听力助听器外化感知与自身语音及堵塞效应的关系
该研究纳入10名正常听力年轻成人和10名感音神经性听力损失年轻成人,均佩戴封闭式和开放式助听器,比较外化感知与自身语音自然度评分,并用真耳测量客观堵塞。结果显示无助听比助听、开放比封闭外化评分更高;自身语音评分趋势类似,但客观堵塞不能解释评分变异,个体自身语音评分也不能预测外化评分。
要点
- 助听器降低声音外化感知和自身语音自然度,封闭式比开放式影响更大。
- 客观堵塞程度与个体外化或自身语音评分无显著相关。
- 长期佩戴的助听器可能改善自身语音感知但干扰外化。
核心结论
- 与无助听相比,助听器对外化感知和自身语音感知均有负面影响,封闭式比开放式影响更大。
- 个体层面上,客观堵塞测量与外化感知无强关联,自身语音评分也不能预测外化评分。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入10名正常听力年轻成人和10名感音神经性听力损失年轻成人。
- 所有参与者佩戴封闭式和开放式助听器,助听器使用者还测试其自用设备。
- 外化感知用0(颅内)到10(扬声器处)数字量表测量,自身语音自然度用1(最不自然)到10(最自然)主观量表评分。
- 堵塞效应通过真耳测量对开放式和封闭式佩戴进行客观评估。
主要发现
- 外化评分在无助听时显著高于助听时,开放式耳塞显著高于封闭式耳塞。
- 自身语音评分在无助听时倾向于高于助听时,开放式耳塞倾向于高于封闭式耳塞。
- 客观堵塞测量未显著解释外化或自身语音评分的变异。
- 个体自身语音评分未显著预测个体外化评分。
- 助听器使用者佩戴自用设备的数据提示,规律佩戴的设备可能对自身语音感知有正面影响,但干扰外化感知。
临床怎么用
- 临床选配助听器时,封闭式耳塞可能更明显影响患者对声音外化和自身语音自然度的感知。
- 评估患者主观外化或自身语音困扰时,不能仅依赖客观堵塞测量。
局限性
- 样本量较小(每组10人),可能限制个体差异分析的统计效力。
- 研究未报告客观堵塞解释评分变异的具體数值(如方差解释量或P值)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: A recent study found that hearing aids fitted with highly occluding domes had an impact on the perception of externally presented speech, producing sound images that were perceived as too close or even inside the head. The present study examined whether this phenomenon is related to the well-known occlusion effect, which describes changes in ear canal levels and perceived own-voice quality during speaking. DESIGN: Participants were 10 young adults with normal hearing and 10 young adults with sensorineural hearing loss. All participants were fitted with both closed- and open-fit hearing aids, and hearing aid users were also tested with their own devices. Externalization was measured using a numerical scale from 0 (inside the head) to 10 (at the loudspeaker). Participants also rated the naturalness of their own voice while speaking using a subjective scale from 1 (most unnatural) to 10 (most natural). Occlusion was also measured objectively for open and closed fittings using real ear measurements. RESULTS: Externalization ratings were significantly higher for unaided than aided listening and for open versus closed domes. Similarly, own-voice ratings tended to be higher for unaided versus aided listening and for open versus closed domes. Although these broad patterns suggest that reduced ratings are associated with more occlusion, objective measures of occlusion did not account for a significant amount of the variance in either kind of rating. Similarly, individual own-voice ratings did not significantly predict individual externalization ratings. The data obtained with hearing aid users wearing their own devices suggested that regularly worn devices can have positive effects on own-voice perception while disrupting externalization. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, compared with unaided listening, hearing aids negatively affected externalization and own-voice perception, with larger effects for closed than open fittings. However, at the individual level, measures of occlusion and sound externalization were not strongly related.
引用
- Ertürk P, Best V. Relating Sound Externalization, Own-Voice Perception, and Occlusion in Adults With Hearing Aids. Ear Hear. 2026. PMID: 42478026. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001870
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。