文献速递耳科与耳神经小儿耳鼻咽喉

正常听力儿童、人工耳蜗儿童及声码器模拟者的语音感知与产出错误

Perception and Production Errors in Normal Hearing Children, Pediatric Cochlear Implant Users, and Children Listening to Vocoder Simulations.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2026-06-16

本研究比较20名5-9岁人工耳蜗(CI)儿童与两组听力年龄匹配的4-8岁正常听力儿童(NH,听自然语音;NHV,听九通道声码器模拟语音)在辅音感知与产出中的错误模式。结果显示CI与NH组平均错误率无显著差异,但NHV组感知错误率显著更高且高于其产出错误率;各组塞音错误少于擦音、清辅音错误少于浊辅音,但个别辅音错误模式存在差异。

要点

  • CI与NH儿童总体错误率相似,但个别辅音错误模式不同。
  • NHV组感知错误率显著高于NH和CI组,提示声码器模拟局限。
  • 所有组塞音错误少于擦音,清辅音错误少于浊辅音。

核心结论

  • CI与NH组总体错误率相似,但个别辅音错误模式可差异很大。
  • NHV组感知表现显著更差,提示声码器模拟可能无法完全反映CI使用的复杂性。

研究设计与样本

  • 三组对照研究:20名5-9岁CI儿童(3岁前植入),两组各20名4-8岁听力年龄匹配NH儿童,分别听自然语音(NH)或九通道声码器模拟语音(NHV)。
  • 采用改良版California辅音测试评估语音感知与产出能力。

主要发现

  • 所有组感知与产出呈中等相关,NHV组相关性略弱。
  • CI与NH组平均错误率无统计学显著差异;NHV组感知错误率显著高于NH和CI组。
  • NHV组感知错误率显著高于其产出错误率。
  • 所有组塞音错误少于擦音,清辅音错误少于浊辅音,组间存在一定变异。
  • 擦音/v/、/θ/、/z/在各组错误率最高;CI儿童常以[d]替代/ɡ/(NH儿童罕见),最常见产出错误为[f]替代/θ/;NH儿童常混淆/θ/与/f/或以[f]替代/v/。

临床怎么用

  • CI儿童干预应针对其观察到的特定辅音错误模式。
  • 临床应认识到声码器模拟的局限性,不宜完全等同于CI使用经验。

局限性

  • 需进一步研究以深入理解CI使用者感知与产出错误的相互作用,从而优化临床方案。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This study investigates the relationship between speech perception and production, focusing on consonant error patterns in children using cochlear implants (CIs), children with normal hearing (NH), and NH children listening to vocoder simulations (NHV). The goals were to determine how perception and production errors align within and across groups, to identify feature- and consonant-specific error patterns, and to assess the relative contributions of developmental constraints, signal degradation, and auditory experience. DESIGN: The study included three groups: 20 children with CIs, ages 5 to 9 years, implanted before the age of three; and two hearing-age-matched control groups of 20 children each, ages 4 to 8 years, presented with natural speech (NH) or listening to nine-channel tone vocoder simulations (NHV). To evaluate their speech perception and production abilities, participants were assessed using a modified version of the California Consonant Test. RESULTS: Relationships between perception and production: Moderate correlations were observed between perception and production across all groups, with slightly weaker correlations in the NHV group, supporting the interconnected nature of these processes. Error rates across groups: No statistically significant differences were observed in mean error rates between the CI and NH groups. However, the NHV group exhibited significantly poorer perception abilities, with higher error rates compared with both the NH and CI groups. NHV listeners also showed significantly higher error rates in perception than in production. This diminished perception in the NHV group likely reflects limited adaptation to the vocoder's degraded auditory signal. Error patterns across consonant features: All groups made fewer errors for stop consonants compared with fricatives in perception and production. In addition, all groups demonstrated fewer errors with voiceless consonants compared with voiced ones in perception and production, with some variability across groups. These results indicate that consonant features such as manner and voicing systematically influence performance. Individual consonant errors: The study revealed discrepancies between perception and production errors for individual consonants. Fricatives (e.g., /v/, /θ/, /z/) were associated with the highest error rates across groups. CI children frequently substituted [d] for /ɡ/, a rare pattern among NH children. Their most common production error was substituting [f] for /θ/, while NH children often confused /θ/ and /f/ or substituted [f] for /v/. These findings indicate that CI children's errors are more variable and sometimes atypical compared with NH peers, whereas NHV errors were broader and less systematic. CONCLUSIONS: The study's results emphasize that while overall error rates are similar between CI and NH groups, the error patterns for individual consonants can differ considerably. This indicates that interventions for children with CIs should focus on the specific error patterns observed. The poorer performance of the NHV group in perception underscores the limitations of vocoder simulations and suggests they may not fully capture the complexities of CI use. Clinical practices should incorporate these insights to develop more effective techniques tailored to the specific needs of children with CIs. Further research is needed to deepen our understanding of the interplay between perception and production errors in CI users to refine clinical protocols accordingly.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Peskova O, Thomas AL, Assmann PF, et al. Perception and Production Errors in Normal Hearing Children, Pediatric Cochlear Implant Users, and Children Listening to Vocoder Simulations. Ear Hear. 2026. PMID: 42301218. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001848

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。