佩戴听力防护装置使我的工作表现更差:听力防护装置使用对感觉运动追踪表现的影响
两项实验让听者在街道噪声中听取坐标反应测量语料库命令并追踪移动目标,比较无听力防护装置与听力防护装置条件。两项实验中听力防护装置条件下追踪正确目标的时间更少,且差异在关键语句呈现时最明显。作者认为工人关于佩戴听力防护装置后表现更差的抱怨有依据,且影响超出听觉情境意识。
要点
- 两项实验中,听力防护装置条件下听者追踪正确目标的时间均少于无听力防护装置条件。
- 剔除目标未知时间点后,听力防护装置条件表现仍差于无听力防护装置条件。
- 追踪误差差异在坐标反应测量语句呈现期间最为明显。
核心结论
- 工人关于佩戴听力防护装置后表现更差的抱怨有依据,且影响超出听觉情境意识减退。
- 对非听觉方面工作表现的负面影响在关键聆听时段可能最强。
- 处理这些表现方面将是解决职业环境中听力防护装置不使用问题的重要部分。
研究设计与样本
- 两项实验,听者听取坐标反应测量语料库命令并在街道噪声背景中追踪屏幕上九个移动物体之一。
- 实验1用数字滤波器模拟被动听力防护装置的衰减特性来模拟佩戴听力防护装置。
- 实验2由听者实际佩戴听力防护装置。
- 连续记录追踪误差以同时检查听力防护装置对言语理解、追踪准确性的影响及追踪准确性随时间与 ongoing 听觉事件的变化。
主要发现
- 两项实验中,听力防护装置条件下听者追踪正确目标的时间均少于无听力防护装置条件。
- 剔除目标未知时间点后,听力防护装置条件表现差于无听力防护装置条件。
- 追踪误差的时间动态分析显示差异在坐标反应测量语句呈现期间强烈出现。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Occupational hearing loss is a significant problem worldwide despite the fact that it can be mitigated by the wearing of hearing protection devices (HPDs). When surveyed, workers frequently report that worsened work performance while wearing HPDs is one reason why they choose not to wear them. However, there have been few studies to supplement these subjective reports with objective measures. Where they do exist, assessed performance measures have mostly characterized auditory situational awareness in gross terms (e.g., average speech comprehension scores over an entire session). The temporal dynamics of performance and HPD impacts on nonauditory aspects of work performance are largely unknown. In the present study, we aimed to fill this gap in the literature by measuring how HPD usage impacted sensorimotor tracking performance in relation to ongoing auditory events. DESIGN: In two experiments, listeners heard commands sourced from the coordinate response measure (CRM) corpus (i.e., sentences of the form "Ready <call sign> go to <color> <number> now"). These commands informed listeners of which of nine moving on-screen objects to track with a computer mouse (e.g., "blue four" refers the listener to a blue square). The commands were presented in background street noise and were heard under either "No HPD" or "HPD" conditions. In experiment 1, HPD wearing was simulated with a digital filter designed to mimic the attenuation profile of a passive HPD. In experiment 2, actual HPDs were worn by listeners. Continuous recording of tracking error allowed us to simultaneously examine how HPD wearing impacted speech comprehension, the accuracy of tracking, and how tracking accuracy varied as a function of time on task and ongoing auditory events (e.g., the presentation of a critical CRM sentence). RESULTS: In both experiments, listeners spent less time tracking the correct object in the HPD condition. After trimming data to those time points in which the target object was known, worse performance was exhibited by the HPD condition than the No HPD condition. In the examination of the temporal dynamics of tracking error, it was apparent that differences arose strongly during the presentation of CRM sentences. CONCLUSIONS: Workers' complaints of poorer performance while wearing HPDs are justified and extend beyond just diminished auditory situational awareness. The negative impact on nonauditory aspects of work performance may be strongest around critical listening periods. Addressing these aspects of performance will be an important part of addressing HPD nonuse in occupational settings.
引用
- Wisniewski MG, Chuwonganant CS. Wearing Hearing Protection Makes Me Worse at My Job: Impacts of Hearing Protection Use on Sensorimotor Tracking Performance. Ear Hear. 2025. PMID: 39849312. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001630
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。