文献速递小儿耳鼻咽喉咽喉与嗓音

儿童部分性扁桃体切除术与全扁桃体切除术的比较效果

Comparative Effectiveness of Partial versus Total Tonsillectomy in Children.
PubMed 文献 · Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg · 2017-01-17

本综述检索1980年1月至2016年6月文献,纳入16项随机对照试验,评估儿童部分性与全扁桃体切除术的效果。部分切除术在恢复正常饮食或活动方面更具优势,但扁桃体再生长和症状复发更常见;两组在阻塞症状持续、生活质量或行为结局方面差异通常无统计学意义。数据不足以得出明确结论。

要点

  • 部分性扁桃体切除术在恢复正常饮食或活动方面优于全切除术。
  • 部分性扁桃体切除术与更多咽喉感染和扁桃体再生长相关。
  • 两种术式在阻塞症状持续、生活质量或行为结局方面差异通常无统计学意义。

核心结论

  • 数据不足以就部分性与全扁桃体切除术的比较获益得出明确结论;但手术技术和手术范围似乎均未显著影响结局。
  • 部分性扁桃体切除术在恢复正常饮食或活动方面带来中等程度优势,但也与扁桃体再生长和症状复发相关。
  • 由于人群和手术入路/技术差异,效应可能源于混杂因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 文献检索范围:MEDLINE、EMBASE和Cochrane Library,检索时间为1980年1月至2016年6月。
  • 纳入16项符合条件的随机对照试验(RCT)。
  • 两名研究者独立筛选研究并提取数据,独立评估偏倚风险和证据强度。
  • 异质性妨碍了定量分析。

主要发现

  • 在比较同一技术的4项RCT中,部分性扁桃体切除术在恢复正常饮食或活动方面更快(4项RCT均显示更有利结局)。
  • 在手术技术不同的6项研究中,部分性与全扁桃体切除术相比,恢复正常饮食和活动更快(5项研究显示更有利结局)。
  • 在4项RCT中的3项,部分性扁桃体切除术与全扁桃体切除术相比,咽喉感染更多。
  • 两组在阻塞症状持续、生活质量或行为结局方面的差异通常无统计学意义。
  • 在所有研究中,约166名儿童中有10名(6%)在部分性扁桃体切除术后出现扁桃体再生长。

关键数值与推荐

  • 16项RCT中「部分性」扁桃体切除术的定义各不相同。
  • 11项研究比较了手术技术(如低温等离子消融)。
  • 约166名儿童中10名(6%)在部分性扁桃体切除术后出现扁桃体再生长。
  • 在4项RCT中的3项,部分性扁桃体切除术与更多咽喉感染相关。
  • 在比较同一技术的4项RCT中,4项均显示部分性切除在恢复正常饮食或活动方面更有利。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 异质性妨碍了定量分析。
  • 「部分性」扁桃体切除术操作定义的异质性和差异限制了比较分析。
  • 效应可能由于人群和手术入路/技术差异而源于混杂因素。
  • 数据不足以就部分性与全扁桃体切除术的比较获益得出明确结论。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective To assess the effectiveness of partial versus total tonsillectomy in children. Data Sources MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library from January 1980 to June 2016. Review Methods Two investigators independently screened studies and extracted data. Investigators independently assessed risk of bias and strength of evidence of the literature. Heterogeneity precluded quantitative analysis. Results In 16 eligible randomized controlled trials (RCTs), definitions of "partial" tonsillectomy varied. In addition to comparing partial with total tonsil removal, 11 studies compared surgical techniques (eg, coblation). In studies comparing the same technique, return to normal diet or activity was faster with partial removal (more favorable outcomes in 4 of 4 RCTs). In studies with differing surgical techniques, return to normal diet and activity was faster with partial versus total tonsillectomy (more favorable outcomes in 5 of 6 studies). In 3 of 4 RCTs, partial tonsillectomy was associated with more throat infections than total tonsillectomy. Differences between groups were generally not statistically significant for obstructive symptom persistence, quality of life, or behavioral outcomes. Across all studies, 10 (6%) of roughly 166 children had tonsillar regrowth after partial tonsillectomy. Conclusions Data do not allow firm conclusions regarding the comparative benefit of partial versus total removal; however, neither surgical technique nor extent of surgery appears to affect outcomes markedly. Partial tonsillectomy conferred moderate advantages in return to normal diet/activity but was also associated with tonsillar regrowth and symptom recurrence. Effects may be due to confounding given differences in populations and surgical approaches/techniques. Heterogeneity and differences in the operationalization of "partial" tonsillectomy limited comparative analyses.

来源:Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sathe N, Chinnadurai S, McPheeters M, et al. Comparative Effectiveness of Partial versus Total Tonsillectomy in Children. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28093947. doi:10.1177/0194599816683916

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。