头颈癌局部区域失败试验富集的风险分层:UICC8与专用失败类型风险预测模型的比较
该研究在来自两家不同国家机构的756例患者中验证一个失败类型特异性风险模型,并比较其与UICC第7版和第8版分期对局部区域失败(LRF)的预测性能。模型3年LRF的AUC为65%,显著优于UICC7,但与UICC8无显著差异;模型与UICC8均识别出3年LRF约30%的高风险组,人群均值为18%。结论认为模型在组水平表现良好,UICC8分期表现相当。
要点
- 模型3年LRF的AUC为65%,显著优于UICC7,但与UICC8无显著差异。
- 模型与UICC8均识别出3年LRF约30%的高风险组,人群均值为18%。
- UICC从第7版到第8版在LRF预测上也有改善。
核心结论
- 模型在组水平上表现良好,UICC8分期表现相当。
- 尽管模型是为OS终点开发的,UICC从第7版到第8版在LRF预测上也有明显改善。
研究设计与样本
- 验证数据来自两家不同国家机构的756例患者。
- 通过Brier分数和AUC评估预测性能,并与UICC第7版和第8版分期比较判别性能。
主要发现
- 模型3年LRF的AUC为65%,显著优于UICC7分期,但与UICC8无显著差异。
- 基于模型的风险分层和UICC8均识别出3年LRF约30%的高风险患者组,人群均值为18%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A previously published failure-type specific risk model showed good performance in the original cohort. AIM: to validate the model and separate patients with high- and low-risk loco-regional failure (LRF). GOAL: to identify patients potentially suitable for treatment intensification trials. METHODS: Validation data: 756 patients from two institutions (different countries). Predictive performance was evaluated by Brier scores and AUCs. Discriminatory performance was compared to Union for International Cancer Control (UICC) staging (versions 7 and 8). RESULTS: The model's 3-year AUC for LRF was 65%, significantly better than UICC7 staging, but no significant difference to UICC8. Model-based risk stratification and UICC8 both identified high-risk patient groups with 3-year LRF ≈30%. The population mean was 18%. CONCLUSIONS: The model performed well on a group level. UICC8 staging performed equally well. Although developed for the endpoint of OS, an improvement from UICC version 7 to version 8 was evident also for the prediction of LRF.
引用
- Håkansson K, Muse DH, Bäck A, et al. Risk Stratification for Trial Enrichment Considering Loco-Regional Failure in Head and Neck Cancer: UICC8 Versus Purpose-Built Failure-Type Specific Risk Prediction Model. Head Neck. 2025. PMID: 39890609. doi:10.1002/hed.28085
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。