语音材料、可懂度与掩蔽类型对人工耳蜗使用者瞳孔扩张反应的影响
研究纳入28名成人单侧或双模式人工耳蜗使用者,采用3×3被试内设计,考察3种可懂度条件与3种语音材料对瞳孔扩张反应的影响。主要分析(N=23)显示瞳孔指标随语音材料变化但不随可懂度变化;仅数字三元组分析(n=28)中可懂度影响峰值瞳孔扩张;干扰说话人掩蔽下峰值瞳孔扩张与主观聆听努力均高于连续噪声。
要点
- 人工耳蜗使用者日常句或CVC词下瞳孔扩张反应未随可懂度条件出现可测差异
- 仅数字三元组材料中可懂度条件对峰值瞳孔扩张有主效应
- 干扰说话人掩蔽较连续噪声提高峰值瞳孔扩张与主观聆听努力
核心结论
- 日常句或CVC词的可懂度条件未在单侧或双模式人工耳蜗使用者中引出瞳孔扩张反应的 measurable 差异。
- 仅数字三元组材料观察到可懂度条件对峰值瞳孔扩张的主效应。
- 干扰说话人掩蔽下峰值瞳孔扩张与主观聆听努力均高于连续噪声掩蔽。
研究设计与样本
- 28名语后聋成人单侧或双模式人工耳蜗使用者参与,年龄41至71岁(均值58.4)。
- 采用3×3被试内设计:3种可懂度条件(安静、连续噪声中50%与20%可懂度)×3种语音材料(数字三元组、辅音-元音-辅音词、日常句)。
- 用线性混合模型分析平均瞳孔扩张、峰值瞳孔扩张与基线瞳孔大小;用配对样本t检验比较掩蔽类型对50%句可懂度下瞳孔指标的影响。
主要发现
- 主要分析(N=23)中平均瞳孔扩张、峰值瞳孔扩张与基线瞳孔大小在语音材料间存在差异,但不依赖可懂度条件。
- CVC词引出的平均与峰值瞳孔扩张最低,数字三元组次之,日常句瞳孔反应最明显;日常句基线瞳孔大小大于CVC词与数字三元组。
- CVC词与日常句被评定为最费力、最困难、自感表现最低且放弃倾向最高;自感表现受可懂度影响(安静>50%>20%),其他主观评定随可懂度升高而下降。
- 数字三元组单独分析(n=28)显示可懂度条件对峰值瞳孔扩张有影响。
- 掩蔽类型分析(N=15)显示干扰说话人掩蔽下日常句的峰值瞳孔扩张与基线瞳孔大小均大于连续噪声。
临床怎么用
- 解读人工耳蜗使用者瞳孔测量结果时需考虑语音材料类型对瞳孔反应的影响。
- 数字三元组可能更易显现可懂度相关的瞳孔反应变化,日常句或CVC词下未见此效应。
- 掩蔽类型(干扰说话人 vs 连续噪声)可改变瞳孔扩张与主观聆听努力,评估聆听努力时应记录掩蔽条件。
局限性
- 主要分析样本为23名使用者,掩蔽类型分析样本为15名,样本量有限。
- 仅纳入语后聋成人单侧或双模式人工耳蜗使用者,结果外推需谨慎。
- 可懂度对瞳孔反应的影响仅在数字三元组中观察到,作者推测与该材料认知负荷较低有关。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The pupil dilation response is often used as a physiological measure of listening effort. One way to manipulate listening effort is to manipulate intelligibility. Only a few studies assessed the relationship between intelligibility and the pupil dilation response in cochlear implant (CI) users. Those studies did not consistently replicate the effects of intelligibility on the pupil dilation response evoked by sentence recognition in noise as observed in individuals with typical hearing or hard of hearing. Therefore, this study examined the effects of intelligibility on the pupil dilation response in CI users using several types of speech material. The type of masker is also known to influence listening effort as measured by pupillometry in individuals with typical hearing and hard of hearing. To our knowledge, this is not yet investigated in CI users. Therefore, this was also assessed in the current study. Finally, to account for subjective experiences, ratings of listening effort, difficulty, performance, and tendency of giving up were assessed. DESIGN: Twenty-eight postlingually deafened adult unilateral or bimodal CI users participated. Their ages ranged from 41 to 71 yrs old (mean = 58.4). A 3 × 3 within-subjects design was used with 3 intelligibility conditions (quiet, 50%, and 20% intelligibility in continuous noise) and 3 types of speech material (digit triplets, consonant-vowel-consonant [CVC] words, everyday sentences). Linear mixed model analyses assessed the effects of speech material and intelligibility condition on the mean pupil dilation (MPD), peak pupil dilation (PPD), and baseline pupil size (BPS). A paired sample t test was used to compare the effect of masker type (continuous noise versus a single interfering speaker) on these pupil measures for 50% sentence intelligibility. For all conditions, participants rated their experienced listening effort, difficulty, performance, and tendency of giving up. RESULTS: In the main analysis (N = 23), MPD, PPD, and BPS differed between the speech materials, but these measures did not depend on speech intelligibility. CVC words elicited the lowest MPDs and PPDs, followed by digit triplets and everyday sentences, with the latter showing the most pronounced pupil responses. The BPS was larger for sentences compared with CVC words and digit triplets. CVC words and sentences were rated as the most effortful and difficult, with the lowest self-perceived performance, and evoking the highest tendency to give up. Self-perceived performance was furthermore influenced by intelligibility (quiet > 50% > 20%). The other subjective ratings, such as listening effort, decreased with increasing intelligibility. A separate analysis on the data for the digit triplet material, including all CI users (n = 28), showed an intelligibility effect on the PPD. Finally, the analysis (N = 15) of the effect of masker type showed that PPDs and BPSs were larger for sentences masked with an interfering speaker compared with continuous noise. CONCLUSIONS: The intelligibility conditions in this study did not result in any measurable differences in listening effort, as indicated by the pupil dilation responses of unilateral or bimodal postlingually deafened CI users for everyday sentences or CVC words. A main effect of intelligibility condition on PPD was only found for digit triplets. Speculatively, this may be because the relative simplicity and low cognitive load evoked by this speech material allowed intelligibility effects to become apparent in this specific group of listeners. Subjective ratings indicated greater listening effort, difficulty, and a tendency to give up at lower intelligibility levels. When sentences were masked with an interfering speaker, both PPD and subjective listening effort increased compared with masking with continuous noise. These findings suggest that manipulating masker type can alter the pupil dilation response and perceived listening effort in CI users, even when using everyday sentences.
引用
- de Ruijter JHJ, Zekveld AA, Stronks HC, et al. The Influence of Speech Material, Intelligibility, and Masker Type on the Pupil Dilation Response in Cochlear Implant Users. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 41382329. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001761
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。