从日常生活中的自我报告聆听体验预测个体助听器偏好
研究比较回顾性问卷(言语、空间与听觉质量量表[SSQ])与生态瞬时评估(EMA)收集真实聆听体验以预测助听器偏好的效用,40例轻至中度对称性感音神经性听力损失的有经验助听器使用者参与,两种方法均值差异预测偏好正确率分别为71.8%和72.5%,随机森林模型结合情境信息对单次EMA的预测准确率达93.8%。
要点
- SSQ仅49项中6项能显著区分偏好与非偏好助听器型号。
- EMA中与助听器声音感知相关的问题均与偏好显著关联,低信噪比及电视、交谈、音乐等聆听活动下关联最强。
- SSQ与EMA均值差异预测偏好正确率分别为71.8%和72.5%,随机森林模型结合情境信息对单次EMA预测准确率达93.8%。
核心结论
- SSQ与EMA在考虑均值差异时预测偏好效果相当,但EMA因重复测量特性具有高预后分类准确率,尤其结合声音环境情境信息时,适合个体化听力结局研究。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入40例轻至中度对称性感音神经性听力损失的有经验助听器使用者,完成SSQ问卷并在两个为期2周的佩戴期(两种主要降噪技术不同的助听器型号,佩戴顺序按型号随机化)重复进行EMA。
- EMA与自我报告聆听活动及助听器数据记录的声音环境参数关联,采用线性混合效应模型和五折交叉验证的随机森林模型分析。
主要发现
- SSQ的49个条目中仅6个能显著区分试验结束时偏好与非偏好助听器型号的应答。
- EMA中与助听器声音感知相关的问题均与偏好显著关联,且在低信噪比为主的声音环境及电视、人们交谈、非特异性聆听和音乐聆听相关聆听活动中关联最强。
- SSQ和EMA的聆听体验均值差异分别正确预测71.8%和72.5%的纳入参与者的偏好。
- 随机森林模型结合情境信息对单次EMA进行试验结束偏好预后分类的准确率达93.8%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The study compared the utility of two approaches for collecting real-world listening experiences to predict hearing-aid preference: a retrospective questionnaire (Speech, Spatial, and Qualities of Hearing Scale [SSQ]) and in-situ Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA). The rationale being that each approach likely provides different and yet complementary information. In addition, it was examined how self-reported listening activity and hearing-aid data-logging can augment EMAs for individualized and contextualized hearing outcome assessments. DESIGN: Experienced hearing-aid users (N = 40) with mild-to-moderate symmetrical sensorineural hearing loss completed the SSQ questionnaire and gave repeated EMAs for two wear periods of 2-weeks each with two different hearing-aid models that differed mainly in their noise reduction technology. The EMAs were linked to a self-reported listening activity and sound environment parameters (from hearing-aid data-logging) recorded at the time of EMA completion. Wear order was randomized by hearing-aid model. Linear mixed-effects models and Random Forest models with five-fold cross-validation were used to assess the statistical associations between listening experiences and end-of-trial preferences, and to evaluate how accurately EMAs predicted preference within individuals. RESULTS: Only 6 of the 49 SSQ items significantly discriminated between responses made for the end-of-trial preferred versus nonpreferred hearing-aid model. For the EMAs, questions related to perception of the sound from the hearing aids were all significantly associated with preference, and these associations were strongest in EMAs completed in sound environments with predominantly low SNR and listening activities related to television, people talking, nonspecific listening, and music listening. Mean differences in listening experiences from SSQ and EMA correctly predicted preference in 71.8% and 72.5% of included participants, respectively. However, a prognostic classification of single EMAs into end-of-trial preference with a Random Forest model achieved a 93.8% accuracy when contextual information was included. CONCLUSIONS: SSQ and EMA predicted preference equally well when considering mean differences, however, EMAs had a high prognostic classifications accuracy due to the repeated-measures nature, which make them ideal for individualized hearing outcome investigations, especially when responses are combined with contextual information about the sound environment.
引用
- Christensen JH, Rumley J, Gil-Carvajal JC, et al. Predicting Individual Hearing-Aid Preference From Self-Reported Listening Experiences in Daily Life. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 38783420. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001520
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。