老年喉与喉部不对称不能预测65岁及以上患者发声困难
结果显示,两组间视频喉镜特征无差异;发声困难组VHI-10更高(13 vs. 2)、BMI更低(26.5 vs. 28.3),但老年喉和喉部不对称均与发声困难无关。
要点
- 老年喉和喉部不对称在65岁以上人群中常见,但与发声困难无关。
- 发声困难组VHI-10更高、BMI更低,但年龄、性别和身高无差异。
- 视频喉镜特征不能区分老年发声困难患者。
核心结论
- 在65岁及以上患者中,老年喉或喉部不对称与发声困难无关。
主要发现
- 发声困难组VHI-10显著高于非发声困难组(13 vs. 2),BMI显著更低(26.5 vs. 28.3)。
- 两组在年龄、性别和身高上无差异。
- 146例(73%)有3项老年喉表现:声带弓形、声带突突出、内收时声带突接触先于声带中段接触。
- 171例(85.5%)有整体喉部不对称,166例(83%)有相位不对称,131例(65.5%)有声带运动速度或幅度不对称。
- 仅24例(每组12例)显示心室显露增加、对侧假声带收缩和杓间切迹倾斜三联征,提示可能的神经性麻痹。
关键数值与推荐
- 发声困难组VHI-10中位数13,非发声困难组2。
- 发声困难组BMI中位数26.5,非发声困难组28.3。
- 老年喉表现与性别、年龄和身高相关,但与发声困难无关。
临床怎么用
- 视频喉镜下的老年喉和喉部不对称表现不能用于预测或诊断老年发声困难。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Presbyphonia and presbylarynx are common in aging people. Presbylarynx and laryngeal asymmetry increase with age and are visible on videostroboscopy. The purpose of this study was to determine if findings of presbylarynx or overall laryngeal asymmetry could be linked with patient-reported dysphonia. METHODS: Two hundred exams of patients over 64 were included: 100 with and 100 without voice complaints. Their videostroboscopic exams were evaluated for presbylarynx and laryngeal asymmetry. RESULTS: Median age was 72 (65-95) and 127 (63.5%) were female. No videostroboscopic exam features distinguished the dysphonia patients from those without. The dysphonia group had a significantly higher VHI-10 (13 vs. 2) and lower BMI (26.5 vs. 28.3) than the non-dysphonia group but did not differ in age, gender, nor height. Gender, age, and height were associated with findings of presbylarynx but not with dysphonia. 146 (73%) had 3 findings of presbylarynx (bowing, vocal process prominence, and vocal process contact preceding midfold contact at adduction). 171 (85.5%) patients had overall laryngeal asymmetry, 166 (83%) had phase asymmetry, and 131 (65.5%) had asymmetric speed or range of motion of the vocal folds. Only 24 (12 in each group) displayed the triad of increased ventricular show, contralateral false vocal fold contraction, and interarytenoid cleft tilt consistent with possible neurogenic paresis. CONCLUSION: Neither presbylarynx nor laryngeal asymmetry was associated with dysphonia in patients age 65 and over. Pathologic presbyphonia remains a complaint without a universal distinguishing group of predictive features, complicating patient care and treatment.
引用
- Crawley BK, Vegar I, Dehom S, et al. Presbylarynx and Laryngeal Asymmetry as Predictors of Dysphonia in Patients 65 and Over. Laryngoscope. 2026. PMID: 42260323. doi:10.1002/lary.70639
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。