大规模研究:听力损失的类型与程度和安静及噪声下言语识别的关系
该回顾性研究分析斯坦福耳科研究所5593例患者(51%女性,平均年龄57岁)的纯音测听、单耳安静下词识别(WRQ)和单耳QuickSIN数据,探讨传导性(CHL)、混合性(MHL)和感音神经性(SNHL)听力损失与言语识别的关系。结果显示CHL患者WRQ和QuickSIN表现与正常听力者相似;MHL或SNHL患者随听力损失加重,QuickSIN信噪比损失呈有序系统性下降,而WRQ在达到中重度或更差前保持优良。听阈仅能解释WRQ评分57%的方差和QuickSIN信噪比损失50%的方差。
要点
- CHL患者WRQ和QuickSIN表现与正常听力者相似,不受听力损失程度影响。
- MHL或SNHL患者随听力损失加重,QuickSIN信噪比损失呈有序系统性下降。
- 听阈仅解释WRQ评分57%的方差和QuickSIN信噪比损失50%的方差。
核心结论
- 在本数据集中,传导性听力损失对WRQ评分或QuickSIN信噪比损失影响很小。
- 对于MHL或SNHL患者,言语感知能力随听力损失严重程度增加而下降。
- QuickSIN信噪比损失在听力损失程度下显示出表现缺陷,而这些程度的听力损失下WRQ评分大致优良。
- 数据中的相当大的变异性表明,即使按听力损失类型分类患者,听阈仅解释言语感知能力方差的一部分,尤其是在噪声下。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,检查了在斯坦福耳科研究所接受听力学评估的5593例患者(51%女性)的数据。
- 所有个体完成纯音测听、单耳WRQ和单耳QuickSIN言语感知测试。
- 患者年龄范围为18至104岁(平均57岁)。
- 不同听力损失分类的平均年龄分别为:正常听力(NH)51.1岁、传导性听力损失(CHL)48.5岁、混合性听力损失(MHL)64.2岁、感音神经性听力损失(SNHL)68.5岁。
- 使用广义线性混合效应模型和四分位数回归确定听力损失类型和严重程度与不同言语识别结果指标的关系。
主要发现
- CHL患者在WRQ和QuickSIN上的表现与正常听力患者相似, regardless of the hearing loss severity。
- 在MHL或SNHL患者中,随着听力损失加重至中重度或更差,WRQ评分在很大程度上保持优良。
- 相比之下,QuickSIN信噪比损失随着听力损失程度变得更严重而显示有序的系统性下降。
- 这种效应随数据缩放,阈值-QuickSIN关系在CHL中不存在,在MHL中变得更强,在SNHL患者中最强。
- 数据中的变异性表明,听阈仅能解释WRQ评分57%的方差和QuickSIN信噪比损失50%的方差。
关键数值与推荐
- CHL患者WRQ和QuickSIN表现与正常听力患者相似, regardless of the hearing loss severity。
- MHL或SNHL患者WRQ评分在听力损失加重至中重度或更差前保持优良。
- QuickSIN信噪比损失随听力损失程度加重呈有序系统性下降,阈值-QuickSIN关系在CHL中不存在,MHL中更强,SNHL中最强。
- 听阈解释WRQ评分57%的方差和QuickSIN信噪比损失50%的方差。
- WRQ评分无法区分的患者可能通过SIN评分区分。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Understanding speech in noise (SIN) is the dominant complaint of individuals with hearing loss. For decades, the default test of speech perception in routine audiologic assessment has been monosyllabic word recognition in quiet (WRQ), which does not directly address patient concerns, leading some to advocate that measures of SIN should be integrated into routine practice. However, very little is known with regard to how SIN abilities are affected by different types of hearing loss. Here, we examine performance on clinical measures of WRQ and SIN in a large patient base consisting of a variety of hearing loss types, including conductive (CHL), mixed (MHL), and sensorineural (SNHL) losses. DESIGN: In a retrospective study, we examined data from 5593 patients (51% female) who underwent audiometric assessment at the Stanford Ear Institute. All individuals completed pure-tone audiometry, and speech perception testing of monaural WRQ, and monaural QuickSIN. Patient ages ranged from 18 to 104 years (average = 57). The average age in years for the different classifications of hearing loss was 51.1 (NH), 48.5 (CHL), 64.2 (MHL), and 68.5 (SNHL), respectively. Generalized linear mixed-effect models and quartile regression were used to determine the relationship between hearing loss type and severity for the different speech-recognition outcome measures. RESULTS: Patients with CHL had similar performance to patients with normal hearing on both WRQ and QuickSIN, regardless of the hearing loss severity. In patients with MHL or SNHL, WRQ scores remained largely excellent with increasing hearing loss until the loss was moderately severe or worse. In contrast, QuickSIN signal to noise ratio (SNR) losses showed an orderly systematic decrease as the degree of hearing loss became more severe. This effect scaled with the data, with threshold-QuickSIN relationships absent for CHL, and becoming increasingly stronger for MHL and strongest in patients with SNHL. However, the variability in these data suggests that only 57% of the variance in WRQ scores, and 50% of the variance in QuickSIN SNR losses, could be accounted for by the audiometric thresholds. Patients who would not be differentiated by WRQ scores are shown to be potentially differentiable by SIN scores. CONCLUSIONS: In this data set, conductive hearing loss had little effect on WRQ scores or QuickSIN SNR losses. However, for patients with MHL or SNHL, speech perception abilities decreased as the severity of the hearing loss increased. In these data, QuickSIN SNR losses showed deficits in performance with degrees of hearing loss that yielded largely excellent WRQ scores. However, the considerable variability in the data suggests that even after classifying patients according to their type of hearing loss, hearing thresholds only account for a portion of the variance in speech perception abilities, particularly in noise. These results are consistent with the idea that variables such as cochlear health and aging add explanatory power over audibility alone.
引用
- Smith ML, Winn MB, Fitzgerald MB, et al. A Large-Scale Study of the Relationship Between Degree and Type of Hearing Loss and Recognition of Speech in Quiet and Noise. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 38389129. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001484
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。