喉癌手术后患者对治疗决策的反思
该研究基于德国16家医院的两组队列,纳入术前登记的780例喉癌手术患者并随访至术后1年,采用心理社会调整问卷评估对手术的态度。患者协会咨询与更积极态度相关(校正B=8.8;95%CI,1.0-16.6),全喉切除后大学学位者态度较不积极(校正B=-50.8;95%CI,-84.0至-17.6),部分喉切除中共同决策者态度最积极;作者认为术前个体化共同决策和患者协会咨询可能对决策后悔有积极影响。
要点
- 患者协会咨询与术后1年对喉癌手术更积极态度相关(校正B=8.8;95%CI,1.0-16.6)。
- 全喉切除后大学学位者态度较不积极(校正B=-50.8;95%CI,-84.0至-17.6),部分喉切除未见此关联。
- 部分喉切除中期望共同决策但未实现者后悔最明显(平均评分71[22])。
核心结论
- 多数头颈癌患者对手术持积极态度,提示决策后悔水平低;作者认为术前患者协会成员咨询及个体化共同决策可能对决策后悔有积极影响,并建议在日常实践中采用。
研究设计与样本
- 基于患者访谈与问卷的两组队列组合研究,在德国16家医院开展,计划接受喉癌手术者术前入组并随访至术后1年。
- 数据收集自2001年11月28日至2015年3月15日,统计分析自2023年8月21日至2024年1月19日。
- 共纳入780例患者,平均(SD)年龄60.6(10.4)岁,701例(90%)为男性。
主要发现
- 接受患者协会咨询者报告对手术更积极的态度(校正B=8.8;95%CI,1.0-16.6)。
- 全喉切除患者中,大学学位者对手术态度较不积极(校正B=-50.8;95%CI,-84.0至-17.6);部分喉切除患者中未观察到此结果(校正B=-4.8;95%CI,-15.1至5.4)。
- 部分喉切除患者中,对手术态度最积极者为经历共同决策者(无共同决策愿望者问卷平均[SD]评分84[20],有共同决策愿望者83[20])。
- 期望与医生共同决策但最终未经历者表达最多的手术后悔(平均[SD]评分71[22])。
- 对手术的态度与手术类型(全喉切除 vs 部分喉切除)及所有其他测试变量之间无关联。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为术前由患者协会成员咨询以及个体化共同决策可能对决策后悔有积极影响,并建议在日常实践中采用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Clinicians should understand how patients who were treated with laryngeal cancer surgery think about this later on and what factors may be related with regretting surgery. OBJECTIVE: To assess variables associated with a positive attitude toward laryngeal cancer surgery. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This combination of 2 cohorts, based on patient interviews and questionnaires, was studied in 16 hospitals in Germany. Participants scheduled for laryngeal cancer surgery were enrolled before surgery and followed up until 1 year after surgery. Data collection began on November 28, 2001, and ended on March 15, 2015. Statistical analysis was performed from August 21, 2023, to January 19, 2024. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The attitude toward surgery was measured with the Psychosocial Adjustment After Laryngectomy Questionnaire (scores range from 0 to 100, with high scores representing a positive attitude toward the surgery) at 1 year after surgery. In multivariate regression analysis, the following variables were investigated: type of surgery, number of surgeries to the larynx, receipt of radiotherapy and chemotherapy, quality of life, speech intelligibility (objectively measured), age, sex, educational level, employment status, having a partner or not, counseling by patient association, and shared decision-making. RESULTS: Patients (n = 780; mean [SD] age, 60.6 [10.4] years; 701 [90%] male) who had received counseling from the patient association reported a more positive attitude toward surgery (adjusted B = 8.8; 95% CI, 1.0-16.6). Among patients after total laryngectomy, those with a university degree had a less positive attitude toward their surgery (adjusted B = -50.8; 95% CI, -84.0 to -17.6); this result was not observed in patients after partial laryngectomy (adjusted B = -4.8; 95% CI, -15.1 to 5.4). Among patients after partial laryngectomy, the attitude toward surgery was most positive in those who had experienced shared decision-making (mean [SD] questionnaire score, 84 [20] in those without a wish and 83 [20] in those with a wish for shared decision-making). Those who had wished they could decide together with the physician but where this eventually was not experienced expressed the most regret toward surgery (mean [SD] score, 71 [22]). There was no association between attitudes toward surgery and type of surgery (total vs partial laryngectomy) and all other variables tested. CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCE: In this cohort study, most patients with head and neck cancer reported a positive attitude toward surgery, suggesting low levels of decision regret. Counseling by members of patient associations as well as individualized shared decision-making prior to surgery may have a positive impact on decision regret and is advisable in daily practice.
引用
- Singer S, Roick J, Gose A, et al. Patients' Reflections on Treatment Decision After Surgery for Laryngeal Cancer. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2024. PMID: 38935397. doi:10.1001/jamaoto.2024.1422
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。