每日使用电子烟对发声机制的影响:一项多模态研究
本研究比较了26名电子烟使用者(EC组;男10例、女16例)与39名非使用者(对照组;男10例、女29例)的嗓音、咳嗽和呼吸困难症状、空气动力学及喉部运动学。EC组在标准化问卷中报告的嗓音和咳嗽症状显著多于对照组,使用时间越长症状越重;EC组在/hi-hi/发声时声带内收速度显著更小,振幅商变异性及相位不对称性显著更低。结论认为这是每日使用电子烟对年轻成人产生负面影响的初步证据,但嗓音和咳嗽空气动力学未受影响。
要点
- EC组嗓音和咳嗽症状问卷评分显著高于对照组,使用时间越长症状越重。
- EC组在/hi-hi/发声时声带内收速度显著更小,振幅商变异性及相位不对称性显著更低。
- 嗓音和咳嗽空气动力学在两组间未受影响。
核心结论
- 本研究提供初步证据表明每日使用电子烟对年轻成人有负面影响,使用者报告更多嗓音/咳嗽症状及喉部运动学的细微变化,但嗓音和咳嗽空气动力学未受影响。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入26名电子烟使用者(EC组;男10例、女16例)和39名非使用者(对照组;男10例、女29例),完成标准化问卷、空气动力学测量及高速视频内窥镜下的喉部运动学评估,并进行回归分析。
主要发现
- EC组在标准化问卷中报告的嗓音和咳嗽症状显著多于对照组,使用时间更长与症状更重显著相关。
- 使用大麻也与更重的咳嗽症状相关。
- EC组在/hi-hi/发声时声带内收速度显著更小,振幅商变异性及相位不对称性显著更低。
- 嗓音和咳嗽空气动力学未受影响。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文结论称本研究提供的是初步证据。
- 原文指出未来研究应探讨使用时长和大麻使用等因素如何影响电子烟使用者的嗓音和咳嗽。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare self-reported voice, cough, and dyspnea symptom impacts, aerodynamics, and laryngeal kinematics in young adults who do and do not use electronic cigarettes. METHODS: A total of 26 electronic cigarette users (EC group; 10 male, 16 female) and 39 nonusers (control group; 10 male, 29 female) completed the study. Standardized questionnaires related to voice, dyspnea, and cough symptoms were completed. Aerodynamic measures of peak expiratory flow and volume for cough, subglottal pressure, and vital capacity were obtained. Laryngeal kinematics were evaluated during tasks of sustained /i:/ and /hi-hi/ from high-speed videoendoscopy. Comparisons between EC and controls were examined, and regression analyses were calculated to evaluate how characteristics of use (e.g., duration, frequency, co-use with marijuana) were related to outcome measures. RESULTS: The EC group reported significantly greater voice and cough symptoms on standardized questionnaires compared to controls, with a longer duration of use significantly related to greater symptoms. Use of marijuana was related to greater cough symptoms as well. The EC group also exhibited significantly smaller vocal fold adductory velocities during /hi-hi/ productions as well as significantly lower amplitude quotient variability and phase asymmetry. CONCLUSION: This study provides preliminary evidence of the negative effects of daily electronic cigarette use in young adults, with users reporting more voice/cough symptoms, along with subtle changes to laryngeal kinematics. However, voice and cough aerodynamics were not affected. Future studies should investigate how factors of duration and use of marijuana influence voice and cough in electronic cigarette users. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.
引用
- McKenna VS, Ling C, Llico AF, et al. Effects of Daily Electronic Cigarette Use on the Vocal Mechanism: A Multimodality Study. Laryngoscope. 2025. PMID: 40735904. doi:10.1002/lary.32469
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。