d/Deaf青少年及年轻成人的身份认同形成与影响因素:一项质性访谈研究
研究发现身份认同主要围绕「deaf与Deaf身份」及「积极身份形成」两大主题,受设备、语言、学校、家庭、朋友同伴、工作与热情、交叉性及d/Deaf社区影响;deaf身份不以听力身份定义,而是 embrace being deaf同时使用口语。强语言习得、家庭支持及d/Deaf社区联系与积极身份形成相关。
要点
- d/Deaf青少年身份认同包括deaf与Deaf两种构造,可并存且均感自豪。
- 强口语或手语习得、家庭支持及社区联系与积极身份形成相关。
- 临床与家庭应重视通过探索、语言和社区支持d/Deaf身份发展。
核心结论
- d/Deaf青少年及年轻成人积极探索身份认同,deaf既是描述听力水平的医学术语也是一种身份。
- 强语言习得(口语或手语)、家庭支持及d/Deaf社区联系与积极身份形成相关。
研究设计与样本
- 参与者由本机构听力学家招募及口口相传招募,一半访谈用英语、一半用美国手语(ASL)配翻译。
- 三名研究者建立编码本,采用归纳逻辑与扎根理论编码转录稿,并进行主题分析。
主要发现
- 身份认同核心主题围绕deaf与Deaf身份及积极身份形成两方面。
- 身份受设备、语言、学校、家庭、朋友与同伴、工作与热情、交叉性及d/Deaf社区影响。
- 许多参与者形成deaf或Deaf身份或两者兼有,deaf身份不以听力身份定义,而是 embrace being deaf同时使用口语。
- 认同文化性Deaf者通常使用ASL、感到与手语Deaf社区连接并就读寄宿学校。
- 强语言习得(口语和手语使用者)、家庭支持及d/Deaf社区联系与积极身份形成相关,deaf与Deaf身份者均感自豪。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生与家庭可更重视支持d/Deaf身份发展,通过探索、语言和社区促进积极身份形成。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study sought to use qualitative methods to better understand the identities and factors influencing identity in d/Deaf adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with diverse identities and communication methods. DESIGN: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with eighteen severely-to-profoundly d/Deaf AYAs (ages 14 to 25). Participants were recruited by audiologists at our institution and by word of mouth. Half of the interviews were conducted in English and half in American Sign Language (ASL) with an interpreter. Three researchers created a codebook and coded the transcripts using inductive logic and grounded theory. Thematic analysis was performed to identify overarching themes. RESULTS: Through our eighteen interviews and thematic analysis, we found a central theme of identity, primarily centered around (1) deaf versus Deaf identity and (2) positive identity formation. Both categories were influenced by devices, language, school, family, friends and peers, work and passions, intersectionality, and the d/Deaf community. Many participants formed a deaf or Deaf identity or both. In contrast to a paradigm of Deaf versus hearing identity, participants endorsed strong constructs of both Deaf and deaf identity. In this construct, being deaf is not defined by a hearing identity, but by embracing being deaf while using spoken language. Those identifying as culturally Deaf typically used ASL, felt connected to the signing Deaf community, and attended residential schools. The second aspect of identity was positive identity formation, defined as recognizing the benefits of being d/Deaf and being proud of being d/Deaf. We found that strong language acquisition for both spoken and signed language users, as well as family support and d/Deaf community connection, was associated with positive identity formation. Therefore, both those identifying as deaf and Deaf were proud to be d/Deaf. CONCLUSIONS: The AYAs we interviewed were curious about and often actively exploring their identities as a d/Deaf person, even those using spoken language, from hearing families, or with hearing devices. Our study confirmed that many of those using ASL and connected with the Deaf community identified proudly as Deaf. We also found that those with strong spoken language use and family support developed a deaf identity they were proud of. Therefore, in our study, deaf is both a medical term to describe hearing level and an identity. Given our participants' strong interest in identity, clinicians and families could place more emphasis on supporting the development of this d/Deaf identity and fostering positive identity formation through exploration, language, and community.
引用
- Yin S, Lin H, Yeh E, et al. Identity Formation and Influencing Factors in d/Deaf Adolescents and Young Adults: A Qualitative Interview Study. Ear Hear. 2026. PMID: 41881826. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001814
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。