文献速递头颈外科咽喉与嗓音

PRESTO试验成本效果分析:头颈癌放化疗期间预防性吞咽训练

Cost Effectiveness Analysis of the Presto-Trial: A Three-Armed RCT Evaluating Prophylactic Swallowing Exercises in Head and Neck Cancer Patients During (Chemo)radio Treatment.
PubMed 文献 · Head Neck · 2026-10-20

三组效用无显著组间差异,仅时间效应显著;结论认为治疗师主导的每日训练相对于纸质自我管理不具成本效果。

要点

  • 三组吞咽训练模式在效用上无显著组间差异,仅时间效应显著。
  • 治疗师主导组成本最高,APP组效用与纸质组相当但成本更高而被支配。

核心结论

  • 在资源有限条件下,治疗师主导的每日预防性吞咽训练相对于纸质自我管理不具成本效果,低成本交付模式是更经济高效的选择。

主要发现

  • 三组效用(EQ5D5L)无显著组间差异,仅时间效应显著:从基线到放化疗后效用显著下降,从放化疗后到3个月显著上升。
  • 治疗师主导干预成本最高,APP组效用与纸质组相当但成本更高,因此APP组被纸质组支配。

关键数值与推荐

  • 治疗师主导组在放化疗期间接受每日面对面训练,共20次治疗。
  • 成本从卫生服务视角估算,包括员工时间、治疗资源和消耗品;效用基于EQ5D5L在基线、放化疗后和放化疗后3个月测量;ICER计算为Δ成本/ΔQALY。

临床怎么用

  • 在当前资源约束下,可优先考虑纸质自我管理等低成本交付模式进行预防性吞咽训练。
  • 治疗师主导的每日面对面训练虽然可能带来生活质量改善,但成本过高,需权衡资源投入。
  • 未来可探索混合或靶向治疗师参与模式,以在保留临床获益的同时降低成本。

局限性

  • 原文未报告

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Research on oropharyngeal head and neck cancer (HNC) patients indicates that prophylactic swallowing exercises (PSE) during (C)RT can positively affect muscle strength, swallowing function and quality of life (QOL). Primary analyses of the PRESTO-trial showed higher adherence rates for PSE when exercising daily with a speech-language pathologist (SLP), compared to self-guided exercises with either an exercise diary or a digital application. Additionally, higher adherence rates were related to greater improvements in swallowing function and QOL. However, given limited healthcare resources, cost-effectiveness analyses are essential to inform the implementation of such rehabilitation strategies in dysphagia care. This secondary analysis of the PRESTO-data compares the costs and health effects of the three different service models: app-based, therapist-led (daily face-to-face, 20 sessions during (C)RT), and paper-led therapy. METHODS: One hundred fifty patients receiving (chemo)radiotherapy (C)RT for oropharyngeal HNC were randomly assigned to one of the three exercise groups. All performing the same PSE protocol. The treatment protocol required daily training during the first 4 weeks of the (C)RT treatment program. Patients in the therapy group thereby received a total of 20 face-to-face therapy sessions. Health outcomes were expressed as utilities based on the EQ5D5L instrument measured at baseline, post (C)RT and 3 months post (C)RT. Costs were estimated from a health service perspective, including staff time, therapy resources and consumables. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) were calculated as ΔCosts/ ΔQALYs. RESULTS: No significant between-group differences were found for utilities. Only significant time effects were observed, with a significant decrease in utilities from baseline to post (C)RT and a significant increase from post (C)RT to 3 months post (C)RT. The therapist-led intervention was associated with the highest costs. The app-group intervention was dominated by the paper group in terms of cost-effectiveness as the utilities were comparable but at a higher cost in the app-group. Consequently, the ICER was computed between the paper-group and therapist-group and resulted in € 124 061,54/QALY. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the overall positive HR-QOL effects post 3 months, the daily therapist-led delivery of PSE therapy was not cost-effective relative to paper-based self-management. Under current resource constraints, low-cost delivery models represent the most economically efficient option. Future research should explore whether hybrid or targeted therapist involvement yields better value by preserving clinical benefit while reducing cost.

来源:Head Neck,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vergauwen A, Van den Steen L, Baudelet M, et al. Cost Effectiveness Analysis of the Presto-Trial: A Three-Armed RCT Evaluating Prophylactic Swallowing Exercises in Head and Neck Cancer Patients During (Chemo)radio Treatment. Head Neck. 2026. PMID: 42902836. doi:10.1002/hed.70515

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。