新型低成本开放获取3D打印喉显微手术训练器
研究开发了一种低成本、可重复使用的3D打印喉显微手术模拟器,可配合多种动物或人喉组织使用。在科罗拉多大学对医学生、耳鼻咽喉科住院医师和喉科医师进行模拟手术评估,参与者自评各项指标均高于4/5,专家盲评表现显著优于新手,提示该模拟器具有内容、表面和结构效度。
要点
- 该3D打印模拟器成本低、可重复使用,适配多种喉组织进行喉显微手术练习。
- 受训者模拟后操作信心平均评分从1.8/5升至3.0/5,自评教育价值等指标均高于4/5。
- 盲评显示专家手术表现显著优于新手,支持模拟器的结构效度。
核心结论
- 这种新型低成本3D打印手术训练器可成功用于喉显微手术练习,用户评分和盲评提示其具备内容、表面和结构效度。
研究设计与样本
- 通过计算机辅助设计、3D打印迭代原型开发模拟器,并在教育活动中反复使用以改进。
- 研究使用猪喉作为组织模型,参与者包括科罗拉多大学的医学生、耳鼻咽喉科住院医师和喉科医师。
主要发现
- 受训者对模拟体验的自我效能、逼真度、教育价值和教学质量的平均评分均高于4/5。
- 进行黏膜下微瓣手术的平均信心评分从模拟前的1.8/5提高到模拟后的3.0/5。
- 盲评手术操作显示,专家表现统计学上显著优于新手。
临床怎么用
- 该模拟器可用于耳鼻咽喉科受训者进行喉显微手术的反复练习,尤其适合资源有限环境下的技能培训。
局限性
- 证据等级为N/A,研究未报告样本量、具体统计值和置信区间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Otolaryngology trainees often have limited opportunities to practice microlaryngeal surgeries, so there is a need for high-quality simulation activities to aid in developing these skills. To address this gap, we created a low-cost, reusable, 3D-printed microlaryngeal simulator that can be used with various animal/human larynges to practice microlaryngeal surgery. METHODS: The simulator was developed through computer-aided design, iterative prototyping with 3D-printing, and repeated use in educational activities to guide improvements. Upon completion, a study was performed to evaluate educational value. Porcine larynges were used as a tissue model and study participants included medical students, otolaryngology residents, and laryngologists at the University of Colorado. Participants were instructed to raise a submucosal microflap on the vocal fold. Their simulated operations were video recorded and evaluated by a blinded reviewer to assess construct validity. Participants completed a Modified Michigan Standard Simulation Experience Scale Laryngeal Simulator Questionnaire and answered questions about their confidence performing the procedure to assess face and content validity. RESULTS: The average participant ratings for self-efficacy, fidelity, educational value, and teaching quality of the simulation experience were above 4/5 for the trainees The average confidence rating for performing microflap surgery increased from 1.8/5 before the simulation to 3.0/5 postsimulation. Experts performed statistically significantly better than novices as determined by blinded review of the procedures. CONCLUSIONS: This novel, low-cost, 3D-printed surgery trainer allows for the successful practice of microlaryngeal surgery. User-reported ratings and a blinded review suggest the simulator achieves content, face, and construct validity when used in simulated surgery. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: N/A.
引用
- Moore ET, Ambrose E, Lackey TG, et al. Novel Low-Cost Open-Access 3D Printed Microlaryngeal Surgery Trainer. Laryngoscope. 2025. PMID: 41186274. doi:10.1002/lary.70250
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。