文献速递耳科与耳神经小儿耳鼻咽喉

开发与初步验证用于测量医疗环境中听力损失污名的实施、感知与经历的量表

Development and Preliminary Validation of Scales to Measure Enacted, Perceived, and Experienced Hearing Loss Stigma in Health Care Settings.
PubMed 文献 · Ear Hear · 2024-09-19

本研究从污名测量文献中提取条目,改编并认知测试5名、预测试30名医疗服务提供者(HCP),随后通过在线调查招募204名美国基层医疗与听力保健专业人员,对4个d/Deaf及听力困难(d/DHH)污名HCP量表进行探索性因子分析,条目载荷满意,序数α介于0.854与0.944之间,为临床污名评估提供初步工具。

要点

  • 开发并初步验证4个HCP报告d/DHH污名量表:提供者感知污名、提供者实施污名、二手患者经历污名、二手患者感知污名。
  • 量表条目源自污名测量综合文献回顾,经5名HCP认知测试和30名HCP预测试后,在204名美国基层医疗与听力保健专业人员中验证。
  • 探索性因子分析显示条目载荷满意,序数α介于0.854与0.944之间。

核心结论

  • 本研究开发并初步验证的4个量表可帮助HCP更细致地理解d/DHH患者所经历和感知的污名及其在包括医疗环境在内的社会情境中的表现方式。
  • 在临床 encounters 中评估d/DHH污名形式及其与患者脱离和抗拒先进听力保健的关联,可能促成创新的污名减少干预,并可用本文量表评估后应用于临床实践。
  • 作者设想这些量表将进一步细化、改编并在包括基层医疗和听力保健在内的多种医疗情境中测试。

研究设计与样本

  • 量表条目从污名测量综合文献回顾中提取,条目题干和单个条目针对HCP改编,在5名HCP中进行认知测试,并在30名HCP中预测试。
  • 随后通过在线调查招募基层医疗提供者和听力保健专家(N=204)对4个量表进行验证,所有数据均在美国收集。

主要发现

  • 对4个拟议的d/DHH污名HCP量表进行探索性因子分析,量表条目载荷满意,序数α介于0.854与0.944之间。

关键数值与推荐

  • 提供者感知污名指HCP对社会中针对d/DHH个体的负面态度和刻板印象存在的感知。
  • 提供者实施污名指HCP自我报告在临床 encounters 中可能实施的细微或间接污名行为。
  • 二手患者经历污名指d/DHH患者在临床 encounters 中向HCP报告的外部污名行为。
  • 二手患者感知污名指d/DHH患者在临床 encounters 中向HCP报告的负面态度和刻板印象感知。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这些量表可为HCP提供机会,更细致地理解d/DHH患者经历和感知的污名及其在包括医疗环境在内的社会情境中的表现。
  • 作者认为评估临床 encounters 中d/DHH污名形式及其与患者脱离和抗拒先进听力保健的关联,可能促成创新的污名减少干预。
  • 作者设想这些量表将进一步细化、改编并在包括基层医疗和听力保健在内的多种医疗情境中测试。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Qualitative evidence suggests that stigma experienced by people who are d/Deaf and hard of hearing (d/DHH) can reduce willingness to engage with health services. Quantitative evidence remains lacking, however, about how health care providers (HCPs) perceive societal stigma toward people who are d/DHH, how HCPs might enact d/DHH stigma within provider-patient encounters, and what patients who are d/DHH share with providers about those patients' perceptions and experiences of stigma. Such quantitative evidence would allow HCPs to understand if and how stigma influences hearing health decisions made by people who are d/DHH. It could also shape practices to reduce d/DHH stigma within clinical encounters and guide providers in considering stigma as a driving force in their patients' hearing health care decisions. Building that evidence base requires validated quantitative measures. In response, the present study initiated an iterative process toward developing and preliminarily validating HCP self-report measures for different forms of d/DHH stigma. These measures draw upon HCPs' own perspectives, as well as their reports of secondhand information about stigma shared during clinical conversations. We developed and preliminary validated four measures: (1) provider-perceived stigma (HCPs' perceptions of the existence of negative attitudes and stereotypes toward d/DHH individuals in society), (2) provider-enacted stigma (self-reported subtle or indirect acts of stigma HCPs might commit during clinical encounters), (3) secondhand patient-experienced stigma (external acts of stigma reported to HCPs by patients who are d/DHH during clinical encounters), and (4) secondhand patient-perceived stigma (perceptions of negative attitudes and stereotypes reported to HCPs by patients who are d/DHH during clinical encounters). DESIGN: Scale items were extracted from a comprehensive literature review of stigma measures. Question stems and individual items were adapted for HCPs, cognitively tested on 5 HCPs, and pretested with 30 HCPs. The 4 scales were then validated on a sample of primary care providers and hearing care specialists (N = 204) recruited through an online survey. All data were collected in the United States. RESULTS: We conducted an exploratory factor analysis of the four proposed d/DHH stigma HCP stigma scales. Scale items loaded satisfactorily with ordinal alphas ranging between 0.854 and 0.944. CONCLUSIONS: The four measures developed and preliminarily validated in this study can provide opportunities for HCPs to develop a more nuanced understanding of stigma experienced and perceived by their patients who are d/DHH and how that stigma manifests across social contexts, including health care settings. Further, the ability to assess forms of d/DHH stigma in clinical encounters, as well as their association with patient disengagement and resistance to advanced hearing care, could lead to innovative stigma-reduction interventions. Such interventions could then be evaluated using the measures from this article and then applied to clinical practice. We envision these measures being further refined, adapted, and tested for a variety of health care contexts, including primary care settings where hearing difficulties may first be identified and in hearing health care settings where audiologic rehabilitation is initiated.

来源:Ear Hear,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Adams ET, Nyblade L, Madson G, et al. Development and Preliminary Validation of Scales to Measure Enacted, Perceived, and Experienced Hearing Loss Stigma in Health Care Settings. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 39294880. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001541

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。