4D-CT与支气管镜诊断气管软化症的评分者间与评分者内信度比较
本研究纳入10例不同程度动态气管塌陷患者,比较硬质支气管镜视频与4D-CT气道分割在评估气管软化严重程度时的评分者间与评分者内信度。
要点
- 支气管镜评估气管软化严重程度的评分者间与评分者内信度均高于4D-CT。
- 两种方法在评分者间与评分者内均达到高度一致水平。
- 未来需明确两种 modality 的最佳角色以建立标准化严重程度评级。
核心结论
- 内镜评估在气管软化严重程度判定上的评分者间与评分者内信度均高于4D-CT。
研究设计与样本
- 收集10例不同程度动态气管塌陷患者的去标识化硬质支气管镜视频与4D-CT气道分割,共20段视频供评估。
- 采用随机化多学科问卷,由两家机构的耳鼻咽喉科、呼吸科、普外科和放射科医师在间隔1个月的两个时间点对全部病例的塌陷严重程度进行评分。
- 使用Gwet的AC2评估评分者间与评分者内信度,取值0表示轻微一致、1表示几乎完全一致。
主要发现
- 支气管镜评分者间信度在T1为AC2=0.79(95%CI[0.57,1])、T2为AC2=0.76(95%CI[0.52,1])。
- 4D-CT分割评分者间信度在T1为AC2=0.66(95%CI[0.44,0.89])、T2为AC2=0.68(95%CI[0.39,0.97])。
- 支气管镜评分者内信度为AC2=0.91(95%CI[0.87,0.96]),4D-CT为AC2=0.84(95%CI[0.76,0.91])。
临床怎么用
- 在评估气管软化严重程度时,支气管镜的信度优于4D-CT,可作为更可靠的评估依据。
- 未来研究应明确两种方法的最佳应用场景,以建立标准化严重程度评级并改善手术候选者的识别。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Bronchoscopy and 4D-CT can be used to diagnose and characterize tracheomalacia. This study aims to assess inter- and intra-rater reliability of rigid bronchoscopy and 4D-CT imaging in determining tracheomalacia severity. METHODS: De-identified rigid bronchoscopy videos and 4D-CT derived airway segmentations were collected for 10 patients with varying degrees of dynamic tracheal collapse, for a total of 20 videos for review. A randomized, multidisciplinary survey was administered to physicians from otolaryngology, pulmonology, general surgery, and radiology at two institutions. Participants rated the severity of collapse for all cases at two time points, 1 month apart. Gwet's AC2 was used to assess inter- and intra-rater reliability, with values ranging from 0 (slight agreement) to 1 (almost perfect agreement). RESULTS: Nineteen physicians completed the initial ratings (T1), and 12 completed the repeat ratings 1 month later (T2). Inter-rater agreement for bronchoscopy was substantial at T1 (AC2 = 0.79, 95% CI: [0.57, 1]) and at T2 (AC2 = 0.76, 95% CI [0.52, 1]). Similarly, ratings of 4D-CT segmentations demonstrated substantial agreement initially (T1: AC2 = 0.66, 95% CI [0.44, 0.89]) and at T2 (AC2 = 0.68, 95% CI [0.39, 0.97]). Bronchoscopy (AC2 = 0.91, 95% CI: [0.87, 0.96]) and 4D-CT (AC2 = 0.84, 95% CI: [0.76, 0.91]) had substantial agreement for intra-rater reliability. CONCLUSION: Endoscopic assessment showed higher inter- and intra-rater reliability than 4D-CT. Future studies should focus on defining the optimal role of these modalities to establish a standardized severity rating, thereby improving identification of surgical candidates.
引用
- Case HF, Amin S, Wang X, et al. Inter- and Intra-Rater Reliability of 4D-CT Versus Bronchoscopy in Diagnosing and Grading Tracheomalacia. Laryngoscope. 2026. PMID: 42530134. doi:10.1002/lary.70774
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。