成人人工耳蜗双耳与单耳在安静下言语识别的匹配纵向分析
单中心回顾性队列纳入2013年2月至2025年3月植入的184例语后聋成人(109例单耳、75例双耳),经1:1倾向评分匹配后各60例。匹配后双耳在单音节词识别上显著优于单耳(β=12.70,p=0.005),该优势不受年龄组影响,且不能归因于设备使用量差异。
要点
- 双耳人工耳蜗在安静下单音节词识别较小单耳显著获益(β=12.70,p=0.005)
- 该优势与累积听觉经验无交互,提示非使用量或选择偏倚所致
- 年龄组20至50岁与50至70岁间双耳效应无显著差异
核心结论
- 严格匹配的纵向队列显示,双耳人工耳蜗在安静下单音节词识别上较小单耳具有稳健优势。
- 该优势不能归因于设备使用量差异,且年龄组间无显著效应修饰,提示年龄无关的双侧获益。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性队列,纳入2013年2月至2025年3月植入的184例语后聋成人(109例单耳、75例双耳)。
- 采用1:1倾向评分匹配(年龄、性别精确匹配、术前听力学主成分),匹配后120例(60例单耳、60例双耳)。
- 激活后3、6、12个月评估安静下言语识别,用线性混合效应模型分析纵向轨迹。
主要发现
- 匹配前双耳组基线更差但改善更陡、各时间点得分更高。
- 匹配后双耳组单音节词识别主效应显著(β=12.70,p=0.005),更严格匹配下结果平行(β=13.53,p=0.005)。
- 累积听觉经验强烈预测改善(两个样条项p<0.001),但组别×累积使用无显著交互。
- 术前得分×性别交互显著(β=14.49,p=0.021),术前表现对男性预后价值更高,且仅见于单音节词。
- 双音节词双耳效应较小但显著,句子呈同方向趋势;年龄组未显著修饰双耳效应。
关键数值与推荐
- 单音节词识别:双耳较单耳β=12.70,p=0.005;严格匹配下β=13.53,p=0.005。
- 术前得分×性别交互:β=14.49,p=0.021,仅见于单音节词。
- 累积听觉经验样条两项均p<0.001,组别×累积使用交互不显著。
临床怎么用
- 可为成人双耳人工耳蜗咨询提供证据,支持公共保险框架下扩大成人双侧植入覆盖的政策讨论。
- 安静下低上下文任务(单音节词)获益最明确,可用于术前 Counseling 与疗效预期沟通。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性设计,样本量有限(匹配后120例)。
- 需更大规模前瞻性队列与机制性终点确认获益的持久性、外推性与神经基础。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Evidence for a bilateral cochlear implant (BiCI) advantage in quiet is inconsistent, in part because many studies compare binaural versus acutely monaural conditions within BiCI users, which cannot model long-term unilateral (UniCI) adaptation. The authors asked whether BiCI confers a measurable benefit over UniCI for speech perception in quiet after rigorously controlling selection bias, and which patient factors modulate this benefit. DESIGN: Single-center retrospective cohort of 184 postlingually deafened adults (109 UniCI, 75 BiCI) implanted between February 2013 and March 2025. The authors performed 1:1 propensity-score matching (PSM) using age, sex (exact match), and principal component composites of preoperative audiology to yield 120 patients (60 UniCI, 60 BiCI) with excellent balance. Speech perception in quiet (mono-, di-syllable, sentence) was assessed at 3, 6, and 12 months after activation. Longitudinal trajectories were analyzed with linear mixed-effects models, with cumulative auditory experience (Average Daily Device Use × Months Post-Activation) modeled via restricted cubic splines. Prespecified interactions tested effect modification by sex, age group (20 to 50 versus 50 to 70), cumulative use, and preoperative performance. Sensitivity analyses used a stricter PSM caliper (0.1). RESULTS: Before matching, BiCI recipients-despite poorer baselines-improved more steeply and achieved higher scores across time points. After PSM, BiCI showed a significant main effect for monosyllabic word recognition ( β = 12.70, p = 0.005), with parallel results under stricter matching ( β = 13.53, p = 0.005). Cumulative auditory experience strongly predicted improvement (both spline terms p < 0.001), but there was no significant Group × Cumulative-use interaction, indicating comparable use-performance slopes in BiCI and UniCI. Thus, the BiCI advantage cannot be attributed to greater device use. A significant Preoperative Score × Sex interaction ( β = 14.49, p = 0.021) indicated that higher preoperative performance was more prognostic in males than females; this effect was specific to monosyllables. Disyllables showed a smaller yet significant BiCI effect; sentences trended in the same direction. Age group (20 to 50 versus 50 to 70) did not significantly modify the BiCI effect, and combining age groups was required to detect statistical significance, consistent with an age-independent bilateral benefit. CONCLUSIONS: In a rigorously matched cohort with longitudinal modeling, BiCI yielded a robust advantage over UniCI for quiet monosyllabic recognition that persisted after controlling for behavioral and demographic confounders. The absence of a Group × Use interaction and the pattern restricted to low-context tasks support an interpretation most consistent with neurophysiological mechanisms (e.g., binaural summation, interaural-timing integration, cortical-level plasticity), rather than motivational or selection-related artifacts. Because this advantage was not significantly modified by age, the data suggest that bilateral stimulation offers broadly preserved benefits across adult age ranges. These findings provide clinically actionable evidence to inform counseling and strengthen policy discussions on expanding adult coverage from unilateral to bilateral implantation under public insurance frameworks. Larger, prospective cohorts with mechanistic endpoints remain essential to confirm durability, generalizability, and neural underpinnings.
引用
- Nam DW, Yun JW, Park HR, et al. Age-Independent Bilateral Advantage in Quiet Speech Recognition: A Matched Longitudinal Analysis of Adult Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2026. PMID: 42244467. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001837
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。