OSA患者DISE下上气道多平面塌陷的机制分析
前瞻性纳入107例中重度OSA患者,行上气道CT、DISE及颏舌肌肌电监测,按VOTE系统分类比较塌陷模式。发现多平面塌陷是解剖与功能因素共同作用,VOTE系统不能准确描述不同平面解剖和功能病因的影响,口咽侧壁、舌根及会厌塌陷程度均受颏舌肌功能影响。
要点
- 107例中重度OSA患者均存在腭后区完全塌陷,ggEMG功能参数在三种腭后塌陷模式间无统计学差异。
- 口咽完全塌陷且舌后部分塌陷者BMI更高、舌后气道更长更窄,阻塞性呼吸暂停时ggEMG功能异常更明显。
- 会厌完全塌陷者腭后截面积和舌后前后径最小、舌后气道最长;无会厌塌陷者清醒期和入睡初期ggEMG激活水平较低。
核心结论
- DISE下上气道多平面塌陷是解剖及功能因素共同作用的结果,VOTE评分系统无法正确描述不同平面解剖和功能病因对气道塌陷的影响。
- 口咽侧壁、舌根及会厌的塌陷程度均可受到颏舌肌功能的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,纳入2019年9月至2023年4月于清华大学北京清华长庚医院确诊的中重度OSA成年患者107例,其中男101例、女6例,年龄20~59(38.8±8.0)岁,AHI≥15次/h。
- 每例研究对象均进行清醒上气道CT平扫、DISE下口内表面颏舌肌肌电(ggEMG)监测,并根据VOTE评分系统分类比较。
主要发现
- 107例中重度OSA患者均存在腭后区完全塌陷,其中前后塌陷组47例、左右塌陷组10例、环形塌陷组50例。
- 三种腭后塌陷模式组间ggEMG功能参数差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05);腭后左右塌陷组腭后左右径最窄[前后、左右和环形塌陷组分别为14.45(12.0,16.2)mm、11.40(9.6,14.4)mm、12.70(11.0,15.8)mm,H=6.41,P=0.041],舌后前后径最宽[分别为11.95(9.0,15.7)mm、14.30(11.8,20.3)mm、14.10(11.8,16.9)mm,H=8.40,P=0.015]。
- 与O1T1组相比,O2T1组BMI较高[(29.43±3.35)kg/m2 vs.(26.70±2.53)kg/m2,t=-2.83,P=0.007]、舌后气道更长[(25.94±5.80)mm vs.(20.90±5.48)mm,t=-2.60,P=0.014]、舌后左右径更窄[(15.59±3.87)mm vs.(21.10±8.07)mm,t=2.59,P=0.017],且阻塞性呼吸暂停事件中ggEMG功能异常更明显[R4,(0.02±0.01)vs.(0.01±0.01),t=2.08,P=0.045]。
- 按会厌塌陷程度分类:E0组31例、E1组33例、E2组43例;E2组腭后截面积最小(H=11.01,P=0.004)、舌后前后径最小(H=7.06,P=0.029)、舌后气道最长(H=9.65,P=0.008);E0组清醒期(R1,H=8.59,P=0.014)与入睡初期(R2,H=9.79,P=0.007)ggEMG激活水平较低。
临床怎么用
- 对中重度OSA多平面塌陷患者,除解剖评估外应关注颏舌肌功能状态,以全面判断塌陷病因。
- VOTE评分系统不能准确反映不同平面解剖和功能病因的影响,临床病因分析需结合ggEMG等功能指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To assess the anatomical and genioglossus electromyography (ggEMG) indicators in obstruction patterns classified by the VOTE system. Methods: This prospective study was conducted from September 2019 to April 2023, with a total of 107 adult patients (101 males and 6 females) aged 20-59 (38.8±8.0) years old (AHI≥15 times/hour) diagnosed with moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) at Beijing Tsinghua Changgung Hospital. Each subject underwent 3-D upper airway computed tomography (UACT), drug-induced sleep endoscopy and intraoral surface ggEMG monitoring. Based on VOTE system, the characteristics of UA collapses were classified and compared. Statistical analysis was conducted by SPSS 21.0. Results: All 107 patients with moderate to severe OSA had complete collapse of the velopharynx airway (including 47 cases in anteroposterior collapse group, 10 cases in the lateral collapse group, and 50 cases in the concentric collapse group). Comparing patient data from three different collapse modes, it was found that the velum pattern groups showed no statistical ggEMG differences (P>0.05); however, the lateral group exhibited the narrowest velopharynx mLAT [AP: 14.45(12.0, 16.2) mm, Lat: 11.40(9.6, 14.4) mm, Con: 12.70(11.0, 15.8) mm,H=6.41, P=0.041], and largest glossopharynx mAP[AP: 11.90(9.0, 15.7) mm, Lat: 14.30(11.8, 20.3) mm, Con: 14.10(11.8, 16.9) mm,H=8.40, P=0.015]. We found that patients with complete oropharynx lateral walls and partial tongue base collapse tended to have a higher BMI [(29.43±3.35)kg/m2 vs.(26.70±2.53) kg/m2,t=-2.83, P=0.007], longer glossopharynx length [(25.94±5.80) mm vs. (20.90±5.48)mm, t=-2.60,P=0.014], narrower glossopharynx mLAT [(15.59±3.87) mm vs. (21.10±8.07) mm, t=2.59, P=0.017], and were more likely to combine ggEMG dysfunction during obstructive apnea events [R4,(0.02±0.01)vs.(0.01±0.01), t=2.08, P=0.045)]. Moreover, all patients were classified according to the degree of epiglottic collapse (including 31 cases of no collapse, 33 cases of patial collapse, and 43 cases of complete collapse). The complete epiglottic collapse group exhibited the narrowest velopharynx minimal cross-sectional airway area (H=11.01, P=0.004) and the narrowest glossopharynx anteroposterior airway dimensions (H=7.06, P=0.029) and the longest glossopharynx length (H=9.65,P=0.008), whereas, the group of no epiglottic collapse showed the lowest ggEMG activation while awake (R1,H=8.59,P=0.014) and during sleep-onset (R2,H=9.79,P=0.007). Conclusions: The multiple plane collapse of the UA under DISE is the result of the combined effects of anatomical and functional factors, while the VOTE system cannot accurately describe the impact of different anatomical and functional causes. Among them, the degree of oropharynx lateral walls, tongue base and epiglottic collapse can all be affected by the function of the genioglossus muscle. This study can provide a theoretical basis for the comprehensive etiological treatment of OSA patients with multiple plane collapse. 目的: 基于VOTE[腭后(V),口咽侧壁(O),舌根(T),会厌(E)]评分系统分析阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停(OSA)患者药物诱导睡眠内镜(DISE)下上气道多平面阻塞部位、模式和程度的影响机制。 方法: 该前瞻性队列研究纳入2019年9月至2023年4月于清华大学北京清华长庚医院耳鼻咽喉头颈外科确诊的中重度OSA的成年患者107例(AHI≥15 次/h),其中男101例,女6例,年龄20~59(38.8±8.0)岁。对每例研究对象均进行清醒上气道CT平扫及DISE下的口内表面颏舌肌肌电(ggEMG)监测。根据VOTE评分系统将不同层面的塌陷模式进行分类比较。采用Kruskal-Wallis H检验或独立样本t检验。多组间比较采用方差分析。 结果: 107例中重度OSA患者均存在腭后区完全塌陷,其中前后塌陷组47例、左右塌陷组10例、环形塌陷组50例。对比3种不同塌陷模式的患者数据发现,3组间ggEMG的功能参数差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05);腭后左右塌陷组的腭后左右径最窄[前后、左右和环形塌陷组分别为:14.45(12.0,16.2)mm、11.40(9.6,14.4)mm、12.70(11.0,15.8)mm,H=6.41,P=0.041],且舌后前后径最宽[前后、左右和环形塌陷组分别为:11.95(9.0,15.7)mm、14.30(11.8,20.3)mm、14.10(11.8,16.9)mm,H=8.40,P=0.015]。与口咽部和舌后部分塌陷的OSA患者(O1T1组)相比,口咽部完全塌陷且舌后部分塌陷患者(O2T1组)的BMI较高[(29.43±3.35)kg/m2 vs.(26.70±2.53)kg/m2,t=-2.83,P=0.007]、舌后气道更长[(25.94±5.80)mm vs.(20.90±5.48)mm,t=-2.60,P=0.014]、舌后左右径更窄[(15.59±3.87)mm vs.(21.10±8.07)mm,t=2.59,P=0.017],且在发生阻塞性呼吸暂停事件中可表现出ggEMG功能异常(R4,(0.02±0.01)vs.(0.01±0.01),t=2.08,P=0.045)。将107例中重度OSA患者按照会厌塌陷程度分类,其中0级会厌塌陷(E0组)31例,1级会厌塌陷(E1组)33例,2级会厌塌陷(E2组)43 例。其中E2组患者具有最小的腭后截面积(H=11.01,P=0.004)和舌后前后径(H=7.06,P=0.029),以及最长舌后气道(H=9.65,P=0.008)。E0组清醒期(R1,H=8.59,P=0.014)与入睡初期(R2,H=9.79,P=0.007)的ggEMG激活水平较低。 结论: DISE下上气道多平面塌陷是解剖及功能因素共同作用的结果,而VOTE评分系统无法正确描述不同平面解剖和功能病因对于气道塌陷的影响。其中,口咽侧壁、舌根及会厌的塌陷程度均可受到颏舌肌功能的影响。.
引用
- Zhou YQ, Xu JK, Yin GP, et al. [Mechanism analysis of the site, pattern, and degree of upper airway multiple plane collapse during drug-induced sleep endoscopy in patients with obstructive sleep apnea]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 42811548. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20251111-00591
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。