在美国四类人群中初步验证经历性年龄歧视测量工具
本研究通过文献回顾、专家讨论和认知访谈改编四种年龄歧视测量工具,并在美国四类人群中以方便抽样在线自填问卷进行初步验证。对60岁以上后天失聪或听力困难者、其照护伙伴、医疗服务提供者和一般人群分别进行探索性因子分析和序数α信度估计,各量表条目载荷良好,部分量表信度高。作者认为这套初步验证的经历性年龄歧视测量工具可为后续更大规模、更多样化环境的研究提供起点。
要点
- 改编四种年龄歧视测量工具并在美国四类人群中初步验证。
- 60岁以上后天失聪或听力困难者中,社会污名与就业歧视两因子载荷均>0.7,中度相关0.428。
- 照护伙伴、一般人群和医疗服务提供者各提取单因子,载荷良好,前两者序数α分别为0.95和0.96。
核心结论
- 年龄歧视威胁高收入和低收入国家老年人的健康与福祉。
- 经过验证的年龄歧视测量工具对于理解年龄歧视、失聪或听力困难污名与老年人福祉之间的关系以及设计有效的年龄歧视减少和缓解干预措施是必要的。
- 这套初步验证的经历性年龄歧视测量工具为更多研究提供了起点,这些研究不仅进一步验证这些工具,而且规模更大、在更多样化的环境中进行,并提供对年龄歧视体验及其对老年人健康与福祉影响的见解。
研究设计与样本
- 通过文献回顾、专家讨论和认知访谈改编四种年龄歧视测量工具。
- 在美国通过自填在线问卷调查进行验证,使用方便样本,包括四类人群:60岁及以上在获得语言后或成年后失聪或听力困难者(后天性)、60岁及以上后天性失聪或听力困难者的照护伙伴、医疗服务提供者和一般人群。
- 对每个量表应用探索性因子分析,并以序数α估计量表信度。
主要发现
- 在60岁以上后天性失聪或听力困难者(N=146)中,九个社会污名条目和四个就业歧视条目分别良好载荷于两个独立因子,一个测量社会污名,一个测量就业歧视;所有载荷均>0.7;两因子中度相关,相关系数为0.428。
- 在60岁及以上后天性失聪或听力困难者的照护伙伴(N=72)中,九个条目良好载荷于单一因子,载荷在0.650至0.936之间,序数α为0.95。
- 在一般人群(N=312)中,十个条目清晰载荷于单一因子,载荷在0.702至0.919之间,序数α为0.96。
- 在医疗服务提供者(N=203)中,十一个条目良好载荷于单一因子,载荷在0.541至0.874之间。
- 在这三个人群中,每个单一因子均测量社会污名。
局限性
- 作者指出这套经历性年龄歧视测量工具仅为初步验证,需要更多研究进一步验证这些工具,且这些研究应规模更大、在更多样化的环境中进行。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Ageism appears widely across the globe and poses an important threat to older people's well-being and health. With respect to hearing health, experiences, perceptions, and fear of ageism can delay the diagnosis of hearing loss, reduce pursuit of hearing care, and fuel reluctance to wear a hearing device. Ageism intertwines with hearing loss stigma, which potentially deepens the negative effects of both; however, little evidence exists to quantify the effects of the intersection of ageism and hearing loss stigma. This lack of data on both hearing loss stigma and ageism, and their intersection, may stem from the lack of validated measures for both. Therefore, as part of a parent study to develop and preliminarily validate d/Deaf and hard of hearing stigma measures, we also adapted and preliminarily validated measures of both experienced and observed ageism. DESIGN: We adapted four ageism measures through a literature review, expert discussions, and cognitive interviews and validated them in the United States through self-administered online surveys with convenience samples of (1) people aged 60 and older who became d/Deaf or hard of hearing (d/DHH) after developing language or in adulthood ("acquired" d/DHH), (2) care partners of people aged 60 or older who are d/DHH (acquired), (3) health care providers, and (4) the general population. For each of the scales, we applied exploratory factor analysis and estimated scale reliability with ordinal α. RESULTS: For the population of persons over age 60 who are d/DHH (acquired) (N = 146), nine social stigma items and four employment discrimination items loaded well onto two separate factors, one which measures social stigma and one which measures employment discrimination. All loadings were >0.7. The two factors were moderately correlated at 0.428. For care partners of people aged 60 or older who are d/DHH (N = 72), nine items loaded well onto a single factor, with loadings between 0.650 and 0.936 and an ordinal α of 0.95. Among the general population (N = 312), 10 items loaded cleanly onto a single factor, with loadings between 0.702 and 0.919 and an ordinal α of 0.96. For the health care providers (N = 203), 11 items loaded well onto a single factor, with loadings between 0.541 and 0.874. For these three populations, each of the single factors measure social stigma. CONCLUSIONS: Ageism threatens the health and wellbeing of older people in both high- and low-income countries. Validated measures of ageism are necessary to understand the relationship between ageism, d/DHH stigma and the well-being of older adults and to design effective ageism-reduction and mitigation interventions. This preliminary validated set of experienced ageism measures offers a starting point for more studies that not only further validate these measures but are larger in scale, occur in more diverse settings, and provide insights into the experience of ageism and its effects on the health and well-being of older adults.
引用
- Nyblade L, Stelmach RD, West JS, et al. Preliminary Validation of Experienced Ageism Measures With Four Populations in the United States. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 39294882. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001475
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。