非处方助听器预设集合大小的评估
结果显示,参与者在安静环境下显著偏好32个预设集合,且未对言语感知造成显著损害。
要点
- 老年OTC助听器用户安静下更偏好大型预设集合。
- 偏好预设与NAL-NL2的差异主要反映总增益不同。
- 大型预设集合未显著损害噪声下言语感知。
核心结论
- 包含用户偏好偏差的大型预设集合更受偏好,尤其在安静环境下,且未对言语感知造成显著损害。
研究设计与样本
- 采用受试者内设计,比较四种助听器预设集合:小型(4个)、中型(16个)、大型(32个)及个体化NAL-NL2目标。
- 预设基于大型听力图数据库的NAL-NL2真耳插入增益(REIG)目标(65 dB SPL输入)推导,大型集合还纳入经验性偏好偏差。
- 采用双败淘汰赛确定偏好设置,随后进行言语测试;使用Friedman和Conover检验分析偏好排名,线性混合效应模型评估言语接收阈值差异。
主要发现
- 安静环境下参与者显著偏好32个预设集合,49%将其排最高,44%将NAL-NL2排最后。
- 噪声下偏好趋势相似但变异性更大,偏好排名无统计学差异。
- 言语接收阈值在安静下各集合间略有差异,噪声下无差异。
- 有经验的助听器用户偏好更多增益,且更不倾向于偏好预设而非NAL-NL2。
- 当参与者偏好预设而非NAL-NL2时,差异主要反映总增益不同,而非频谱形状差异。
临床怎么用
- OTC助听器可考虑提供更多预设选项或至少允许用户调整预设,以提高偏好满意度。
- 对于有经验的助听器用户,需注意其可能偏好更多增益且不倾向于预设。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Over-the-counter (OTC) hearing aids are available as self-fitting and preset-based devices. Preset-based devices may be more accessible to older adults with limited technological literacy, but it is unclear whether users prefer settings from larger preset collections that incorporate individual preference deviations or if simpler collections based only on prescriptive targets are sufficient. This study investigated whether potential OTC hearing aid users prefer gain-frequency configurations from larger preset collections, and whether these preferences impact speech perception in quiet and noise. DESIGN: A within-subjects design was used to compare user preferences and speech perception outcomes across four hearing aid preset collections: small (4 presets), medium (16 presets), and large (32 presets) collections, as well as individualized NAL-NL2 targets. Presets were derived using NAL-NL2 real-ear insertion gain (REIG) targets for a 65 dB SPL input based on a large database of audiograms representing the OTC hearing aid market. The large (32) preset collection also incorporated empirically derived preference deviations away from prescription targets. A double-elimination tournament identified preferred settings, followed by speech testing. Forty-one older adults with mild-to-moderate sensorineural hearing loss matching OTC eligibility criteria participated. Participants listened to speech stimuli using presets delivered via a research hearing aid with eight-channel linear gain. Participants completed double-elimination style tournaments to determine their most preferred configuration in quiet and noise within each collection and overall. Preference rankings were analyzed using the Friedman and Conover tests. Speech reception thresholds were measured in quiet and noise. Linear mixed-effects models evaluated differences in speech reception thresholds, and regression analyses examined individual predictors of gain preferences and deviations from targets. RESULTS: Participants significantly preferred presets from the 32-preset collection in quiet, with 49% ranking it highest and 44% ranking NAL-NL2 last. Preferences in noise showed similar trends but were more variable, and preference ranks were not statistically different. Speech reception thresholds differed slightly across collections in quiet but not in noise. Experienced hearing aid users preferred more gain and were less likely to prefer presets over NAL-NL2. When participants preferred a preset over NAL-NL2, the difference between their preferred preset and NAL-NL2 primarily reflected differences in overall gain (more or less than NAL-NL2 prescription gain), rather than differences in the spectral shape of the configuration. CONCLUSIONS: Larger preset collections that incorporate user preference deviations away from prescription targets were more preferred, especially in quiet, without significant detriment to speech perception. Results suggest that users may prefer preset hearing aids with more preset options or at least the ability to adjust presets.
引用
- Jorgensen E, Kreul L, Werner M, et al. An Evaluation of Preset Collection Size in Over-the-Counter Hearing Aids. Ear Hear. 2026. PMID: 42168802. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001835
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。