使用全景ECAP方法评估人工耳蜗使用者阵列类型差异
本研究使用全景电诱发复合动作电位方法(PECAP)评估不同电极阵列类型对电流扩散和神经反应性的影响,数据来自91耳Cochlear设备和53耳Advanced Bionics设备。结果显示,Cochlear设备中直阵列的电流扩散比预弯阵列更宽,而Advanced Bionics设备中未发现阵列类型效应。作者强调这是事后分析,不能证明因果关系。
要点
- Cochlear设备中,直阵列(Slim Straight)的整体电流扩散比预弯阵列(Contour Advance和Slim Modiolar)更宽,顶端效应最强。
- Advanced Bionics设备中,未发现阵列类型对PECAP电流扩散估计的显著效应(p=0.979)。
- PECAP电流扩散估计与电极-蜗轴距离显著相关(r=0.516,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 对于Cochlear设备使用者,预弯电极阵列在耳蜗内的电流扩散比侧壁电极阵列更窄,顶端效应最强;Advanced Bionics设备中未发现相应阵列类型效应。
- 作者强调这是事后分析,不能证明设备选择会导致特定神经兴奋模式的因果关系。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入91耳Cochlear设备使用者和53耳Advanced Bionics设备使用者,使用前向掩蔽伪迹减少技术在最舒适电平下收集ECAP。
- Cochlear使用者包括直阵列(Slim Straight,CI-22系列,n=35)和两种预弯阵列(Contour Advance,CI-12系列,n=43;Slim Modiolar,CI-32系列,n=13)。
- Advanced Bionics使用者包括直阵列(1J,n=9;SlimJ,n=20)和预弯阵列(Helix,n=4;Mid-Scala,n=20)。
- 其中41耳有CT扫描,计算了电极-蜗轴距离。
- 使用线性混合效应模型分析阵列类型和电极对PECAP估计的影响,并进行相关性分析。
主要发现
- Cochlear使用者中,阵列类型(p=0.001)和电极(p<0.001)对PECAP电流扩散估计有显著效应,且存在显著交互作用(p=0.006)。
- Slim Straight阵列的整体电流扩散比两种预弯阵列(Contour Advance和Slim Modiolar)更宽,交互作用显示顶端效应最强。
- PECAP电流扩散估计与电极-蜗轴距离在受试者间显著相关(r=0.516,p<0.001)。
- Advanced Bionics使用者中,未发现阵列类型对PECAP电流扩散估计的显著效应(p=0.979)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 作者强调这是事后分析,不能证明设备选择会导致特定神经兴奋模式的因果关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Cochlear implant companies manufacture devices with different electrode array types. Some arrays have a straight geometry designed for minimal neuronal trauma, while others are precurved and designed to position the electrodes closer to the cochlear neurons. Due to their differing geometries, it is possible that the arrays are not only positioned differently inside the cochlea but also produce different patterns of the spread of current and of neural excitation. The panoramic electrically evoked compound action potential method (PECAP) provides detailed estimates of peripheral neural responsiveness and current spread for individual patients along the length of the cochlea. These estimates were assessed as a function of electrode position and array type, providing a normative dataset useful for identifying unusual patterns in individual patients. DESIGN: ECAPs were collected from cochlear implant users using the forward-masking artifact-reduction technique for every combination of masker and probe electrode at the most comfortable level. Data were available for 91 ears using Cochlear devices, and 53 ears using Advanced Bionics devices. The Cochlear users had straight arrays (Slim Straight, CI-22 series, n = 35), or 1 of 2 precurved arrays (Contour Advance, CI-12 series, n = 43, or Slim Modiolar, CI-32 series, n = 13). Computed tomography scans were also available for 41 of them, and electrode-modiolus distances were calculated. The Advanced Bionics users had 1 of 2 straight arrays (1J, n = 9 or SlimJ, n = 20), or precurved arrays (Helix, n = 4 or Mid-Scala, n = 20). The ECAPs were submitted to the PECAP algorithm to estimate current spread and neural responsiveness along the length of the electrode array for each user. A linear mixed-effects model was used to determine whether there were statistically significant differences between different array types and/or for different electrodes, both for the PECAP estimates of current spread and neural responsiveness, as well as for the available electrode-modiolus distances. Correlations were also conducted between PECAP's estimate of current spread and the electrode-modiolus distances. RESULTS: For Cochlear users, significant effects of array type ( p = 0.001) and of electrode ( p < 0.001) were found on the PECAP's current-spread estimate, as well as a significant interaction ( p = 0.006). Slim Straight arrays had a wider overall current spread than both the precurved arrays (Contour Advance and Slim Modiolar). The interaction revealed the strongest effect at the apex. A significant correlation between PECAP's current-spread estimate and the electrode-modiolus distances was also found across subjects ( r = 0.516, p < 0.001). No effect of array type was found on PECAP's estimate of current spread for the Advanced Bionics users ( p = 0.979). CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that for users of the Cochlear device, precurved electrode arrays show narrower current spread within the cochlea than those with lateral-wall electrode arrays, with the strongest effect present at the apex. No corresponding effects of array type were found in the Advanced Bionics device. This could have implications for device selection in clinical settings, although the authors underscore that this is a post-hoc analysis and does not demonstrate a causal link wherein device selection can be expected to give rise to specific neural excitation patterns.
引用
- Garcia C, Carlyon RP. Assessing Array-Type Differences in Cochlear Implant Users Using the Panoramic ECAP Method. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 40400053. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001673
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。