年龄相关性听力损失的多频衰减模式:样条混合效应模型纵向分析
Objective: Based on longitudinal audiological data, this study explores the multifrequency dynamic decline patterns of age-related hearing loss (ARHL) to provide a theoretical foundation for early screening and intervention of ARHL.…
要点
- 各频率听阈随年龄非线性上升(P<0.001),高频组年龄效应系数显著高于低频组。
- 8000Hz听阈上升速率最高(1.10 dB/年),70~74岁达峰值1.39 dB/年,90~100岁降至0.56 dB/年。
核心结论
- 样条混合效应模型可精准解析ARHL多频非线性衰减特征。
- 各频率听力损失速率呈现「老年早期进展-中期加速-晚期趋缓」三阶段模式。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纵向听力学数据分析,纳入2009年1月至2025年5月解放军总医院耳鼻咽喉头颈外科门诊111例ARHL患者。
- 纳入标准:首次测听年龄≥50岁,无高强度噪声暴露史、中耳炎或突发性聋病史,双耳听力对称,至少2次间隔≥1年的纯音测听。
- 基于R语言构建样条混合效应模型,用自然样条基函数拟合各频率听阈随年龄的非线性效应。
主要发现
- 111例患者平均首次测听年龄(72.9±9.9)岁,随访2~17次,平均测听间隔(7.2±4.3)年,最长间隔14.9年。
- 8000Hz听阈上升速率最高(1.10 dB/年),70~74岁达峰值1.39 dB/年,90~100岁降至0.56 dB/年。
- 125Hz听阈上升速率从50~54岁的0 dB/年持续升至80~84岁的1.04 dB/年。
临床怎么用
- 理解「早期进展-中期加速-晚期趋缓」三阶段模式有助于制定分阶段干预策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: Based on longitudinal audiological data, this study explores the multifrequency dynamic decline patterns of age-related hearing loss (ARHL) to provide a theoretical foundation for early screening and intervention of ARHL. Methods: A total of 111 patients who visited the Otolaryngology Department of PLA General Hospital between January 2009 and May 2025 and underwent at least two pure-tone audiometry tests with an interval of no less than one year were included. The inclusion criteria were as follows: aged 50 years or older at the first test, no history of high noise exposure, otitis media, or sudden deafness, and symmetrical hearing in both ears. Their longitudinal audiological data were analyzed, and a spline mixed-effects model was constructed using R. Natural spline basis functions were employed to fit the nonlinear effects of hearing threshold shifts across frequencies with age, meanwhile, the growth rates of each frequency, age effect coefficients (β), and hearing threshold trends were calculated across frequencies, while calculating annual progression rates and age effect coefficients (β) for each frequency. Results: The average age at the first test was (72.9±9.9) years, with follow-ups ranging from 2 to 17 times and an average test interval of (7.2±4.3) years (maximum interval: 14.9 years). The model revealed: ① Hearing thresholds increased nonlinearly with age across all frequencies (P<0.001), with the high-frequency group (6 000, 8 000 Hz) showing significantly higher age effect coefficients than the low-frequency group (125, 250 Hz) (8 000 Hz basis function B2: β=72.21, t=7.46 vs. 500 Hz basis function B3: β=39.12, t=9.95). ② The coefficient of PTA (mean of 500, 1 000, 2 000, 4 000 Hz) basis function B2 (β=46.97) was lower than the full-frequency mean (β=51.24), and its dynamic changes were highly synchronized with 2 000 Hz. ③ The 8000 Hz frequency exhibited the highest hearing threshold increase rate (1.10 dB/year), peaking at 70-74 years (1.39 dB/year) and declining to 0.56 dB/year at 90-100 years. In contrast, the 125 Hz rate increased steadily from 0 dB/year at 50-54 years to 1.04 dB/year at 80-84 years. Conclusions: The spline mixed-effects model accurately delineates the multifrequency nonlinear decline characteristics of ARHL, revealing a three-stage pattern of hearing deterioration across frequencies: "early progression in the elderly, mid-term acceleration, and late-stage deceleration." The strong correlation between 2 000 Hz and PTA suggests its potential value as a screening indicator. 目的: 基于纵向听力学数据,探讨年龄相关性听力损失(age-related hearing loss,ARHL)的多频动态衰减模式,为ARHL的早期筛查与干预提供参考依据。 方法: 研究对象为2009年1月至2025年5月期间在中国人民解放军总医院耳鼻咽喉头颈外科门诊就诊并接受过至少2次间隔不少于1年的纯音测听检查的111例ARHL患者,其中男104例,女7例,年龄50~100岁。纳入标准包括:首次测听时年龄在50岁及以上,无高强度噪声暴露史,无中耳炎或突发性聋病史,双耳听力对称。对这111例ARHL患者的纵向听力学数据进行分析,基于R语言构建样条混合效应模型,通过自然样条基函数拟合各频率随年龄增长的非线性效应,同时计算各频率听力损失增长速率和年龄效应系数(β)以及各频率听阈变化趋势。 结果: 111例ARHL患者平均首次测听年龄为(72.9±9.9)岁,随访2~17次,平均测听间隔为(7.2±4.3)年,最长间隔14.9年。模型显示:①各频率听阈随年龄呈非线性上升(P值均<0.001),高频组(6 000、8 000 Hz)年龄效应系数显著高于低频组(125、250 Hz)(8 000 Hz基函数B2:β=72.21,t=7.46;500 Hz基函数B3:β=39.12,t=9.95);②500、1 000、2 000、4 000 Hz平均听阈(PTA)基函数B2系数(β=46.97)低于全频听阈均值(β=51.24),其动态变化与2 000 Hz高度同步;③8 000 Hz频率听阈上升速率最高(1.10 dB/年),70~74岁达峰值1.39 dB/年,90~100岁降至0.56 dB/年;125 Hz听阈上升速率从50~54岁的0 dB/年持续升至80~84岁的1.04 dB/年。 结论: 样条混合效应模型可精准解析ARHL的多频非线性衰减特征,揭示各频率听力损失速率呈现“老年早期进展-中期加速-晚期趋缓”的三阶段模式。2 000 Hz听阈与PTA高度相关,提示其可作为潜在的筛查指标。.
引用
- Han LM, Chen AT, Lou T, et al. [Multifrequency attenuation patterns in age-related hearing loss: a longitudinal analysis using spline mixed-effects models]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 41956765. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20250529-00299
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。