文献速递小儿耳鼻咽喉咽喉与嗓音

颌面部骨骼模型入门级3D打印的优势与局限

Benefits and Limitations of Entry-Level 3-Dimensional Printing of Maxillofacial Skeletal Models.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg · 2017-01-01

本病例系列对比了6个模型(3对),使用入门级自制3D打印与高端第三方供应商制作的儿童下颌骨模型,比较成本、解剖模型保真度和临床多功能性。自制模型测量值与商业模型相当,提示可接受精度(0.54 mm;95%CI,0.36-0.72 mm),但神经管可见性、牙根可见性和可灭菌性劣于商业模型。

要点

  • 自制入门级3D打印下颌骨模型与商业模型测量值相当,精度为0.54 mm(95%CI,0.36-0.72 mm)
  • 自制模型打印成本约90美元,其中98%与人工相关;初始固定成本包括打印机零售价2899美元和每年699美元的软件订阅费
  • 自制模型在神经管可见性、牙根可见性和可灭菌性方面劣于商业立体光刻渲染模型

核心结论

  • 这种低成本的自制入门级3D打印简单骨骼模型的方法可能适合进行颌面部重建的普通耳鼻咽喉科实践。
  • 尽管商业建模提供了一些独特功能,如可灭菌材料和高级虚拟规划,但自制建模也能产生高保真度的渲染模型,可用作教育和手术规划的工具,包括术前钛板弯制。

研究设计与样本

  • 病例系列,共6个模型(3对),对比入门级自制3D打印儿童下颌骨模型与高端第三方供应商模型,并进行文献回顾。
  • 比较在一家城市儿科耳鼻咽喉科诊所进行,对象为既往接受过儿童颅面重建并使用商业生产医疗模型进行手术规划的患者。
  • 每个供应商模型均使用计算机断层扫描成像数据制作;使用相同数据源,自制模型以聚乳酸为材料,使用市售打印机打印。
  • 数据收集时间为2015年11月1日至2015年12月30日。

主要发现

  • 自制模型(1个新生儿、1个儿童和1个成人模型)与其商业对应模型的定量比较中,对3对模型中的每一对分析7个独立测量的均值;游标卡尺测量结果显示自制模型与商业模型相当,提示可接受精度(0.54 mm;95%CI,0.36-0.72 mm)。
  • 自制生产的固定成本包括购买入门级打印机(零售价2899美元)和年度软件订阅费(每年699美元);购买这些初始资产后,自制下颌骨的打印成本约为90美元,其中98%的成本与人工相关。
  • 入门级自制模型的物理质量,如神经管可见性、牙根可见性和可灭菌性,劣于商业生产的立体光刻渲染模型。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: A protocol for creating exceptionally low-cost 3-dimensional (3-D) maxillofacial skeletal models does not require proficiency with computer software or intensive labor. Small and less affluent centers can produce models with little loss in accuracy and clinical utility. OBJECTIVES: To highlight the feasibility and methods of introducing in-house, entry-level additive manufacturing (3-D printing) technology to otolaryngologic craniofacial reconstruction and to describe its clinical applications and limitations, including a comparison with available vendor models. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This case series of 6 models (3 pairs) compared cost, side-by-side anatomical model fidelity, and clinical versatility using entry-level, in-house 3-D pediatric mandible model production vs high-end, third-party vendor modeling, including a review of the literature. Comparisons were made at an urban pediatric otolaryngology practice among patients who had previously undergone pediatric craniofacial reconstruction with use of a commercially produced medical model for surgical planning. Each vendor model had been produced using computed tomographic imaging data. With the use of this same data source, in-house models were printed in polylactic acid using a commercially available printer. Data were collected from November 1 to December 30, 2015. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Models created from these 2 methods of production were assessed for fidelity of surface anatomy, resilience to manipulation and plate bending, cost of production, speed of production, sterilizability, virtual surgical planning options, and alveolar nerve canal and tooth root visibility in mandibles. RESULTS: For the quantitative comparisons between in-house models (1 neonatal, 1 pediatric, and 1 adult model) and their commercial counterparts, the mean value of 7 independent measurements was analyzed from each of 3 model pairs. Caliper measurements from models produced through entry-level, in-house manufacturing were comparable to those taken from commercially produced counterparts, suggesting an acceptable degree of accuracy (0.54 mm; 95% CI, 0.36-0.72 mm). Fixed costs for in-house production included acquiring an entry-level printer (retail $2899) and an annual software subscription ($699 per year). After purchase of these initial assets, the printing cost for an in-house mandible was approximately $90, with 98% of that cost related to labor. Physical qualities of entry-level, in-house models such as nerve canal visibility, tooth root visibility, and sterilizability were inferior compared with commercially-produced stereolithic renderings. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This low-cost method of in-house, entry-level 3-D printing of straightforward, skeletal models may suit a general otolaryngology practice that performs maxillofacial reconstruction. Although commercial modeling offers several unique features, such as sterilizable materials and advanced virtual planning, in-house modeling also produces renderings with high fidelity, which may be used as tools for education and surgical planning, including preoperative plate bending. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4.

来源:JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Legocki AT, Duffy-Peter A, Scott AR, et al. Benefits and Limitations of Entry-Level 3-Dimensional Printing of Maxillofacial Skeletal Models. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28056140. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2016.3673

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。