文献速递耳科与耳神经

单侧听力损失:理解言语识别与定位能力的变异性——对人工耳蜗候选资格选择的启示

Unilateral Hearing Loss: Understanding Speech Recognition and Localization Variability-Implications for Cochlear Implant Candidacy.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2017-01-01

研究比较了成人重度至极重度单侧听力损失(UHL)者与双侧正常听力者、单侧正常听力者的言语识别与定位能力。UHL者的听觉能力变异很大,仅部分由听阈解释;发病年龄和病程影响部分而非全部指标。结果支持在考虑人工耳蜗候选资格时采用包括声源定位和不同环境言语识别在内的多样化临床测量。

要点

  • UHL者听觉能力变异大,听阈仅能部分解释其表现。
  • 儿童期发病的UHL者定位能力显著优于近期发病者,但噪声下言语识别两组无差异。
  • UHL者听阈与言语识别显著相关,另两组无此相关。

核心结论

  • UHL者的听觉能力差异很大,仅部分可由听阈水平解释;发病年龄和听力损失时长影响部分而非全部指标的表现。
  • 结果支持在考虑重度至极重度UHL者作为潜在人工耳蜗候选者时,需要修订并采用多样化的临床测量,包括声源定位、不同环境下的言语理解和功能能力的仔细考量。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究评估了成人重度至极重度UHL者和成人双侧正常听力者。
  • 设有三个年龄-性别匹配组:UHL组(一耳重度至极重度听力损失,对侧耳正常听力)、双侧正常听力组和单侧正常听力组。
  • 测量包括弥漫餐厅噪声下的自适应句子理解、定位、移动声源言语识别(140°弧内15名说话者之一的词语)以及变化噪声类型和噪声源位置的自适应言语接受阈心理声学任务。

主要发现

  • 双侧正常听力组在所有测量上的得分显著优于UHL组且表现变异性更小,但部分UHL参与者在所有测量上的得分落在双侧正常听力组的范围内。
  • 单侧正常听力参与者在阻塞/聋侧的词语单音节词理解优于UHL者,但在开放/听力侧无此优势。
  • UHL者在开放/听力侧的定位优于单侧正常听力者,但在阻塞/聋侧无此优势,提示UHL者已习得改善完好耳侧定位的策略。
  • UHL组与单侧正常听力组在噪声下言语识别测量上无显著差异。
  • 儿童期发病的UHL参与者定位能力显著优于近期发病者,但两组在噪声下言语识别上无差异。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,随着重度至极重度UHL者被考虑为潜在人工耳蜗候选者,需要修订并采用多样化的临床测量,包括声源定位、不同环境下的言语理解以及对功能能力的仔细考量。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: At a minimum, unilateral hearing loss (UHL) impairs sound localization ability and understanding speech in noisy environments, particularly if the loss is severe to profound. Accompanying the numerous negative consequences of UHL is considerable unexplained individual variability in the magnitude of its effects. Identification of covariables that affect outcome and contribute to variability in UHLs could augment counseling, treatment options, and rehabilitation. Cochlear implantation as a treatment for UHL is on the rise yet little is known about factors that could impact performance or whether there is a group at risk for poor cochlear implant outcomes when hearing is near-normal in one ear. The overall goal of our research is to investigate the range and source of variability in speech recognition in noise and localization among individuals with severe to profound UHL and thereby help determine factors relevant to decisions regarding cochlear implantation in this population. DESIGN: The present study evaluated adults with severe to profound UHL and adults with bilateral normal hearing. Measures included adaptive sentence understanding in diffuse restaurant noise, localization, roving-source speech recognition (words from 1 of 15 speakers in a 140° arc), and an adaptive speech-reception threshold psychoacoustic task with varied noise types and noise-source locations. There were three age-sex-matched groups: UHL (severe to profound hearing loss in one ear and normal hearing in the contralateral ear), normal hearing listening bilaterally, and normal hearing listening unilaterally. RESULTS: Although the normal-hearing-bilateral group scored significantly better and had less performance variability than UHLs on all measures, some UHL participants scored within the range of the normal-hearing-bilateral group on all measures. The normal-hearing participants listening unilaterally had better monosyllabic word understanding than UHLs for words presented on the blocked/deaf side but not the open/hearing side. In contrast, UHLs localized better than the normal-hearing unilateral listeners for stimuli on the open/hearing side but not the blocked/deaf side. This suggests that UHLs had learned strategies for improved localization on the side of the intact ear. The UHL and unilateral normal-hearing participant groups were not significantly different for speech in noise measures. UHL participants with childhood rather than recent hearing loss onset localized significantly better; however, these two groups did not differ for speech recognition in noise. Age at onset in UHL adults appears to affect localization ability differently than understanding speech in noise. Hearing thresholds were significantly correlated with speech recognition for UHL participants but not the other two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Auditory abilities of UHLs varied widely and could be explained only in part by hearing threshold levels. Age at onset and length of hearing loss influenced performance on some, but not all measures. Results support the need for a revised and diverse set of clinical measures, including sound localization, understanding speech in varied environments, and careful consideration of functional abilities as individuals with severe to profound UHL are being considered potential cochlear implant candidates.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Firszt JB, Reeder RM, Holden LK, et al. Unilateral Hearing Loss: Understanding Speech Recognition and Localization Variability-Implications for Cochlear Implant Candidacy. Ear Hear. 2017. PMID: 28067750. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000000380

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。