文献速递耳科与耳神经

人工耳蜗评估过程中结局期望的变化

Changes in Outcomes Expectations During the Cochlear Implant Evaluation Process.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2024-10-02

这项前瞻性混合方法研究纳入32例接受人工耳蜗评估的成年患者,发现队列平均期望基本不变(d=0.01至0.17),但个体层面期望可被修改;高期望者评估后多数领域期望下降,低期望者仅环境评分从评估前到手术日升高(d=0.76);决策冲突总体较低(评估后平均11.4分,手术时14.2分,满分100)。

要点

  • 队列平均CIQOL期望评分在评估后基本不变(d=0.01至0.17),但个体期望可被修改。
  • 高期望者评估后在除情感和社会外所有CIQOL领域期望下降(d=-0.27至-0.77)。
  • 低期望者仅环境评分从评估前到手术日升高(d=0.76),总体决策冲突低。

核心结论

  • 研究结果提示,尽管队列总体平均期望基本不变,但个体参与者的术前期望可被修改,使用CIQOL-Expectations工具测量期望以判断其是否现实有价值。
  • 该信息可用于个体化咨询,更准确地呈现每位患者可能的人工耳蜗结局。
  • 潜在人工耳蜗候选者与现有用户讨论也可能提供有价值的信息以形成期望。
  • 使用CIQOL功能分期及相关临床情景描述沟通人工耳蜗获益,可能促成更现实的患者期望并支持共享决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性混合方法研究,纳入32例接受人工耳蜗评估的成年人工耳蜗患者。
  • 结局指标包括术前CIQOL-35 Profile评分、评估前/评估后/手术日CIQOL-Expectations评分、评估后/手术日决策冲突量表(DCS)评分及术前助听下CNC单词和AzBio句子评分。
  • 还对19例潜在人工耳蜗候选者进行关键知情人访谈的主题分析。

主要发现

  • 目标1:评估后CIQOL-Expectation领域评分在所有参与者平均后基本不变(d=0.01至0.17),但许多参与者在个体层面期望发生变化。
  • 目标2:评估前期望较高的参与者在评估后除情感和社会外所有CIQOL领域期望下降(d=-0.27至-0.77)。
  • 目标2:期望较低的参与者唯一显著变化是环境评分从评估前到手术日升高(d=0.76)。
  • 目标2:评估后至手术日期望基本不变或继续同向变化,缩小了高期望与低期望参与者之间的差距。
  • 目标2:参与者对决定进行人工耳蜗植入总体决策冲突低(评估后平均DCS 11.4分,手术时14.2分,满分100),但评估前期望较低的参与者DCS评分更高(d=0.71)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为使用CIQOL-Expectations工具测量术前期望以判断其是否现实有价值,该信息可用于个体化咨询。
  • 作者认为潜在人工耳蜗候选者与现有用户讨论可能提供有价值的信息以形成期望。
  • 作者认为使用CIQOL功能分期及相关临床情景沟通人工耳蜗获益可能促成更现实的患者期望并支持共享决策。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Patient expectations are a critical factor in determining cochlear implant (CI) candidacy. However, minimal data are available on how potential CI recipients develop their expectations and if expectations can be modified by providers. In addition, there is little insight into the resources patients use to inform their decision to undergo implantation. This project aims to assess (1) the role of the CI evaluation (CIE) process on patients' expectations, (2) the extent to which patients' pre-CI outcome expectations can be modified, (3) the information patients use to inform their expectations, and patients' preferences for the discussion/display of potential CI outcomes. DESIGN: Prospective mixed methods study of 32 adult CI patients undergoing CIEs. Outcome measures included: pre-CI Cochlear Implant Quality of Life-35 Profile scores (CIQOL-35 Profile); pre-CIE/post-CIE/day of surgery CIQOL-Expectations scores; post-CIE/day of surgery Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) scores; and pre-CI aided CNC-word and AzBio sentence scores. Thematic analyses of key informant interviews with 19 potential CI recipients were also performed. RESULTS: In aim 1, CI CIQOL-Expectation domain scores remained essentially unchanged following the CIE when averaged across all participants ( d = 0.01 to 0.17). However, changes in expectations were observed for many participants at the individual level. Regarding the second aim, participants with higher pre-CIE expectations showed a decrease in expectations following the CIE for all CIQOL domains except emotional and social ( d = -0.27 to -0.77). In contrast, the only significant change in participants with lower expectations was an increase in expectations in the environment score from pre-CIE to the day of surgery ( d = 0.76). Expectations remained essentially unchanged or continued to change in the same direction between the post-CIE and the day of surgery, narrowing the gap between participants with higher and lower expectations. Overall, participants demonstrated low overall conflict related to their decision to proceed with cochlear implantation (mean DCS of 11.4 post-CIE and 14.2 at time of surgery out of 100) but DCS scores were higher for participants with lower pre-CIE expectations ( d = 0.71). In aim 3, key informant interviews demonstrated no differences between the low- and high expectation cohorts regarding resources used to develop their perception of CI outcomes. Potential CI recipients placed high value in talking with patients who had previously received a CI, and preferred discussing CI functional abilities via clinical vignettes described in the CIQOL Functional Staging System rather than by discussing speech recognition or CIQOL-35 Profile scores. CONCLUSIONS: The results of the present study suggest that, although overall expectations averaged across the cohort remained essentially unchanged, individual participants' pre-CI expectations can be modified and there is value in measuring these expectations using the CIQOL-Expectations tool to determine if they are realistic. This information can then be utilized during personalized counseling to present a more accurate representation of likely CI outcomes for each patient. Discussions between potential CI recipients and current CI users may also provide valuable information to inform their expectations. In addition, communicating potential CI benefits using CIQOL functional stages and associated clinical vignettes may result in more realistic patient expectations and support shared decision-making related to CI surgery.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fabie JE, Shannon CM, Chidarala S, et al. Changes in Outcomes Expectations During the Cochlear Implant Evaluation Process. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 39360792. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001577

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。