1型甲状软骨成形术结局的系统综述与Meta分析:Silastic与Gore-Tex比较
该系统综述与Meta分析比较了Silastic与Gore-Tex植入物在单侧声带不动中的结局。共纳入55篇文献,Silastic组41项研究1038例,Gore-Tex组13项研究245例。两组在最大发声时间和嗓音障碍指数上提供充分且可比的结果,但证据受随访、结局多样性、数据有限和发表偏倚限制。
要点
- Silastic组最大发声时间合并平均增加7.8秒(+1.3 SMD),Gore-Tex组为5.7秒(+1.6 SMD)。
- Silastic组嗓音障碍指数-30合并平均变化-45.4(62.2%,-2.09 SMD),Gore-Tex组为-51.6(73.5%,-1.1 SMD)。
- Silastic组嗓音障碍指数-10合并平均变化-15.6(54%,-0.46 SMD),Gore-Tex组为-11.6(43%,-0.86 SMD)。
核心结论
- Silastic与Gore-Tex植入物在1型甲状软骨成形术中提供充分且可比的结果。
- 支持该结论的数据受随访、结局多样性、数据有限和发表偏倚限制。
- 未来研究应致力于在良好随机化环境中比较植入物。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索PubMed、Embase和Web of Science。
- 共检索到1534条记录,最终纳入55篇文献。
- Silastic组41项独特研究共1038例患者。
- Gore-Tex组13项独特研究共245例患者。
主要发现
- Silastic组最大发声时间合并平均增加7.8秒(+1.3 SMD),Gore-Tex组为5.7秒(+1.6 SMD)。
- 最大发声时间的两项分析均存在显著发表偏倚。
- Silastic组嗓音障碍指数-30合并平均变化-45.4(62.2%,-2.09 SMD),Gore-Tex组为-51.6(73.5%,-1.1 SMD)。
- Silastic组嗓音障碍指数-10合并平均变化-15.6(54%,-0.46 SMD),Gore-Tex组为-11.6(43%,-0.86 SMD)。
- 嗓音障碍指数结局中无显著发表偏倚。
局限性
- 数据受随访限制。
- 结局存在多样性。
- 数据可得性有限。
- 最大发声时间的两项分析均存在显著发表偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Type 1 Thyroplasty is a well-established procedure used for medializing an immobile vocal fold. Silastic and Gore-Tex are the two most common materials used to accomplish this, but comparative data on their relative efficacy are scarce. We sought to compare outcomes between Silastic and Gore-Tex implants via systematic review and meta-analysis for unilateral vocal fold immobility. METHODS: We collected available data from PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science on demographics, maximum phonation time (MPT), voice handicap index (VHI-10/30) score, and any other relevant metrics encountered before comparatively evaluating differences in outcomes. RESULTS: The search yielded 1,534 records with 55 manuscripts ultimately included. There were 41 unique studies that utilized Silastic for a total of 1038 patients. There were 13 unique studies that utilized Gore-Tex for a total of 245 patients. The pooled mean increase in MPT for Silastic patients was 7.8 s (+1.3 SMD) compared with 5.7 s for Gore-Tex (+1.6 SMD). There was significant publication bias present in both analyses. The pooled mean change in VHI-30 with Silastic was -45.4 (62.2%, -2.09 SMD) compared with -51.6 (73.5%, -1.1 SMD) with Gore-Tex. The pooled mean change in VHI-10 with Silastic was -15.6 (54%, -0.46 SMD) compared with -11.6 (43%, -0.86 SMD) with Gore-Tex. There was no significant publication bias present in VHI outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Silicone and Gore-Tex implants provide adequate and comparable results in TT1. The data supporting this conclusion are limited by follow-up, diversity in outcomes, limited data availability, and publication bias. Future research should be dedicated to comparing implants in a well-randomized environment. Laryngoscope, 135:1236-1247, 2025.
引用
- Vance DG, Allen DZ, Leming AB, et al. Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Outcomes in Type 1 Thyroplasty Comparing Silastic to Gore-Tex. Laryngoscope. 2024. PMID: 39503469. doi:10.1002/lary.31867
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。