolingual children. Interestingly, although it did not contribute to the group difference, bilingual children's overall consonant recognition in both conditions improved with age, whereas such a developmental trend for monolingual children was observed only in the simulated hearing-loss condition, suggesting possible effects of experience. As for the recognition of individual consonants, the influence of background noise or simulated hearing loss was similar between groups and was consistent with the prediction based on their acoustic characteristics. CONCLUSIONS: The results demonstrated that school-age, English-dominant, Spanish-English bilingual children can recognize English consonants in a background of speech-shaped noise with similar average accuracy as English-speaking monolingual age peers. The general impact of simulated hearing loss was also similar between bilingual and monolingual children. Thus, our hypothesis that bilingual children's English consonant recognition would suffer from background noise or simulated hearing loss more than the monolingual peers was rejected. However, the present results raise several issues that warrant further investigation, including the possible difference in the "normal" range for bilingual and monolingual children, influence of experience, impact of actual hearing loss on bilingual children, and stimulus quality.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nishi K, Trevino AC, Rosado Rogers L, et al. Effects of Simulated Hearing Loss on Bilingual Children's Consonant Recognition in Noise. Ear Hear. 2017. PMID: 28353522. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000428

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。