听众因素与包络保真度关系的建模:跨越十年的汇总分析
该研究汇总四项研究共80例双侧轻至中重度感音神经性听力损失 listener 数据,采用分层Beta-Binomial模型分析言语识别与包络保真度的关系。结果证实包络保真度越高言语识别越好,工作记忆显著影响该关系,而年龄和听力损失程度无显著影响。提示需超越纯音听力图进行个体化干预。
要点
- 包络保真度越高,助听后言语识别越好。
- 工作记忆高者言语识别更优,尤其在包络保真度较差时。
- 年龄和四频率纯音平均听阈不影响包络保真度与言语识别的关系。
核心结论
- 助听后言语识别个体差异与工作记忆相关,年龄和听力损失程度无显著影响。
- 言语识别受背景噪声和助听器处理共同产生的累积包络保真度影响。
研究设计与样本
- 汇总四项已发表研究,纳入80例双侧轻至中重度感音神经性听力损失 listener,年龄49至92岁。
- 采用分层Beta-Binomial模型(贝叶斯框架)估计正确单词识别概率。
主要发现
- 包络保真度与言语识别呈强相关,包络保真度越高言语识别越好。
- 工作记忆对言语识别与包络保真度的关系有显著影响。
- 工作记忆较高者言语识别显著优于较低者,尤其在包络保真度较差时。
- 工作记忆较低者随包络保真度增加言语识别改善。
- 年龄和四频率纯音平均听阈对上述关系无显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 助听器验配需考虑工作记忆等认知因素,超越纯音听力图进行个体化处理。
- 包络保真度等听觉指标可能有助于临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: There is a large variability in speech intelligibility with hearing aids. This variability remains despite the current clinical approaches that provide individualized frequency-specific adjustments to gain in hearing aids. Much of this variability documented in the literature may also be due to differences across studies in terms of outcome measures, test conditions, etc. The objective of this study was to model sources of individual variability in speech intelligibility with hearing aids, in a pooled analysis across four distinct studies that used common methodologies and outcome measures. DESIGN: Deidentified data from 80 unique listeners with bilateral mild to moderately severe sensorineural hearing loss and aged 49 to 92 years were pooled from four published studies. A hierarchical Beta-Binomial (generalized linear mixed-effects) model was implemented to estimate the probability of correct word recognition in the pooled data using a Bayesian framework. Across studies, word recognition was measured for low-context sentences, in multi-talker babble, for a range of signal to noise ratios. Signals were processed through a hearing aid simulator or a wearable device and were customized to the listener's audiogram. Individual studies involved systematic manipulations of wide dynamic range compression, frequency lowering, or microphone directionality. Individual working memory ability was measured using the reading span test. A well-established auditory metric was used to quantify cumulative envelope fidelity (cepstral correlation) from background noise and the hearing aid processing for each listener. RESULTS: The model showed a strong relationship between speech intelligibility and envelope fidelity, confirming previous research findings that higher envelope fidelity was associated with better speech intelligibility. Among the sources of individual variability, working memory had a significant effect on the relationship between speech intelligibility and envelope fidelity. Listeners with higher working memory had significantly better word recognition than those with lower working memory, especially when envelope fidelity was worse. In addition, listeners with lower working memory had better word recognition as envelope fidelity increased. Age and degree of hearing loss (four-frequency pure-tone average) did not have a significant effect on the relationship between speech intelligibility and envelope fidelity. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis of the pooled dataset identified sources of individual variability in aided speech intelligibility, while also overcoming limitations of smaller sample sizes in prior research. The model supported the hypothesis that speech intelligibility is affected by the cumulative envelope fidelity arising from a combination of background noise and hearing aid processing. The study findings indicate that individual variability in speech intelligibility with hearing aid processing is related to working memory after accounting for age and degree of hearing loss. The study highlights the need for individualized treatment of hearing loss beyond the pure tone audiogram. Auditory metrics such as the envelope fidelity metric used in the study may be useful tools in clinical decision-making.
引用
- Rallapalli V, Crukley J, Lundberg E, et al. Modeling the Relationship Between Listener Factors and Envelope Fidelity: A Pooled Analysis Spanning a Decade. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 41177958. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001754
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。