学龄期助听器儿童的声音情绪识别
该研究用非语言特异性伪言语音频测试55名双侧助听器学龄儿童(5.4至17.8岁)对快乐、悲伤和愤怒三种基本情绪的识别,并与86名同龄正常听力儿童及68名年轻成人比较。正常听力组识别能力随年龄改善并在约20岁达平台;助听器组虽随年龄改善但似乎滞后,约8岁起组间差异显著,个体数据中部分助听器儿童达年龄预期水平,且识别得分不能由未助听或助听听阈预测。
要点
- 正常听力者声音情绪识别持续发展至约20岁达平台。
- 助听器儿童组识别能力随年龄改善但似乎滞后,约8岁起与正常听力组差异显著。
- 部分助听器儿童达年龄预期水平,识别得分不能由听阈预测。
核心结论
- 助听器儿童作为一组声音情绪识别也随年龄发展,但似乎速度较慢。
- 个体数据显示部分助听器儿童声音情绪识别达年龄预期水平,提示助听器也可支持年龄典型的声音情绪识别发展。
- 识别得分低于年龄预期的儿童未发现可预测的听力相关因素,可能反映相关认知机制发展的固有变异,听力损失的累积效应也是一种可能。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用非语言特异性伪言语音频句子(表达快乐、悲伤和愤怒三种基本情绪)及儿童友好游戏化测试界面进行声音情绪识别测试。
- 测试组为55名双侧助听器学龄儿童(5.4至17.8岁),均为感音神经性听力损失,未根据听力损失程度或配置进一步排除。
- 对照组为86名年龄匹配正常听力儿童(6.0至17.1岁)和68名相对年轻成人(19.1至35.0岁),用于表征完整发展轨迹。
主要发现
- 正常听力儿童和成人对照组的声音情绪识别随年龄改善,并在约20岁达到平台。
- 助听器儿童的声音情绪识别也随年龄改善,但似乎滞后于正常听力儿童对照组。
- 组间比较显示约8岁起出现显著差异。
- 个体数据显示部分助听器儿童即使为重度听力损失也达年龄预期水平,而另一些得分低于年龄预期甚至处于机遇水平。
- 助听器儿童的识别得分不能由未助听或助听听阈预测,也不能由先前测量的语音线索辨别敏感性(如与平均音高或声道长度感知相关)预测。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: In individuals with normal hearing, vocal emotion recognition continues to develop over many years during childhood. In children with hearing loss, vocal emotion recognition may be affected by combined effects from loss of audibility due to elevated thresholds, suprathreshold distortions from hearing loss, and the compensatory features of hearing aids. These effects could be acute, affecting the perceived signal quality, or accumulated over time, affecting emotion recognition development. This study investigates if, and to what degree, children with hearing aids have difficulties in perceiving vocal emotions, beyond what would be expected from age-typical levels. DESIGN: We used a vocal emotion recognition test with non-language-specific pseudospeech audio sentences expressed in three basic emotions: happy, sad, and angry, along with a child-friendly gamified test interface. The test group consisted of 55 school-age children (5.4 to 17.8 years) with bilateral hearing aids, all with sensorineural hearing loss with no further exclusion based on hearing loss degree or configuration. For characterization of complete developmental trajectories, the control group with normal audiometric thresholds consisted of 86 age-matched children (6.0 to 17.1 years), and 68 relatively young adults (19.1 to 35.0 years). RESULTS: Vocal emotion recognition of the control group with normal-hearing children and adults improved across age and reached a plateau around age 20. Although vocal emotion recognition in children with hearing aids also improved with age, it seemed to lag compared with the control group of children with normal hearing. A group comparison showed a significant difference from around age 8 years. Individual data indicated that a number of hearing-aided children, even with severe degrees of hearing loss, performed at age-expected levels, while some others scored lower than age-expected levels, even at chance levels. The recognition scores of hearing-aided children were not predicted by unaided or aided hearing thresholds, nor by previously measured voice cue discrimination sensitivity, for example, related to mean pitch or vocal tract length perception. CONCLUSIONS: In line with previous literature, even in normal hearing, vocal emotion recognition develops over many years toward adulthood, likely due to interactions with linguistic and cognitive development. Given the long development period, any potential difficulties for vocal emotion recognition in children with hearing loss can only be identified with respect to what would be realistic based on their age. With such a comparison, we were able to show that, as a group, children with hearing aids also develop in vocal emotion recognition, however, seemingly at a slower pace. Individual data indicated a number of the hearing-aided children showed age-expected vocal emotion recognition. Hence, even though hearing aids have been developed and optimized for speech perception, these data indicate that hearing aids can also support age-typical development of vocal emotion recognition. For the children whose recognition scores were lower than age-expected levels, there were no predictive hearing-related factors. This could be potentially reflecting inherent variations related to development of relevant cognitive mechanisms, but a role from cumulative effects from hearing loss is also a possibility. As follow-up research, we plan to investigate if vocal emotion recognition will improve over time for these children.
引用
- Rachman L, Babaoğlu G, Özkişi Yazgan B, et al. Vocal Emotion Recognition in School-Age Children With Hearing Aids. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 40111426. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001645
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。