早期声门癌经口激光显微手术后长期嗓音结局
该回顾性研究纳入102例经口激光显微手术(TLM)治疗的声门癌患者,随访中位5.2年,采用VHI-10、GRBAS及CSID评分评估嗓音。患者自评VHI-10中位7.5属正常范围,而客观与感知评估显示轻至中度发声障碍;CSID评分与声带切除类型及手术分期相关,I型切除与其他类型差异有统计学意义(Cohen's d>0.5)。
要点
- TLM后患者VHI-10自评多正常,客观评估却示轻至中度发声障碍。
- CSID评分与声带切除类型及手术分期相关。
- I型切除的嗓音结局与其他切除类型存在统计学差异。
核心结论
- TLM术后患者常自评VHI为正常,而客观与感知评估者认为嗓音存在轻至中度发声障碍。
- 这种较低的VHI评分可能与癌症幸存者效应有关。
- 了解TLM术后患者体验及手术范围对嗓音的影响有助于更好地进行术前咨询。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,分析TLM术后患者的嗓音结局(GRBAS、VHI-10、CSID评分)。
- 共纳入102例患者,男86例、女16例,中位年龄74岁。
- 中位随访时间5.2年。
主要发现
- 51例为I型切除,27例为Va型切除,其余接受II、III、IV、Vb、VI型及开放垂直喉半切除术。
- VHI-10中位评分7.5(正常<10)。
- CSID中位评分27.5(轻度=20-40)。
- GRBAS平均评分为G1.5、R1、B1、A0、S1.5(轻度=1,中度=2)。
- CSID评分与声带切除类型及手术分期存在相关性;I型ELR切除与其他所有类型的嗓音结局差异有统计学意义(Cohen's d值>0.5)。
关键数值与推荐
- VHI-10正常参考值为<10,本组中位7.5。
- CSID轻度范围为20-40,本组中位27.5。
- GRBAS轻度=1、中度=2,本组平均G1.5、R1、B1、A0、S1.5。
- I型切除与其他类型嗓音结局比较Cohen's d值>0.5。
临床怎么用
- 术前咨询时可告知患者:TLM后自评嗓音可能接近正常,但客观评估多显示轻至中度发声障碍。
- 应结合切除类型与手术分期预判嗓音结局,I型切除者嗓音结局相对更优。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性设计。
- 仅报告了嗓音评估数据与切除类型的相关性,未涉及其他可能影响嗓音的因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Survival after trans-oral laser microsurgery (TLM) for glottic carcinoma is excellent. However, the voice quality after TLM remains unclear. This study examines voice outcomes following different surgical procedures. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective study of voice outcomes (GRBAS, VHI-10, CSID scores) after TLM. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Patients undergoing TLM were studied. We collected the Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10), acoustic analysis (Cepstral Spectral Peak Prominence, CSPP score), and GRBAS rating score. These data were correlated with cancer stage and ELS (surgery type). RESULTS: We studied 102 patients (86 males, 16 females; median age 74). There were 51 type I and 27 type Va resections. The rest underwent types II, III, IV, Vb, VI, and open vertical hemilaryngectomy surgery. The median follow-up time was 5.2 years. The median VHI-10 score was 7.5 (normal < 10). The median CSID score was 27.5 (mild = 20-40). The Average GRBAS score was G1.5, R1, B1, A0, S1.5 (mild = 1, moderate = 2). There was a correlation between the CSID score and the type of cordectomy and surgical stage. There was a statistical difference in Type I ELR resection outcomes compared with all other types in voice outcome (Cohen's d-value > 0.5). CONCLUSIONS: Patients often rate their VHI as normal, while objective and perceptual raters rate voices after TLM as showing mild to moderate dysphonia. This low VHI score may be due to cancer survivorship. Understanding the patient experience after TLM surgery and knowing the extent of surgery on voice outcomes can help better counsel patients undergoing TLM.
引用
- Woo P, Nourmahnad A, Laitman BM, et al. Long-Term Voice Outcomes After Trans-Oral Resection of Early Glottis Carcinoma. Laryngoscope. 2026. PMID: 41982041. doi:10.1002/lary.70561
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。