在线言语噪声研究中主观与客观聆听准确性和努力度测量之间的关系
本研究通过在线平台对67名参与者(42名自报听力正常,25名自报有不同程度听力损失)进行言语噪声测试,使用BKB句子在-8至+20 dB信噪比下评估多项主客观指标。贝叶斯分析显示听力损失和年龄与言语噪声表现相关,主观聆听努力度对信噪比恶化最敏感,参与者尤其听力正常者常低估自身表现。
要点
- 听力损失者较正常听力者客观和主观可懂度更低、主观聆听努力度更高、言语反应时更长。
- 主观聆听努力度是随信噪比恶化最先出现敏感性的指标,其次为主观可懂度、客观可懂度、主观放弃倾听倾向,最后为言语反应时。
- 参与者尤其听力正常者持续低估自身表现。
核心结论
- 言语可懂度仍是首要测量指标,但仅在不利聆听条件下敏感,可能不能代表日常聆听。
- 在更具生态相关性的聆听条件下(一般为中等、正信噪比),聆听努力度成为充分描述聆听体验的关键因素。
- 言语反应时可能提供聆听努力度的有用客观标志,但需谨慎处理测量变异性、定义差异和年龄的潜在混杂效应。
研究设计与样本
- 在线言语噪声研究,使用Labvanced实验平台。
- 共67名参与者,其中42名自报听力正常,25名自报有不同程度听力损失。
- 参与者完成努力评估量表(每日生活聆听努力度的自报测量),随后进行BKB句子识别任务,句子在语音形状噪声中呈现,信噪比为-8、-4、0、+4、+8和+20 dB。
- 参与者通过摄像头录制复述内容,由2名研究助理独立评分。
- 数据采用贝叶斯统计方法分析。
主要发现
- 听力损失和年龄与言语噪声结局相关。
- 与正常听力者相比,听力损失者客观和主观可懂度更低、主观聆听努力度更高、言语反应时(开始言语反应的时间)更长。
- 与年轻者相比,年长者客观可懂度降低、言语反应时更长。
- 从高度有利到更不利的聆听条件变化时,主观聆听努力度最先对信噪比恶化显示敏感性,其次为主观可懂度、客观可懂度、主观放弃倾听倾向,最后为言语反应时。
- 参与者尤其听力正常者持续低估自身表现。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,言语可懂度仍是首要测量指标,但仅在不利聆听条件下敏感,可能不能代表日常聆听。
- 作者认为,在更具生态相关性的聆听条件下(一般为中等、正信噪比),聆听努力度成为充分描述聆听体验的关键因素。
- 作者认为,言语反应时可能提供聆听努力度的有用客观标志,但需谨慎处理测量变异性、定义差异和年龄的潜在混杂效应。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Speech-in-noise performance is of paramount importance to daily function, and there exists a bewildering array of outcome measures to capture the many dimensions of this concept. The aim of the present study was to provide insight into how different speech-in-noise outcome measures relate to one another, how they behave under different test conditions, and how researchers or practitioners might go about selecting an outcome measure (or measures) depending on the context and focus of their enquiry. DESIGN: An online speech-in-noise study was conducted using the Labvanced experimental platform. A total of 67 participants (42 who reported having normal hearing, 25 who said they had some degree of hearing loss) completed the Effort Assessment Scale (a self-reported measure of daily-life listening effort), followed by a sentence recognition task in which BKB sentences were presented in speech-shaped noise at signal to noise ratios (SNRs) of -8, -4, 0, +4, +8, and +20 dB. Participants were instructed to listen to each sentence and then repeat aloud what they heard. Responses were recorded through participants' webcams and later independently scored by 2 research assistants. Several outcome measures were used to tap into both accuracy and listening effort. Specifically, we examined: (1) objective intelligibility (percentage of keywords correctly repeated); (2) subjective intelligibility; (3) subjective listening effort; (4) subjective tendency to give up listening; and (5) verbal response time (VRT) extracted from the audio recordings. Data were analyzed using Bayesian statistical methods. RESULTS: Hearing loss and age were associated with speech-in-noise outcomes. Specifically, we observed lower intelligibility (objective and subjective), higher subjective listening effort, and longer VRT (time to verbal response onset) in hearing-impaired compared with normal-hearing listeners, and reduced objective intelligibility and longer VRT in older compared with younger listeners. When moving from highly favorable to more adverse listening conditions, subjective listening effort was the first measure to show sensitivity to worsening SNR, followed by subjective intelligibility, objective intelligibility, subjective tendency to give up listening, and, finally, VRT. Participants, especially those with normal hearing, consistently underestimated their own performance. CONCLUSIONS: The present findings offer useful insight into how different subjective and objective measures of listening accuracy and effort respond to variation in hearing status, age, and SNR. Although speech intelligibility remains a measure of primary importance, it is a sensitive measure only under adverse listening conditions, which may not be representative of everyday listening. Under more ecologically relevant listening conditions (generally speaking, at moderate, positive SNRs), listening effort becomes a crucial factor to consider to adequately describe the listening experience. VRT may provide a useful objective marker of listening effort, but caution is required to deal with measurement variability, differences in definition, and the potentially confounding effect of age.
引用
- Wiggins IM, Stacey JE, Naylor G, et al. Relationships Between Subjective and Objective Measures of Listening Accuracy and Effort in an Online Speech-in-Noise Study. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 40117131. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001662
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。