文献速递鼻科

内镜鼻窦手术范围评估:评分系统的范围综述

Assessing Surgical Extent in Endoscopic Sinus Surgery: A Scoping Review of Scoring Systems.
PubMed 文献 · Int Forum Allergy Rhinol · 2026-06-01

综述区分了手术范围与手术完整性两个维度,指出CT类工具多评估完整性,术中分类评估范围,并强调结构化评分可揭示指南标准下解剖切除的差异,但证据多为回顾性,亟需前瞻性验证。

要点

  • CT类工具主要评估手术完整性,术中分类评估手术范围,两者不可互换。
  • CoSI与术后结局关联最一致,既往手术不完整者修正性ESS获益更大。
  • ACCESS在生物学反应预测中显示初步效用,LOEM是唯一有结局关联的术中系统。

核心结论

  • CT类与术中类工具捕捉既往手术的不同维度,应根据临床或研究问题选择。
  • 结构化评分一致显示,许多符合指南既往手术标准的患者解剖切除范围存在差异。
  • 手术范围的标准化评估值得评估以整合入临床决策,但亟需前瞻性验证。

研究设计与样本

  • 遵循PRISMA-ScR指南的范围综述,系统检索PubMed/MEDLINE、Scopus和Web of Science。

主要发现

  • 纳入工具涵盖CT类评分(ACCESS、CoSI、SSCS、REC评分)、术中分类(LOEM、完整vs靶向、JRS)、放射-手术一致性指标及研究特定工具。
  • CoSI与结局关联最一致,既往手术不完整预测修正性ESS获益更大。
  • ACCESS在生物学反应预测中显示初步效用。
  • LOEM是唯一有结局关联的术中系统,但证据限于单一团队。
  • 总体证据有限且以回顾性为主。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识别11种工具:CT类包括ACCESS、CoSI、SSCS、REC评分;术中类包括LOEM、完整vs靶向、JRS;另有放射-手术一致性指标及研究特定工具。

临床怎么用

  • 临床或研究中选择工具时需明确评估目的是手术范围还是手术完整性。
  • CT类工具适用于评估解剖结果完整性,术中分类适用于记录实际切除范围。
  • 结构化评分有助于识别既往手术解剖差异,可能影响修正手术或生物学治疗决策。

局限性

  • 总体证据有限,且以回顾性研究为主。
  • LOEM的结局关联证据仅来自单一团队。
  • 亟需前瞻性验证以支持临床决策整合。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) varies substantially in the extent of surgical dissection performed, even when described under the same procedural label. In chronic rhinosinusitis, this heterogeneity may influence postoperative outcomes, revision rates, and response to biologic therapies. This review aimed to identify and characterize available instruments for assessing surgical extent after ESS. METHODS: Scoping review following PRISMA-ScR guidelines with systematic search of PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science. RESULTS: Twenty-one studies describing 11 instruments were included: spanning computed tomography (CT)-based scores (Amsterdam Classification of Completeness of Endoscopic Sinus Surgery [ACCESS], Completion of Surgery Index [CoSI], Sinus Surgery Completeness Score [SSCS], and Residual Ethmoid Cell [REC] score), intraoperative classifications (Lamella-Ostium-Extent-Mucosa [LOEM], complete vs. targeted, and Japanese Rhinologic Society [JRS]), radiologic-surgical concordance metrics, and study-specific tools. A key conceptual distinction emerged between surgical extent (the procedure performed) and surgical completeness (the anatomical result achieved). CT-based instruments primarily assess completeness, whereas intraoperative classifications capture extent. Because similar procedures may yield different anatomical results, these dimensions are not interchangeable. Among CT-based instruments, CoSI demonstrated the most consistent outcome associations, with incomplete prior surgery predicting greater benefit from revision ESS. ACCESS showed preliminary utility in biologic response prediction. LOEM is the only intraoperative system with reported outcome associations, although evidence is limited to a single group. Overall, evidence across instruments remains limited and predominantly retrospective. CONCLUSIONS: CT-based and intraoperative instruments capture different dimensions of prior surgery and should be selected according to the clinical or research question. Notably, structured scoring consistently reveals that many patients meeting guideline criteria for prior surgery have varying anatomical dissection. Given the association between surgical extent, postoperative outcomes, and biologic therapy response, its standardized assessment warrants evaluation for integration into clinical decision making. However, prospective validation is urgently needed.

来源:Int Forum Allergy Rhinol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lein A, Ehrgott MT, Liu L, et al. Assessing Surgical Extent in Endoscopic Sinus Surgery: A Scoping Review of Scoring Systems. Int Forum Allergy Rhinol. 2026. PMID: 42223914. doi:10.1002/alr.70191

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。