虚拟餐厅环境中信噪比、T60、宽动态范围压缩速度与数字降噪对言语清晰度的影响
本研究利用虚拟听觉空间技术模拟含6名空间化竞争说话人的餐厅环境,考察混响时间(0.8与1.8秒)、信噪比(-8.5至11.5 dB)、宽动态范围压缩(WDRC)速度与数字降噪(DNR)对言语清晰度的影响。结果显示WDRC×DNR×听力状态存在交互:快速WDRC时DNR有益,慢速WDRC时DNR有害;混响时间越低、信噪比越正,表现越好。
要点
- 快速WDRC时DNR改善言语清晰度,慢速WDRC时DNR损害言语清晰度。
- 混响时间越低、信噪比越正,言语清晰度表现越好。
- WDRC×DNR交互模式在听力正常与听障两组 listener 中均观察到了。
核心结论
- DNR在WDRC放大低强度信号前降低低幅度噪声,抵消了快速WDRC的一个潜在缺点,从而在本模拟中改善言语清晰度。
- 数据提示,在某些同时存在混响和噪声的真实环境中,当助听器采用快速压缩时间常数时,老年听障者激活DNR可能觉得言语更清晰。
- 需要额外研究来确定合适的DNR强度,并在可穿戴助听器和更广泛的聆听环境中确认结果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用虚拟听觉空间技术模拟小餐厅聆听环境,包含两名不同混响时间(0.8和1.8秒)及-8.5至11.5 dB信噪比范围。
- 纳入临床听力正常组以评估模拟效应在无听力损失复杂效应时的表现。
- 使用助听器模拟考察慢速与快速WDRC联合DNR有无对言语清晰度的影响,WDRC与DNR设置选为当前消费者可用助听器的合理估计。
- 环境中包含6名空间化竞争说话人以增强真实感。
主要发现
- 观察到WDRC×DNR×听力状态交互:快速WDRC时DNR对言语清晰度有益,慢速WDRC时DNR对言语清晰度有害。
- WDRC×DNR交互模式在两组 listener 中均观察到。
- 混响时间与信噪比存在显著主效应,表明混响时间越低、信噪比越正,表现越好。
局限性
- 需要额外研究来确定合适的DNR强度,并在可穿戴助听器和更广泛的聆听环境中确认结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Hearing aid processing in realistic listening environments is difficult to study effectively. Often the environment is unpredictable or unknown, such as in wearable aid trials with subjective report by the wearer. Some laboratory experiments create listening environments to exert tight experimental control, but those environments are often limited by physical space, a small number of sound sources, or room absorptive properties. Simulation techniques bridge this gap by providing greater experimental control over listening environments, effectively bringing aspects of the real-world into the laboratory. This project used simulation to study the effects of wide-dynamic range compression (WDRC) and digital noise reduction (DNR) on speech intelligibility in a reverberant environment with six spatialized competing talkers. The primary objective of this study was to determine the efficacy of WDRC and DNR in a complex listening environment using virtual auditory space techniques. DESIGN: Participants of greatest interest were listeners with hearing impairment. A group of listeners with clinically normal hearing was included to assess the effects of the simulation absent the complex effects of hearing loss. Virtual auditory space techniques were used to simulate a small restaurant listening environment with two different reverberation times (0.8 and 1.8 sec) in a range of signal to noise ratios (SNRs) (-8.5 to 11.5 dB SNR). Six spatialized competing talkers were included to further enhance realism. A hearing aid simulation was used to examine the degree to which speech intelligibility was affected by slow and fast WDRC in conjunction with the presence or absence of DNR. The WDRC and DNR settings were chosen to be reasonable estimates of hearing aids currently available to consumers. RESULTS: A WDRC × DNR × Hearing Status interaction was observed, such that DNR was beneficial for speech intelligibility when combined with fast WDRC speeds, but DNR was detrimental to speech intelligibility when WDRC speeds were slow. The pattern of the WDRC × DNR interaction was observed for both listener groups. Significant main effects of reverberation time and SNR were observed, indicating better performance with lower reverberation times and more positive SNR. CONCLUSIONS: DNR reduced low-amplitude noise before WDRC-amplified the low-intensity portions of the signal, negating one potential downside of fast WDRC and leading to an improvement in speech intelligibility in this simulation. These data suggest that, in some real-world environments that include both reverberation and noise, older listeners with hearing impairment may find speech to be more intelligible if DNR is activated when the hearing aid has fast compression time constants. Additional research is needed to determine the appropriate DNR strength and to confirm results in wearable hearing aids and a wider range of listening environments.
引用
- Ellis GM, Crukley J, Souza PE, et al. The Effects of Signal to Noise Ratio, T60 , Wide-Dynamic Range Compression Speed, and Digital Noise Reduction in a Virtual Restaurant Setting. Ear Hear. 2024. PMID: 38254265. doi:10.1097/AUD.0000000000001469
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。