智能手机耳镜在神经耳科/耳科中的应用
这项前瞻性单中心研究纳入57例成人,比较智能手机耳镜(SEO)与显微镜耳镜检查对鼓膜病变的识别与评估。单张SEO图像加简要病史对正常鼓膜的诊断正确率为96%(23/24),对显微镜确认的异常鼓膜识别率为100%(33/33);盲法医师识别病变时诊断与主治医师一致率为82%(27/33)。93%(53/57)患者对SEO使用感到非常舒适,88%(50/57)认为查看图像对理解病情非常有用。
要点
- SEO识别正常鼓膜特异度96%,识别异常鼓膜敏感度100%。
- 盲法医师基于SEO图像的诊断与主治医师一致率为82%(27/33)。
- 93%(53/57)患者对SEO使用感到非常舒适。
核心结论
- SEO识别正常鼓膜的特异度为96%,识别病变的敏感度为100%。
- 其阳性预测值为97%且假阳性率低,使其成为有用的筛查工具。
- 患者对该技术接受度高,在医疗或可能的远程医疗环境中使用感到舒适。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性单中心研究,为期3个月,纳入57例就诊于三级学术医学中心神经耳科门诊的成人。
- 患者同意后接受病史采集和显微镜耳检查,随后临床医师用SEO拍摄双侧鼓膜。
- 第二位盲法神经耳科医师接收每侧鼓膜的SEO图像和简要病史进行诊断。
主要发现
- 单张SEO鼓膜图像加简要病史对正常鼓膜的诊断正确率为96%(23/24)。
- 对显微镜确认的异常鼓膜识别率为100%(33/33)。
- 盲法医师识别病变时,诊断与主治医师完全一致率为82%(27/33)。
- 患者调查中93%(53/57)对SEO使用感到非常舒适。
- 88%(50/57)报告查看获取的图像对理解病情非常有用。
关键数值与推荐
- SEO识别正常鼓膜特异度96%,识别病变敏感度100%。
- 阳性预测值97%,假阳性率低。
- 盲法医师与主治医师诊断一致率82%(27/33)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为SEO阳性预测值97%且假阳性率低,使其成为有用的筛查工具。
- 作者指出患者对该技术接受度高,在医疗或可能的远程医疗环境中使用感到舒适。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective A smartphone-enabled otoscope (SEO) can capture tympanic membrane (TM) images. We sought to compare a SEO to microscopic otoscopy in the detection and evaluation of TM pathology in an otology/neurotology practice. Study Design Prospective single-site study in adults presenting over a 3-month period. Setting Neurotology clinic within a tertiary care academic medical center. Subjects and Methods Following consent, 57 patients underwent a medical and microscopic ear examination. Afterward, clinicians photographed bilateral TMs using a SEO. A second "blinded" neurotologist received a SEO-acquired image of each TM and a brief patient history. Our primary end point was identification of TM pathology (or lack thereof) and the blinded neurotologists' corresponding diagnosis. Secondary end points included patient-reported SEO comfort levels. Results A single SEO-acquired TM image and brief patient history resulted in correct diagnosis of 96% (23/24) of normal TMs and identification of 100% (33/33) of microscope-confirmed abnormal TMs. When pathology was identified by the "blinded" physician, the diagnosis was identical to that made by the primary treating physician 82% (27/33) of the time. On patient surveys, 93% (53/57) of patients felt "very comfortable" with SEO utilization, and 88% (50/57) reported viewing acquired images was "very useful" in understanding their condition. Conclusion A SEO is 96% specific in identifying normal TMs and 100% sensitive in identifying pathology. Its 97% positive predictive value and small false-positive rate makes it a useful screening tool. Furthermore, patients are receptive to this technology and felt comfortable with its utilization in a health care or possible telemedicine setting.
引用
- Moshtaghi O, Sahyouni R, Haidar YM, et al. Smartphone-Enabled Otoscopy in Neurotology/Otology. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2017. PMID: 28118550. doi:10.1177/0194599816687740
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。