超过5%候选标准的成人单侧耳聋人工耳蜗植入者临床结局
本回顾性图表综述评估单中心27例单侧耳聋或不对称性听力损失成人人工耳蜗植入者,其中11例术前候选耳CNC词识别率超过5%标准。结果显示超过标准组与符合标准组在全部5项主要结局上均显著改善,两组术后得分及改善幅度无统计学显著差异。作者认为应考虑放宽候选标准,并需更大规模临床试验评估。
要点
- 超过5% CNC候选标准的单侧耳聋或不对称性听力损失患者植入人工耳蜗后仍显著获益。
- 超过标准组与符合标准组在术后各项测试得分及改善幅度上无统计学显著差异。
- 作者认为应考虑采用更宽松的单侧耳聋人工耳蜗候选标准。
核心结论
- 超过5% CNC术前候选标准的单侧耳聋和不对称性听力损失人工耳蜗植入者在单独使用人工耳蜗的言语感知、空间听觉和主观报告的生活质量结局上显著改善。
- 超过标准组观察到的获益与符合5%标准的单侧耳聋和不对称性听力损失人工耳蜗植入者无法区分。
- 作者认为应考虑更宽松的单侧耳聋和不对称性听力损失人工耳蜗候选标准,并有必要开展更大规模临床试验以更宽松的候选耳标准评估人工耳蜗疗效。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性图表综述,评估单个人工耳蜗中心的临床经验。
- 受试者为自2019年9月起植入且术后随访至少3个月的27例成人人工耳蜗植入者,其中单侧耳聋21例、不对称性听力损失6例。
- 排除修复手术或同时行迷路切除术与人工耳蜗植入的患者。
- 根据术前最佳助听条件下(耳背式助听器、声场中距前方扬声器0.9米、较好耳以插入式耳机给予45 dB HL言语加权噪声掩蔽)测量的CNC得分分为两组:MEETS组术前CNC词得分<5%,EXCEEDS组得分>5%。
- 临床方案包括在相同测试条件下使用AzBio句子的言语识别测试、使用定制7扬声器阵列的双耳空间测试(宽带噪声声源定位和空间分离噪声中的矩阵句子言语接收阈)以及人工耳蜗生活质量(CIQOL)量表。
主要发现
- 27例单侧耳聋人工耳蜗植入者中,11例术前CNC得分超过5%候选标准。
- MEETS组和EXCEEDS组在全部5项主要研究结局指标(单独人工耳蜗CNC和AzBio、双耳噪声下言语理解与声源定位、CIQOL)上均显著改善。
- MEETS组与EXCEEDS组之间唯一具有统计学显著差异的是EXCEEDS组术前CNC和AzBio得分显著更高,此为基于术前安静下言语感知得分分组的预期结果。
- MEETS组与EXCEEDS组在任何测试的术后得分或术前至术后评估的改善幅度上均无统计学显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 候选耳候选标准为词识别得分不优于5%。
- 传统人工耳蜗候选标准为最佳助听条件下言语识别得分50%至60%。
- 本中心单侧耳聋植入标准源自传统候选标准:候选耳CNC词识别得分50%。
- MEETS组定义为术前CNC词得分<5%,EXCEEDS组定义为得分>5%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应考虑更宽松的单侧耳聋和不对称性听力损失人工耳蜗候选标准。
- 作者认为有必要开展更大规模临床试验以更宽松的候选耳标准评估人工耳蜗疗效。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: While single-sided deafness cochlear implants (SSD-CIs) have now received regulatory approval in the United States, candidate-ear candidacy criteria (no better than 5% word-recognition score) are stricter than for traditional CI candidates (50 to 60% speech recognition, best-aided condition). SSD implantation in our center began before regulatory approval, using a criterion derived from traditional candidacy: 50% consonant-nucleus-consonant (CNC) word-identification score in the candidate ear. A retrospective analysis investigated whether SSD patients exceeding the 5% CNC criterion nevertheless benefitted from a CI as assessed by spatial-hearing tests (speech understanding in noise [SIN] and localization) and by a patient-reported outcome measure quality-of-life instrument validated for patients with CIs. DESIGN: A retrospective chart review assessed the clinical experience of a single CI center. Subjects consisted of 27 adult CI recipients with SSD (N = 21) or asymmetric hearing loss (AHL; N = 6) implanted since September 2019 with at least 3 months of postoperative follow-up. Patients with revision surgery or simultaneous labyrinthectomy and CI surgery were excluded from the sample. Subjects were divided into 2 groups based on preoperative CNC scores measured under best-aided conditions with a behind-the-ear hearing aid in the sound field at 0.9 m from a front loudspeaker, and the better ear masked using an insert earphone with 45 dB HL speech-weighted noise. The "MEETS" group had preoperative CNC word scores <5%; the "EXCEEDS" group had scores >5%. The clinical protocol also included intelligibility tests using AzBio sentences in the same test conditions as CNC; binaural spatial testing (broadband-noise sound localization, and matrix-sentence speech-reception thresholds in spatially separated noise) using a custom-built 7-speaker array; and the CI Quality of Life (CIQOL) instrument. To evaluate CI benefit, preoperative unaided performance was compared with postoperative binaural (acoustic ear + CI ear) performance at a clinic visit closest to 6 months postsurgery. RESULTS: Of 27 SSD-CI recipients, 11 subjects exceeded the 5% preoperative CNC candidacy criterion. Both the MEETS and EXCEEDS groups improved significantly on all 5 primary study outcome measures (CI-alone CNC and AzBio, binaural SIN and sound localization, and CIQOL). The only statistically significant differences observed between the MEETS and EXCEEDS groups were that preoperative CNC and AzBio scores were significantly higher for the EXCEEDS group, as expected given that the groups were defined based on preoperative speech-perception scores in quiet. There were no statistically significant differences between the MEETS and EXCEEDS groups in postoperative scores in any test or in the magnitude of the improvement from preoperative to postoperative assessment. CONCLUSIONS: SSD- and AHL-CI recipients exceeding the 5% CNC preoperative candidacy criterion significantly improved in CI-alone speech perception, spatial hearing, and subjectively reported CIQOL outcomes and the observed benefits were indistinguishable from SSD- and AHL-CI recipients who met the 5% criterion. A less-restrictive SSD-CI and AHL-CI candidacy criterion should be considered, and larger-scale clinical trials to evaluate CI efficacy using a less-stringent candidate-ear criterion are warranted.
引用
- Bernstein JGW, Pillion EM, Tolisano AM, et al. Clinical Outcomes for Adult Single-Sided Deafness Cochlear Implantees Exceeding the 5% Candidacy Criterion. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 39569999. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001578
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。