全国喉部激光手术趋势:手术室与诊室操作的比较
基于美国Medicare Part B理赔数据库2013—2022年数据,分析诊室喉部激光消融术(CPT 31572)与手术室直接喉镜切除术(CPT 31540、31541)的年度趋势。诊室激光手术量自2017年引入以来相对稳定(每年18887—25241例,趋势线斜率+16,R²=0.02),仅占全部喉部切除手术的8.4%—12.1%;而手术室切除手术量下降(31540斜率-132,R²=0.93;31541斜率-950,R²=0.93)。结论认为诊室激光手术占比较小且近年稳定,与向诊室操作发展的医疗趋势相反,需进一步研究手术室切除减少的原因。
要点
- 诊室激光手术量2017—2022年相对稳定,年范围18887—25241例,趋势线斜率+16,R²=0.02。
- 诊室激光手术仅占全部喉部切除手术的8.4%—12.1%。
- 手术室喉部切除手术量下降:CPT 31540趋势线斜率-132(R²=0.93),CPT 31541斜率-950(R²=0.93)。
核心结论
- 诊室激光手术仅占喉部病变切除手术的一小部分,且近5年数量相对稳定,与医疗操作向诊室转移的总体趋势形成对比。
- 需进一步研究以理解过去10年手术室喉部病变切除手术减少的原因。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国Medicare Part B理赔数据库2013—2022年的年度趋势分析,检索CPT代码31572、31540、31541和31545,记录每个日历年计费总次数并分析年度趋势,不纳入活检操作。
- 证据等级为4级。
主要发现
- 诊室激光手术(CPT 31572)自2017年引入以来年数量相对稳定,范围18887—25241例,趋势线斜率+16,R²=0.02。
- 诊室激光手术占全部喉部切除手术的比例范围为8.4%—12.1%。
- 手术室喉部切除手术(CPT 31540和31541)在研究期间下降,趋势线斜率分别为-132(R²=0.93)和-950(R²=0.93)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需进一步研究以理解过去10年手术室喉部病变切除手术减少的原因。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To analyze national trends in the prevalence of office-based laryngeal ablative procedures and compare those with traditional operative excisional procedures utilizing direct laryngoscopy. METHODOLOGY: For years 2013-2022, the US Medicare Part B claims database was searched for Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes 31572 (flexible laryngoscopy with laser ablation of lesion), 31540 (operative direct laryngoscopy with excision of lesion), 31541 (operative direct microlaryngoscopy with excision of lesion), and 31545 (operative direct microlaryngoscopy with excision of lesion and local tissue flap reconstruction). For each CPT code, the total number of charges billed to the Medicare database in each calendar year was recorded and annual trends were analyzed. Biopsy procedures were not included. RESULTS: The annual number of office-based laser procedures (CPT 31572) remained relatively constant since the CPT code was introduced in 2017 (range: 18887-25241 procedures annually, trendline slope = +16, R2:0.02). Office-based laser procedures comprised a small portion of total laryngeal excisional procedures (range: 8.4%-12.1%). The total number of operative laryngeal excisions, billed by CPT 31540 and 31541, declined over the studied time frame (Trendline slope = -132, R2:0.93; Trendline slope = -950, R2: 0.93 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Office-based laser procedures comprise a small fraction of procedures to remove laryngeal lesions. The number of office-based laser procedures has been relatively stable over the last 5 years. This finding contrasts with the prevailing health care trend toward office-based procedures. Further research is needed to understand the decrease in operative laryngeal lesion excision procedures observed over the last 10 years. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4 Laryngoscope, 135:823-828, 2025.
引用
- Scher M, Shave SM, Tracy JC, et al. National Trends in Laryngeal Laser Surgery: Comparison of Operative Versus Office-Based Procedures. Laryngoscope. 2024. PMID: 39422366. doi:10.1002/lary.31847
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。