基于CiteSpace的突发性聋伴耳鸣文献计量学分析与思考
运用CiteSpace对2011—2021年中国知网、万方及Web of Science收录的突聋伴耳鸣相关文献进行分析,最终纳入中文文献74篇、英文文献16篇。耳鸣是突聋最常见的伴随症状,中文文献中64篇(86.5%)伴耳鸣,英文文献中15篇(93.8%)伴耳鸣;64篇提及耳鸣的中文文献中仅9篇提到耳鸣匹配检查。作者认为耳鸣匹配检查是有效评估手段,建立突聋诊疗体系或指南时应重视耳鸣症状及其不良心理反应的诊疗。
要点
- 耳鸣是突聋最常见的伴随症状,中文文献中64篇(86.5%)伴耳鸣,英文文献中15篇(93.8%)伴耳鸣。
- 64篇提及耳鸣的中文文献中仅9篇提到耳鸣匹配检查,1篇提到声治疗及心理辅导。
- 4种类型突聋伴耳鸣发生率由低到高为低中频82.4%、中高频90.7%、全聋型92.4%、平坦型92.8%。
核心结论
- 耳鸣是突聋最常见的伴随症状,耳鸣匹配检查是有效评估手段。
- 作者认为建立突聋诊疗体系或指南时应重视耳鸣症状及其不良心理反应的诊疗,以减少突聋康复后期耳鸣的发生率。
研究设计与样本
- 运用CiteSpace软件对2011—2021年中国知网、万方及Web of Science数据库收录的突聋伴耳鸣相关辅助检查和治疗文章进行分析总结。
- 共检索随机对照研究207篇,其中中文121篇、英文86篇,最终纳入中文文献74篇、英文文献16篇。
主要发现
- 74篇中文文献中伴随症状为耳鸣64篇(86.5%)、头晕/眩晕58篇(78.4%)、耳闷25篇(33.8%)、头痛10篇(13.5%)、失眠4篇(5.4%)、头晕耳鸣混杂4篇(5.4%)、呕吐2篇(2.7%)。
- 16篇英文文献中伴随症状为耳鸣15篇(93.8%)、眩晕12篇(75.0%)、耳闷1篇(6.3%)、各种症状混杂1篇(6.3%)。
- 64篇提及耳鸣的中文文献中仅9篇提到耳鸣匹配检查,1篇提到耳鸣伴随症状的治疗为声治疗及心理辅导。
- 4种类型突聋伴耳鸣发生率由低到高依次为低中频82.4%、中高频90.7%、全聋型92.4%、平坦型92.8%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为耳鸣匹配检查是有效评估手段,建立突聋诊疗体系或指南时应重视耳鸣症状及其不良心理反应的诊疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To explore the incidence of sudden deafness accompanied with tinnitus, the selection of examination protocols and treatment, and to provide reference for the establishment of new guidelines for sudden deafness. Methods: CiteSpace software was used for analysis and data mining to analyze and summarize the computer-retrieved articles on diagnostic examination and treatment of sudden deafness accompanied with tinnitus collected from CNIC, Wanfang and Web of Science databases from 2011 to 2021. Results: A total of 207 randomized controlled studies were retrieved in this study, including 121 in Chinese and 86 in English. Finally, 74 Chinese literatures and 16 English literatures were included. Among the 74 valid Chinese literatures, 64 (86.5%) were accompanied with tinnitus, 58 (78.4%) with dizziness/vertigo, 25 (33.8%) with aural fullness, 10 (13.5%) with headache, 4 (5.4%) with insomnia, 4 (5.4%) with a mixture of dizziness and tinnitus, and 2 (2.7%) with vomiting. Among the 16 English literatures, 15 (93.8%) were accompanied with tinnitus, 12 (75.0%) with vertigo, 1 (6.3%) with aural fullness, and 1 (6.3%) with a mixture of various symptoms. Among the 64 Chinese articles mentioning tinnitus, only 9 mentioned tinnitus matching tests, and 1 mentioned that the treatment for tinnitus accompanying symptoms was sound therapy and psychological counseling. The incidence rates of tinnitus accompanying four different types of sudden deafness, from low to high, are as follows: low-to-mid frequency, 82.4%; mid-to-high frequency, 90.7%; complete deafness, 92.4%; and flat type, 92.8%. Conclusion: Tinnitus is the most common accompanying symptom of sudden deafness, and tinnitus matching test is an effective evaluation method. When establishing a scientific, comprehensive, and systematic diagnosis and treatment system or guidelines for sudden deafness, attention should be paid to the diagnosis and treatment of tinnitus symptoms and their adverse psychological reactions, in order to reduce the incidence of tinnitus patients in the later stage of recovery from sudden deafness. 目的: 探讨突发性聋(突聋)伴耳鸣的发生率、检查方案选择及治疗,为临床建立完善的突聋新指南提供参考。 方法: 运用CiteSpace软件分析及数据挖掘,对计算机检索出的2011—2021年中国知网、万方以及Web of Science数据库收录的有关突聋伴耳鸣相关辅助检查和治疗的文章进行分析总结。 结果: 本研究共检索随机对照研究207篇,其中中文121篇,英文86篇;最终纳入中文文献74篇,英文文献16篇。74篇中文文献中,伴随症状为耳鸣的64篇(86.5%),头晕/眩晕58篇(78.4%),耳闷25篇(33.8%),头痛10篇(13.5%),失眠4篇(5.4%),头晕耳鸣混杂4篇(5.4%),呕吐2篇(2.7%);16篇英文文献中伴随症状为耳鸣的15篇(93.8%),眩晕12篇(75.0%),耳闷1篇(6.3%),各种症状混杂1篇(6.3%)。64篇提及耳鸣的中文文献中,仅9篇提到了耳鸣匹配检查;1篇提到耳鸣伴随症状的治疗为声治疗及心理辅导。4种不同类型突聋伴耳鸣发生率由低到高依次为:低中频82.4%,中高频90.7%,全聋型92.4%,平坦型92.8%。 结论: 耳鸣是突聋最常见的伴随症状,耳鸣匹配检查是有效评估手段。在建立科学、完善、全面、系统的突聋诊疗体系或指南的同时应重视耳鸣症状及其不良心理反应的诊疗,减少突聋康复后期耳鸣的发生率。.
引用
- Chen S, Zhang JN, Huo Y, et al. [Metrology analysis and thoughts of literatures on tinnitus associated with sudden deafness based on CiteSpace]. Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2024. PMID: 39107120. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20231023-00164
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。